Hi Missy - Hope you are doing well. When I 1st started with point2 I was doing the same thing but as time has gone on and the more I thought about it, I just let everyone in on the handshake. Who knows if someone outside my area may end up with a customer that likes one of my listings. I don't really see the downside myself.

I think that you should accept everyone's handshakes except for the ones who are in another state or MLS than you are.  I also don't handshake with agents who don't accept handshakes for others.