It appears that the Chinese drywall problem might now be a domestic problem as well. The following link is to a new article with claims about Synthetic Gypsum Drywall market by Georgia Pacific as GP Tough Rock. This product is made in the United States and Canada.

It was sold through 84 Lumber and produced by Georgia Pacific in the case that was filed in Florida. The action was filed Friday, April 24, in U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida, Ocala Division. The lead attorney for the plaintiff is Brian Warwick of the law firm of Varnell & Warwick in The Villages, Fla. Janet Varnell of that firm is a board member of the National Association of Consumer Advocates.

This is a brief summary of the complaint as found in the article written by Craig Webb is Editor of ProSales.

According to the suit, Michael Swidler--a builder who has worked 15 years for Lennar Homes, Eagle Homes, and Deluca Homes--ordered 289 sheets of GP ToughRock drywall from 84's Tavares, Fla., store in May 2006 to be used in building a house for his family. The Michael and Jill Swidler and their two children moved into the home in October 2006. 

In early 2007, "the plumbing fixtures and several silver picture frames in the plaintiffs' home started to corrode," the suit maintains. In January 2008, coils in the house's HVAC unit developed a leak. The coils were replaced, but in July 2008 they sprung another leak. The family's microwave quit working in April 2008 because a keypad stopped working properly, in August 2008 the Swidlers' year-old TV set died, and in February 2009 the dishwasher failed because copper wiring in the unit had deteriorated. 

"The smoke detectors in the plaintiffs' home randomly go off without cause, and the home has a strong sulfur odor throughout," the suit reads. "All the copper ground wires attached to every light-switch and outlet in the home have turned black and are rapidly oxidizing." And pieces of Jill Swidler's jewelry has turned black, it says. By mid-April 2009, the Swidlers moved out of the house. 

 I will try to findout more on this new entry into the toxic drywall fiasco.  It still appears that "Fly Ash" better known as Coal Ash is the main culprit.  Stay tuned for more information as it is discovered.  For right now I would just be careful when selling or inspecting a home that has been built in the past 7 or so years.  If you have any question or concern go with that "gut" feeling and bring in another set of eyes to help.

 

 

 
Post is included in group: Realtors®
Post is included in group: Professional Home Inspectors
Post is included in group: Independent Thinking Inspectors
Post is included in group: Home Inspectors across the country
Post is included in group: Ask the Home Inspector

9 Comments on Looks like Georgia Pacific has entered the Drywall Problem fiasco.

MAY
05
380,547 Points 23 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Ruh Roh-----will be interesting to see how this all plays out.  I wonder why there isn't more evidence of it?  It seems that in 3 years a lot more instances would have popped up.  Maybe it just isn't enough time for inspectors to have been through them since original purchase yet.

12:20pm • #1
129,754 Points 2 Featured Posts

Fly ash is being used in concrete as an additive. Just sat through a seminar by a large concrete manufacurer here in CT that was praising this stuff as Green. If fly ash is the culprit I wonder about it's use in concrete.

12:52pm • #2
MAY
11

Thanks Scott, I will keep an eye out for more info.

7:37pm • #3
MAY
12

I'm still trying to findout more about the GP drywall issue.  I contacted GP to no avail, they sent me to the PR department who then said they had not information on this.  So, if anyone comes across GP drywall problems, please let me know!!

4:38pm • #4
JUN
07

Synthetic gypsum is also called FGD gypsum. (Flue Gas Desulferization)  Large power plants inject a slurry of powdered limestone into the flue gas and it reacts with the sulfer and forms Gypsum (calcium sulfate). The solid gypsum is filtered out.  In most states the filtered material has to be sent to a hazardous waste land fill because of its contaminats, heavy metals, mercury, ash and any unburned fuel componants. 

That is unless it is "recycled".  Sold to a wallboard manufacturer, heated and ground, and put between two pieces of paper to be hung on our walls.  Natural gypsum is mined in the US, Canada and Mexico. It is the remnants of evaporated seas.  The large drywall manufactures have some plants that use synthetic gypsum and some that use natural.

 

George
9:37am • #5
JUN
08

Thanks for the information George.  The FGD has been used for years in drywall.  From what I have been able to tell the problems start when they start using fly ash.

10:01am • #6
AUG
10

The defective Chinese drywall debacle has been making news for months now, with homeowners plagued by sulfur fumes that smell like “rotten eggs” and cause air conditioning coils to corrode. Residents complain of sinus and respiratory ailments, eye and skin irritation, persistent runny or bloody noses, headaches, and asthma. Some situations were so severe that residents had to vacate their homes. In some cases, victims have been harassed by builders into signing unfair, one-side remediation agreements. The issues surrounding defective Chinese drywall are confusing and worrisome. Here is a good blog that has been providing emerging and valuable information on the problems: www.chinese-drywall-answers.com

 

Cynthia
9:40pm • #7
DEC
05

my house was built with georgia pacific drywall that was made in usa and canada,I know this becouse i've been ripping my walls down becouse ive been told by an inspector that I have chinese drywall.Well to make a long story short its not chinese drywall makeing me and my family sick and turning all the copper and brass black in my house it's GEORGIA PACIFIC DRYWALL that was made in the USA and Canada hopefully they will step up and take care of this problem 

ryan gilbert
7:41pm • #8
DEC
06

Leave a response…



(optional)
What does the graphic say?
 
Dscn0354 Rainmaker_large

Scott Patterson - Middle TN Home Inspector

Spring Hill, TN

More about me…

Trace Home Inspections

Address: Spring Hill, TN, 37174

Office Phone: (615) 302-1113

Cell Phone: (615) 870-4162

Email Me

Looking for an inspection or just some honest information from one of nations most respected inspectors, look no further!

MUDTRAP.COM

Scott Patterson's Facebook profile


Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find TN real estate agents and Spring Hill real estate on ActiveRain.