Location: Wisconsin
Submitted 04/29/12 09:13 PM

Q. I am a seller with signed Offer to Purchase and earnest money ~ buyer requested access to fix some windows and said he'd let me know if he had financing in three weeks. He did not contact me and went ahead and did some renovations including tearing out carpets that he did not replace. We contacted him and he said "no financing" could we do a Contract for Deed...which we couldn't. Now he wants earnest money and payment for work and stuff he put into house and I'm left with a lot of undone work and I didn't ask for any work to be done. Also I was selling the house as is. He is suing...am I obligated and should I be suing him?

 

Answer #1
Submitted 05/24/12 09:54 AM
Frank Pabon Appleton Mortgage Appleton FHA Appleton Refinance 9206239242 (Hartford Financial Services - Wisconsin Mortgage Lender): Mortgage in Appleton, WI Frank Pabon Appleton Mortgage Appleton FHA Appleton Refinance 9206239242 (Hartford Financial Services - Wisconsin Mortgage Lender)
Mortgage
Appleton, WI

Contact Me

A.

I'm not an attorney but I do play one on TV. If the contract does not state any work done to be credited back to him - no issues. Sue all he wants, he won't get anything.                 

Answer #2
Submitted 05/24/12 10:06 AM
Richard Foster ABR/M, CREN, CRS, GRI, RRG, SFR (Elite Realty): Agent in Green Valley, NV Richard Foster ABR/M, CREN, CRS, GRI, RRG, SFR (Elite Realty)
Agent
Green Valley, NV

Contact Me

A.

The contract rules all. If the contact called for work, and for payment, and for the man-on-the-moon to do the other thing... That will guide. I would talk to an attorney TODAY. I would also recommend you talk to the broker of the agent that let you into this situation in the first place too. You need legal counsel.

 

Answer #3
Submitted 05/24/12 10:38 AM
Carla Muss-Jacobs - Principal Broker/ Owner | Buyers Broker | Buyers Agent EBA (503-810-7192 | BuyersAgentPortland.com): Broker Owner in Portland, OR Carla Muss-Jacobs - Principal Broker/ Owner | Buyers Broker | Buyers Agent EBA (503-810-7192 | BuyersAgentPortland.com)
Broker Owner
Portland, OR

Contact Me

A.

What I'm amazed at is this:  "he'd let me know if he had financing in three weeks."  I don't practice real estate in WI, but in my local market if a buyer didn't have financing in place . . . hmmmmmmm why would a seller give a "buyer" access to anything??  Did you have an agent?  Why would you allow a buyer who can't prove they can actually buy the property access?  So that's one point.  The other is, as the other two comments before mine, what does the contract read?  Seems to me the "buyer" (and I use the term loosely in this case since they, apparently, can NOT buy) took a huge risk by not securing financing in the first place, not knowing if he could purchase the property and then doing repairs?!?  OY VEY.  Were any of your represented?  I'd never allow my buyer clients to take the risk of doing repairs without knowing if they were able to purchase the property in the first place, but that's just me.  As far as refunding earnest money, depends on what the purchase agreement (contract) reads.  If the buyer is within his rights to revoke based on the fact he can not obtain financing (which is a provision in our real estate contracts, again, not sure what's in yours) then he would be entitled to his EM refund.  The repairs . . . are a separate issue, IMHO.  Talk to a GOOD real estate attorney.  If you don't have one, your Wisconsin Bar Association has a referral program.  Might be a good place to start.  My one word synopsis of this is: SLOPPY.  And I'm sorry that both buyer and seller are going through this. 

Sponsor

Disclaimer: ActiveRain does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any Ask a Real Estate Professional responses. All questions and responses are provided by ActiveRain Real Estate Network community members. You agree that any use you make of such responses is at your own risk and that ActiveRain is not responsible for any losses resulting from your reliance on any Ask a Real Estate Professional responses. Ask a Real Estate Professional responses should never be used as a substitute for advice from a qualified professional. By submitting a question to Ask a Real Estate Professional, you acknowledge that ActiveRain is not responsible for any response you receive or do not receive, and you agree to hold ActiveRain harmless from any loss, harm, injury or damage resulting from or arising out of your submission of the question or your use of or reliance on any response thereto.