According to one Florida mortgage banker they are.
I received an email from the Mortgage Bankers Association of Florida that contained a reprint of an editorial from the Miami Herald by Alex Sanchez. Who is Alex Sanchez? He is president and chief executive officer of the Florida Bankers Association.
According to the Florida banker's perspective, Florida mortgage brokers are Satan incarnate and are solely responsible for the sad shape in which the financial sector and housing in general finds itself.
Here are some of the misdeeds blamed on mortgage brokers by Mr. Sanchez in his editorial.
- "More than 80 brokers who were caught stealing from clients by siphoning funds from escrow accounts and issuing excessive fees were allowed to continue working in the industry."
- "Here-today-gone-tomorrow mortgage originators were in the practice of doing whatever needed to be done to close the loan. As we now see, some unscrupulous individuals working in the mortgage industry were willing to lie, cheat or steal just to seal the deal."
- "Banks, which are well capitalized (meaning they have required rainy-day funds) conduct a series of examinations to determine the credibility of a loan before its issuance, including verification of income, requiring a solid deposit and performing substantial credit checks. According to recent news articles, others peddled mortgages "that required no money down and minuscule payments for the first few years." Some even forged records like tax forms, account balances and income statements."
First I would like to correct Mr. Sanchez's understanding of Florida lending law.
Mortgage brokers cannot get near escrow money. They could not siphon off escrow funds if they wanted to because in no part of the transaction does a mortgage broker collect or have access to escrow funds.
Granted, some brokers have been caught in questionable and in some instance illegal practices. These people should be barred from any type of employment in our industry and prosecuted to the full extent of the law.
In fact, I doubt that you would find many in our industry that would not vote for special penalties for these people.
But, are bad brokers alone in this problem? No. Real estate agents, title agents, appraisers, bankers, builders and attorneys have all been guilty.
Unethical people from every sector have stepped up to take advantage of a system in disrepair. But for a banker to blame mortgage brokers for the mortgage problems we are facing that was in a large part created by the banks is nothing more than a smoke screen to hide the real problems in our industry, which is the greed of many bankers.
What sector created the no income, non-owner, high loan to value mortgage?
What sector threw out the window payment history, employment history, and assets, and used instead a credit score to make a lending decision?
What sector was responsible for overseeing the underwriting practices for these mortgages?
What sector pushed these products on mortgage brokers and offered them in some instances two times the normal compensation to deliver these loan products?
What sector threw principles of decisioning out the window for short term profits?
The answer is one that Mr. Sanchez will not want to face. It is squarely on the door step of our bankers.
Mortgage brokers do not have any money to lend. They are simply providing origination services for bankers.
I know Mr. Sanchez is going to continue to cry that broker fraud is the problem. The facts are different. If you remove all numbers of mortgage fraud, no matter what sector committed it, we would still have a major lending crisis because the lending practices of the majority of the banks involved in mortgage loan production were operating on automatic with no one watching the store.
They were asleep at the wheel. Blaming others for their lack of responsibility will not change that fact.
Shame on you Mr. Sanchez for not accepting your (industry's) fair share of the blame.
If you would like to read the complete message from Mr. Sanchez see this link.
http://www.miamiherald.com
If you would like to contact Mr. Sanchez directly to voice your opinion about his statements you can reach him at:
Alejandro “Alex” Sanchez
President
Florida Bankers Association
P.O. Box 1360
Tallahassee, FL 32302
850.224.2265
asanchez@floridabankers.com
www.floridabankers.com
I guess I could end this by saying that some of my best friends are bankers…