If you represent yourself as a buyer in an Idaho short sale purchase, can you demand the bank pay you a commision?
First and foremost, the money you think you're saving by doing this is not worth it. These are complex transactions and having an experieced agent to help you navigate it is worth far more than you're going to save.
If you're not an agent, I would say it's highly unlikely you'll get the lender to give you the commission. This is probably an instance where representing yourself is not going to net you anything extra.
In a short sale situation, the lender is going to look at the HUD and in the section that details who the commission is going to, they are going to see only one brokerage listed. They will in all probability cut the listing agents fee significantly since both sides are being paid to one brokerage.
The lender does in fact take into account the commissions on a short sale. They take into account any fees that reduce the net below what they have determined to be acceptable. At that point they will start making cuts, and commissions are usually one of the first line items they go after.
Technically, the fees for a listing are an agreement between the listing agent and seller. The listing agent and seller agree in the listing contract what percentage or amount they are going to offer the selling agent. If you are representing the seller and are not a licensed agent, you are not a party to that contract and are not considered the selling agent.
Do you know how your are being represented in the purchase and sale agreement? If you let the listing agent fill out the purchase and sale agreement and used one of our association's forms you are most likely being represented as either a limited dual agent without an assigned agent or the brokerage is acting as a non agent on your behalf.
In this case the listing agent is also the selling agent.
Bottom line is demands usually fall on deaf ears with lenders in short sale situations. They are going to do what policy mandates.