It seems like every day you read a different opinion on Duplicate Content. "Don't do it! Your site will get banned!" some people say. I would always get hammered with criticism when I would chime in and tell them that it's simply not true and that most people don't need to worry about duplicate content penalties. After all, if this was Google's policy, then I could just make a copy of my competitor's site and watch them get kicked out of Google.

Syndicating Content

Last week the Real Estate Institute of Queensland Australia contacted me asking permission to reprint one of my articles in their print and online magazine. Should I have said no fearing Google may send me in Search Engine "time out" (located on search results page 173)? No way! After all, not even Google could stop me from adding "Internationally Syndicated Columnist" to my resume! Yet I hear people all the time talking about how bad Article Syndication is. I've never understood why people would think Google looks down on articles that are good enough to be syndicated.

Straight From the Horse's Mouth

I take a very boring approach to SEO topics like this. I only recommend information that comes directly from the horse's mouth. So when Matt Cutts, one of Google's top web engineers was asked about Duplicate Content, my ears perked up! His reply was "Honest webmasters often worry about duplicate content when they don't need to"

It's Original! (If You Don't Include the other 132,999)

This is a great exercise. Open up Google and then copy and paste a snippet of home page text from almost any template website such as Advanced Access. Or you can just click this link for the search results. What you will find is 133,000 websites that contain the same content. What can we conclude from this?

  1. These real estate agents do not understand the important of differentiating themselves from other agents. (But that's another post for another day)
  2. Google still indexes pages that contain duplicate content

Copy and Paste is not the Answer

Please don't misinterpret this post. I am not saying that you should simply copy articles instead of writing original content. That's not the point at all. In fact, duplicate content just for the sake of duplicating content provides no value to search engines or to web visitors.

Nothing Beats The Original

Here is another practical example. I copy and pasted into Google a sentence from one of my articles on my website. Click here for the results. You will notice that that the exact same article shows up 3 times in Google's search results. (Google is suppressing the last result because it's similar to what's already displayed). Here is a breakdown of the results in the order they appear

  1. The first result links to my website where the original article appeared
  2. The second result shows another company that has flat out stolen my article. (Does anyone know a good lawyer?)
  3. The third result is from a debunk website that we never did finish (wow I really need to remove that site!)

Looking at the order of the results, it looks like Google nailed it. First place goes to the original source. Second place goes to a company so lazy that they have to steal my articles. And third place to a broken website that shouldn't be online.

Kiss My Ranking Goodbye!

If you still insist that Google penalizes sites for duplicate content, then I am about to commit SEO suicide. I will be posting this exact same article to my other blog. If you think I am crazy, it gets worse. In addition to duplicating the content, I am going to tell Google all about it. Here goes…

Hi Googlebot!

I know you are probably so smart that you don't even need me to tell you this, but this article is just a reprint. You can find the original article on my other blog. Please don't be mad at me for duplicating this content. Please don't condemn me to Google Hell. After all, I didn't try to trick you into thinking this was original content. I hope we can still be friends!

Thanks,

Brad

I personally think this is exactly the way Google would prefer it. I simply syndicated the blog post and disclosed the original location. To me, it would be worse to tried to "game the system" by swapping paragraphs, rewriting portions of the content, and altering the title to make search engines think it's an original document.

A few Disclaimers:
As I stated above, fresh and original content is still king! I do not recommend duplicating your blog post. The only reason why I am duplicating this post is to prove a point. As you have seen from the above example, Google is a very smart search engine and will credit to the original source.

Google still penalizes sites that blatantly duplicates (or mirrors) sites and content with the sole intention of exploiting the search engines. This and other "black hat" practices should NEVER be used to gain rankings.

Some of you may notice that this post has been classified as "Members Only". I am only doing this until Google "crawls" the original blog post. I want to ensure Google knows about the original document first before the search engine sees the duplicated version.

I look forward to your comments.

h2 { color:#356D9E!important; font-family:Trebuchet MS,Arial,Helvetica,sans-serif; font-size:20px!important; font-size-adjust:none; font-stretch:normal; font-style:normal; font-variant:normal; font-weight:normal; letter-spacing:0pt; line-height:24px; margin:9pt 0pt 0px; padding:6px 0pt 0px; } h3 { color:#356D9E!important; font-family:Trebuchet MS,Arial,Helvetica,sans-serif; font-size:20px!important; font-size-adjust:none; font-stretch:normal; font-style:normal; font-variant:normal; font-weight:normal; letter-spacing:0pt; line-height:24px; margin:9pt 0pt 0px; padding:6px 0pt 0px; } a { color:#356D9E; text-decoration:underline; } p{ margin-top:2px!important;} a:hover { color:#ffffff; text-decoration:none; background:#356D9E; border 1px solid #DDA603 }
 

50 Comments on Setting The Record Straight About Duplicate Content

JUN
05
2007
134,016 Points 25 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Nothing better than de-bunking the myths. I have a templeted site by Alamode. I had a fairly low page rank of 2 I believe after 2 years. I changed out all of my pages with origonal content.

I also got a brand new URl about 2 months ago. Still no ranking. Any ideas how to change that?

Interesting to me is if I go to Google and check my URl in quotes the first result that comes up is my url

portland real property . com / rose city blog  . My rose city blog was only started about 3 weeks ago.

Great Post by the way rates a 5'er

11:51pm • #1
464,040 Points 13 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
Brad I enjoyed reading your post.  This Google stuff is so confusing, so many opinions.  What you said made sense.
11:55pm • #2
JUN
06
2007
1 Featured Post
Brad - I'm just glad I don't understand all this stuff...only in the sense that I wouldn't know how to duplicate something if I tried!  But, it looks like I joined a good group to learn from so thank you.
12:04am • #3
2 Featured Posts

Great post again Brad.  I enjoy reading your stuff.  I really appreciate you sharing your knowledge. 

I sometime duplicate posts to active rain, especially localism, that are on my home blog site.  I have always worried about it...I guess I can stop. 

12:11am • #4
Very interesting post.  I had no idea stuff like this was being done.  I found your resuklts of the search even more interesting.  Glad to see the original articles win out!!!
12:14am • #6
248,073 Points 16 Featured Posts Outside Blog

you are correct.  i have seen lots of high ranking stuff that is duplicate content.

but, like you, i think it is utterly lacking in creativity and in poor taste, but that's another point.  lol

12:17am • #7
1 Featured Post Hit Router
I am so confused.  I am trying to be noticed by google, and I am about to just give up.  
12:24am • #8
348,033 Points Outside Blog

Always enjoy reading your material. Thanks for sharing.

Carolin Benjamin
Bob & Carolin Benjamin - The Benjamin Team
Keller Williams Integrity First Realty
Gold Canyon Arizona

12:45am • #10
161,840 Points 3 Featured Posts Outside Blog

This answers a lot of questions I had regarding search results. Thanks.

 

2:55am • #11
577,289 Points 95 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router
Brad, thanks for clarifying what I knew in my gut. There is a local agent in my area, that duplicated everything on her 2 blogs and still ranks high.
5:22am • #12
370,427 Points 62 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Thank you for the contribution. I had a  friend that just started blogging (blogger) and asked me about duplicate content.  I just emailed your blog to save me a whole bunch of typing.
5:49am • #13
257,389 Points 7 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Oh, man!  I was making duplicates of everyone's sites I didn't like - you mean to tell me they won't get banned?  Sigh...   :) Just kidding.

This is good information, I have a couple of different sites going and like to use similar content. 

1:01pm • #14
135,825 Points 15 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Brad - Thanks for the information. 
8:32pm • #16
JUN
07
2007
10 Featured Posts

I knew I should have talked about dup content on my blog. Glad to see you covered it in your usual fine fashion!

Great job!

11:47am • #17
JUN
08
2007

Brad

Thanks for clarifying an issue that I've been confused about since joining AR

7:20am • #18
JUN
11
2007
257,389 Points 7 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
Is there any advantage to doing "mirror" sites?  I had a blog of my own that's fallen by the wayside as I built up my AR blog, which is now my default.  Should I keep it up and copy the posts over?
7:00pm • #19
13 Featured Posts
Jeff, No avoid mirror sites! Google doesn't mind a few of the same articles, but they think you are trying to "game the system" if you start mirroring entire websites.
9:47pm • #20
JUN
13
2007
257,389 Points 7 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Thanks, Brad.  I just got this info elsewhere simultaneously - must be important!

Would a blogger blog and AR with similar but not identical posts be considered mirroring? 

11:45am • #21
105,709 Points

Thanks, Brad.  I enjoy your insightful posts.

I also saw recently where one person will post an original blog, then at other sites post an abbreviated version, directing the interested reader to the original blog for the full version.  Any pros or cons with that way of doing it?

Best of success!

2:58pm • #22
107,233 Points 3 Featured Posts
Brad what you say in your post is great.  There are some realtors I know who have advanced access and all of their sites have the exact same articles, won't that eventually hurt their rankings?  I do have a question:  I often post blogs on AR and then enter the same info as journal entries on my site, can that hurt my ranking?  I have observed other realtors posting their blogs in more than one place and the posts are identical. 
3:16pm • #23
JUN
14
2007
257,389 Points 7 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
I'm seconding all these questions, Brad - I think a lot of agents are duplicating content in two or more locations.
9:25am • #24

Great post!  Cutts' quote was simple, but really says it all.  It amazes me some of the rumors I hear, even from "professional" seos.   The seo for http://www.forplaycatalog.com/ told the owners not to distribute product descriptions to their retailers because their site would get a duplicate conetnt penalty! I laughed for a good 15 mintues when I heard that.

 I don't agree with Cutts explanation of supplemental results.  Having a page you want to rank being supplemental IS HELL!  Being supplemental means that you will never show before something in the regular index.  Once it is there, it is a PAIN to get out!  If you try to disallow it, Googlebot will ignore that request!

I agree 100% with the mirror site statement, but I want you to check this out.  I have to pull this from archive.org because they finally took the mirrors down about 2 months ago.

 http://web.archive.org/web/20060103174221/http://threewisheslingerie.com/
http://web.archive.org/web/20060203073106/http://3wisheslingerie.com/
http://web.archive.org/web/20060205175254/3wishes.com/
http://web.archive.org/web/20060407224914/threewishes.com/

This company had 4 mirror sites for at least 3 years!  They all gained solid PR that passed to subpages well.  They had the #3 spot for lingerie for quite some time.  However, one day it was one version, the next day it was a mirror.  Google had to have known.   Not advocating people do this, but Google clearly practices selective enforcement.

 

8:35pm • #25
130,211 Points Outside Blog
A lot of new information about something I really had no idea about. So much to learn, so little time! Thanks for getting me heading in the right direction!!
9:09pm • #26
JUN
15
2007
VERY, VERY helpful.  Thank you for the content. I was sent here by link to gather more info.  We are creating  new site and although much of this is not new, it does confirm some things that I need to focus on for our new site as far as web copy.
4:40am • #27
123,587 Points Outside Blog
Thank you so much for clearing this up, you are right we get conflicting information and it was very confusing.  Now I know the correct answer.  Thanks again
5:54am • #28
4 Featured Posts Outside Blog Hit Router

 Brad:  I came to this post from your comment in my post about Homes.com - Advanced Access. . .

 Thanks for all the useful information - the more info - the more confusing.  I visited the Google link you had and copied the bullet point below.

  • If your site participates in an affiliate program, make sure that your site adds value. Provide unique and relevant content that gives users a reason to visit your site first.
  • It seems that maybe we won't get penalized for content that is not original (if I get the message) but still it is recommended for best SEO.  It only makes sense to gear your site to the audience you want to reach and not take the easy way to keeping a template site as it is.

    12:47pm • #29
    19 Featured Posts

    Hey Brad,

    I gave you props and linked to this blog over at my blog about Link Farming

    Love to get your feedback.

    Frank

    11:46pm • #30
    JUN
    30
    2007
    Brad- trying to understand. When I post AR or to localism on lets say a local event or real estate market then put the same post on my website blog am I hurting my rankings?  I do this so the info reaches the right readers not for search engines.
    1:36am • #31
    AUG
    17
    2007
    226,783 Points 12 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

    I've always been afraid to post an article in both places. This makes me feel better.

    12:45pm • #32
    Very interesting post.   Now, what I've been doing is having all my AR blogs posted on my Squidoo mirror, or at least a link back to the AR post from Squidoo.  Is this an example of inadvisable duplication?    It's all original stuff on AR. 
    1:24pm • #33
    2 Featured Posts

    THanks for this strong information.  Sometimes we trick ourselves into worrying about the little stuff.

    I like to 'reference' and link over to other blog posts.

    Whatever Google does, I love 'em.  Isn't ranking connected to popularity.  If someone has a new real estate url, it needs traffic.  Maybe you will have to advertise about it somewhere else to get the people looking for you.  Then, go for longevity.  Being found in the searches is different. Google finds you in just a few days.  I can recall when this took a couple months. But, you have to have information on your website that lends itself to being recognized early on searches.

    The Advanced Access type sitea, plus those connected to franchises don't give you a lot of leaway for keywords except in your own content.  If your office has an IT guy and you don't reallyi ever get to mess with your website, at least figure out where your profile is and beef that up with rich information that people need to know when looking for someone like you.   I've had clients who knew they were lucky to be able to click onto the internet.  The web designer at their office didn't do them any favors, IMO.

    2:30pm • #34
    AUG
    18
    2007
    2 Featured Posts Outside Blog
    Brad.........thanks so much for this information.  I have always wondered about this.  In the past, I have cut and pasted a blog I put on ActiveRain and put it on another blog of mine.  Then I go in and change a few adjectives in my blog.  For instance I would change, "It was a thrilling time in my life" to read "It was an enjoyable time in my life".   I thought this might trick google a bit.   What do you think?  Waste of time?
    8:58pm • #35
    AUG
    26
    2007
    205,044 Points 1 Featured Post Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router
    Lots of good reading - information we all need to know, thanks for posting it.  I will bookmark.  I just set up my own blog and was thinking how smart it would be to just put some of the blogs that I've written here on Rain over to mine.  Maybe I'll get more attention on my own blog.  By attention, I mean readers.
    2:06am • #36
    AUG
    31
    2007
    18 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor
    Brad, your post, like your many others, continues to live on and give me more and more work to do.lol. I have to run now to my other blog and undo all the cutting and pasting from my AR blog. BTW, that's why I am quiting Advanced Access - same old, same old as everywhere else. There is an agent with Advanced Access who is always in the top of the 1st Google page and her web-site never works when clicking on some basic buttons. Go figure.
    9:00pm • #37
    247,611 Points 3 Featured Posts Outside Blog

    Brad,

    Appreciate you settling this issue about duplicate content. What I've read is that you should slightly alter your text so Google won't hurt you real bad. What I sometimes do is write, or copy, part of my own blog from another site and then link back to the original site. Like cross-linking for additional SEO exposure.

    10:44pm • #38
    SEP
    01
    2007
    Thanks Brad for clearing this up once and for all.
    4:15am • #39
    DEC
    15
    2007
    Localism Sponsor Hit Router
    Thanks for some really fresh helpful information! I have been catching up on all of your blogs.
    2:30pm • #40
    124,439 Points 1 Featured Post
    Brad- I have been posting identical content on both my blog post. I just learned that it isn't recommended. Thank You
    2:46pm • #41
    DEC
    31
    2007
    535,586 Points 45 Featured Posts Outside Blog
    Interesting comments, Brad, though a bit confusing as well. I'm looking forward to your answers to the above questions.
    7:30pm • #42
    JAN
    01
    2008
    1 Featured Post

    Hi Brad...

     

    I just came across this blog... WoW.. I always thought about re posting my blog on my point 2 website... Is it possible.....

    1:13pm • #43

    Thanks for the great insight and information. I have always wondered about duplicate content and wondered how it was addressed so thanks for answering clearly a question I have pondered.

     Look forward to reading more from you! Hapy New Year!

    1:52pm • #44
    Thanks so much for clarification. I've been pondering this topic, and read many different opinions on it. Yours was as clear and well written article as any of the others. Thank you.
    8:17pm • #45
    2 Featured Posts
    Yep, you are correct, absolutely and it is amazing how rumors get started and who starts them and why as well. Keep fighting the good fight. and as the most prolific online article writer in the history of mankind, I know from first hand experience that you are correct; sincerely, Lance Winslow
    9:16pm • #46
    JAN
    02
    2008

    Brad - I had not read this post before.  I'm so glad it was referred to today. I thought you could not duplicate posts with out penalty.  Thank you very much for the information.

    Happy New Year!

    1:55am • #47
    JAN
    08
    2008
    8 Featured Posts

    Brad,

    Great post.  Thanks for setting the record straight.  I will continue to play it on the safe side by slightly altering content on my multiple sites, if for no other reason than to try and highlight different keywords.

    8:21am • #48
    JAN
    12
    2008
    Great post~ I actualy triplicate my postings!!! I get rankings!!!!
    12:09am • #49
    FEB
    06
    2008
    13 Featured Posts


    Thanks all for the great comments. Always glad to help.

    Lance: You are too kind!

    9:11am • #50

    Leave a response…



    (optional)
    What does the graphic say?
     
    Newheadshot-brad Rainmaker_large

    Brad Carroll - Real Estate Web Designer

    Knightdale, NC

    More about me…

    Dakno Marketing

    Address: 1100 Navaho Drive, Suite 204, Raleigh, NC, 27609

    Office Phone: (888) 325-6610

    Cell Phone: (919) 926-7010

    Email Me

    Discussing the latest trends in Real Estate Web Design and Marketing


    Ready to start driving more traffic to your site? Purchase the Real Estate Website Accelerator.

    Use coupon code
    "acceleratorAR"
    and save $20!



    Learn the formula for creating a successful, lead generating website. Purcahse the Real Estate Website Success Guide.

    Use coupon code
    "successAR"
    and save $10!
    Dakno Real Estate Blog

    Subscribe to RSS headline updates from:
    Powered by FeedBurner

    #creditfooter {display:none;} .feedburnerFeedBlock li { list-style-image:none; list-style-position:outside; list-style-type:none; font-size:12px!important; margin-left:-30px; padding-right:10px; } .feedburnerFeedBlock a { font-size:12px; } .feedburnerFeedBlock .headline {border:0px;}


    Links

    Archives

    RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

    Find NC real estate agents and Knightdale real estate on ActiveRain.