Special offer

True Real Estate Tax Relief Would Create Another Real Estate BOOM!

By
Real Estate Broker/Owner with Elite Legacy Realty Inc.

bombAt first there was talk in Florida about completely getting rid of real estate taxes for homesteaded properties while increasing our sales tax by a penny or two. Most people that I spoke to applauded the idea.  

 

Florida used to have some of the cheapest real estate taxes in the nation before the real estate boom hit. People from other states were coming down in droves to buy cheap real estate and enjoy cheap taxes. But now Florida real estate in most cases is no longer affordable, taxes have doubled or tripled, and our insurance rates are at astronomical rates. Florida's "snowbirds" are quickly realizing that they can no longer afford to retire here.

 

Currently I live in Windermere, Florida and my property taxes are about $7,800 a year, which is a bargain when you consider that Windermere residents who live in the 10 million dollar estates in the exclusive community of Isleworth pay about $200,000 a year in property taxes. So, if I didn't have to pay my property taxes, then I could definitely afford to send my kids to a local college. As for the Windermere residents that live in Isleworth, well, they could use the extra money to pay their country club dues for the year, or maybe they could buy another expensive toy, since I hear that living in Isleworth doesn't necessarily guarantee you membership in the country club.

 

So why would getting rid of real estate taxes create another boom? First, it would create a buying frenzy because many more buyers would qualify for a mortgage. This would stimulate the market and help get some of the buyers that are now sitting on the fence to start buying as well. This would make Florida once again the place to live by creating a chaing reaction where buyers would start coming into Florida to Buy, Buy, Buy! Sellers would Sell, Sell, Sell! Builders would Build, Build, Build! And Realtors would again make commissions! But best of all, retirees could once again afford to live here and not worry about real estate taxes eating up their retirement funds.

 

But the original plan is already falling apart. Our politicians are already changing it into everything other than what they promised Floridians when they were trying to get elected. It's not that most of us didn't see it coming; we just chose to believe that they would have some ethics, but who are we kidding, they're not Realtors®.

 

Hey, I know what, next time let's elect Realtors® instead of politicians and maybe we will have a more ethical government. You think?

Julie Chapman
Julie Chapman Broker - Ormond Beach, FL
Daytona Beach Shores, Florida

Glynn County Georgia's property taxes average about 1% of the sales price of the home paid annually and includes your garbage pick up.  One of the greatest things that Glynn County has implemented not only a homestead exemption for owner occupied, but also for retired, veterans, etc. 

There is a second tier of our homestead exception (referred to as Scarlett-Williams named after the legislators who wrote this bill)  that allows the property owner to hold their assessed value from the year they purchase the home the entire time they own it. (So many people can't afford their homes in later years due to increase and values and increase in taxes.) 

We are in grow so maybe that is what caused some of our real estate boom - it really attracts those retiring buyers who don't want to worry about increasing property taxes. 

May 25, 2007 01:15 PM
Tchaka Owen
Galleria International Realty - Hollywood, FL

Phil - the question I ask everytime someone pops up with the same old argument about eliminating property taxes is:  why not just reduce them significantly, instead of elimination?  But no one ever answers me.  I pose the same question to you.

- Tchaka 

May 26, 2007 10:21 AM
Janie Coffey
First Coast Sotheby’s International Realty - Ponte Vedra, FL
Uniting Extraordinary Homes w/ Extraordinary Lives
I can't wait!  I hope so.  Additionally another reason is that many sellers WANT to SELL and WANT to BUY a new home but they feel TRAPPED in their current home becuase the taxes are so low due to homesteading.  MANY many are in places that are either too small, too large or in some other way no longer fits their needs and maybe then it will help them move on. 
May 26, 2007 12:23 PM
Terry Haugen STAGE it RIGHT! 321-956-2495
Stage it Right! - Melbourne, FL

Oh gee the old property tax debate again.  Seems we are all waiting with baited breath for our elected legislature to make good on at least one campaign promise.  They won't!  I've said many times before, taxes were not an issue here until insurance went through the roof.  Does anyone hear about insurance reform here?  Of course not, the insurance industry bought and paid for our legislators, including governor Crist who realized in excess of 500k for his campaign from the insurance industry.  So the result will be a property tax cut, as currently proposed, enough for me to buy a pizza a week for 52 weeks, a budget cut in Brevard County of 93 million dollars, the cut back and elimination of many social programs, the lay offs of at least 100 county workers (me included), cutting library and park hours and on and on.  All this while the insurance companies are raking in billions in profits and not one of our elected officials is even talking about that.  I'd like to see the elimination, if necessary, of property taxes, the increase in sales tax, with food, medicine and clothing at a reduced sales tax rate so the poor amongst us are not paying for my property tax relief.  But what I'd really like to see is the insurance companies having to roll back their rates to pre-2004. 

Terry Haugen - STAGE it RIGHT!

May 26, 2007 01:45 PM
Jay Beckingham
Christensen Financial Mortgage - Port St Lucie, FL
Seniors ROCK!

if you eliminated taxes why do i feel that at some point they will reserface.

tchaka says lower taxes, may i add with fiscal responsibility i'm all for it.

if you keep SOH we must have some form of portability. 

BUT we need to stop talking about it and do something. 

May 26, 2007 02:25 PM
Tchaka Owen
Galleria International Realty - Hollywood, FL

Jay - for clarification, I say lower taxes instead of eliminating them.  There's all this talk of eliminating taxes but few address the need for the state and counties to have income.  And those that do only mention increasing the sales tax, which is regressive.  Like you, I agree that fiscal responsibility is needed.  Local govts are crying about the tax reduction but they were doing fine a few years ago when they made a fraction of what they do now.  

Julie - 2 things:  1) GA has state income tax, which FL doesn't.  2) I like the 2nd tier exemption you talk of and that's somewhat like the SOH that FL has.  The problem with that is that once rapid appreciation occurs, those who bought before are fine but those who buy afterwards pay massive taxes.  That's part of the whole problem here in FL.

- Tchaka 

 

May 26, 2007 02:37 PM
Phil Malhao
Elite Legacy Realty Inc. - Orlando, FL
Tchaka, I understand your point in reducing property taxes significantly rather than eliminating them. In fact there are many sides to this debate so lets look at them. The towns need taxes to function so that we can have our police, firehouses, services, etc. This of course can be taken care of by increasing our taxes on what we buy. While this is a fair way to spread the burden, it does also cause the poor to have to shoulder some of this cost. On the other side of the coin, homeowners that don't have children currently are paying taxes for schools that they do not use. Renters who contribute absolutely nothing to the system, are using all the services for free, while retirees are struggling to make ends meet. So where is the fairness in this system? So lowering the taxes does nothing to shift the burden evenly to those that pay nothing into the system that they now use for free. What do you think? 
May 29, 2007 04:48 AM
Phil Malhao
Elite Legacy Realty Inc. - Orlando, FL
Terry, you are absolutely right. I didn't address the insurance problem here in depth cause I figured that I could probably milk it on another blog. But since you brought it up. This is probably the biggest crisis that Florida is facing right now, and if we don't get a handle on it soon, we will be getting stigmatized by it.
May 29, 2007 04:57 AM