Very interesting statistics coming in, now, re the impact of the internet on the real estate industry.
In one recent survey, done by the National Association of Realtors and Baylor University School of Business, in the U.S., it charted where buyers found the home they purchased:
* 34% from Real Estate Agent.
* 32% Internet.
* 15% yard signs.
* 7% Friend, relative or neighbour.
* Less than 1% from Home Books and Magazines.
In the same survey, when buyers and sellers were queried as to how they chose their Realtor, only 4% were chosen because of their company affiliation.
I find the above statistics to be very interesting, indeed, and to support what I first noted a good three years ago. Affiliation with a name brand franchise model no longer delivers on the referral option that was once an essential part of that "big box" name.
With the internet, the buyer doesn't pop by a franchise office in Toronto, say, and ask to be referred to a Salt Spring realtor. It's rare that this would happen, today, and yet 10 to 15 years ago that was a vital part of such a franchise option.
With the internet, the buyer is searching out areas / realtors/ inventory on Google or some other search engine, and they do this for a substantial time before deciding "where" to look more indepth, and "who" to call to do so. The contact comes directly from the internet, and the contact for this buyer might simply be the realtor who has the last listing that caught the buyer's eye. Company affiliation, then, has become unimportant. Even realtor "name" becomes less important. It's about the listing information that captured the attention. Brand loyalty, to either a company or a well-known realtor, is evaporating.
In a city environment, yard signs might play a role in being discovered. Not so useful in a secondary home/discretionary marketplace, though, unless the sign is "up" during the "season". July/August/September could be seen as Salt Spring & the Southern Gulf Islands "season", where signage might attract a potential buyer's interest, while they're "on Island". Otherwise, the sign sits for a lengthy time, and only the "locals" are driving by it.
With only 1% of buyers coming off Home Books and Magazines, where does that leave the Driftwood supplement, our main print publication? It might catch a few "looks" in the "season" -- someone popping off a boat, at the marina, and picking up the real estate supplement, or catching the ferry to a Gulf Island, and viewing property options en route, but in the "off season", no one would see this publication, except the "locals". It doesnt' "bring" a buyer, then, for most of the calendar year.
The car industry, the stock market side of investing, the book business...the internet changed all of these businesses, severely, at an earlier point in time. It's now the turn of the real estate industry.
Even the mls system is not as valid a medium of information as one would hope for. The data input sheet used for all areas are too uniform. If there's one thing the internet is teaching us all, it's the ability to be "niched". In one Board, recently, they stuck a private island listing in an area that was a good 3 hours away, geographically, just because they didn't want to create a "slot" for this one-off Island. Was that good service for a seller, a buyer, a listing agent, a buyer's agent? I don't think so! Surely, in today's digital world, it would only have been a couple of mouse clicks, to "get it right"????
So, if we're in the middle of a serious shift, in how real estate is "being done", for the benefit of the two parties to any transaction (that's the seller and the buyer), what is the way for a realtor to significantly "market" a property? And how can that be made to work for a secondary home/discretionary marketplace, where the buyer isn't "local"?
17 Comments on Marketing thoughts, in this fast disappearing "hybrid moment"....
SEP
24
2009
This is interesting information-with the Internet many people are changing the way they do business and think of business in general. A good Internet presence is essential.
Hi Li, I generally agree with the findings, but as always there are always exceptions to the general rule. I find that using Homes & Land mag, for example, is an excellent Listing Tool that a seller can relate too. The eyes tend to gloss over when I reference keyword placement and search engine optimization LOL.
Appreciated the comments! I still use print media in my secondary home marketplace, as the buyer isn't "local". The Homes and Land website, though, is more valuable to me than their magazine. Too hit and miss! To stay in biz, I think that magazine formats are going to have to be the "online" source.
It is amazing to me that Agents in my office swear up and down they get buyers from the Homes Mag in our area. Let them spend their money then!
To answer your other question about how do you market to people outside your local area, I would think you need to use the keywords they are looking for. If you can, try interviewing some folks who have already bought from you and ask what words they used. Here are some that I can think of:
Our Sellers expect to be advertised in the local newspapers and Home Magazines and we do, but the advantage of buying these ads aretheir internet presence. Realtor.com, Home Magazine web sites and building our web sites do the best lead/sales generating. Looking forward to the blogging to start adding to that presence.
I so appreciated all your comments...thank you, too,Evelyn, for your ideas re keywords. I know that sellers like to see their properties listed in the print formats, including Homes and Land, and other similars, and their web presence can bring client base (has happened to me, in the past, too), but I think there's been a further shift, and we're all in that swimming pool of change, treading water...to come to the fore, on the internet, that is the question....
Li, I've found that my sellers have no problem understanding that advertising their property in the local newspapers and home magazines is not an effective way to bring in buyers to a vacation and second home destination. For me, any internet exposure is preferable to print media. I agree that there's been a fundamental change in the way we do business just in the last 3 years, since the downturn in the market. Hopefully, we're all out here working together right now to find out what works and learning from each other's experiences.
You're right, Kate, that things are a little different in a secondary home marketplace...the buyer is from somewhere else/no local market, so local items never worked.
The real estate books and newspapers are shrinking daily. The smart publications are moving online, adding Twitter and IPhone functions, and trying to keep up!
I agree and love this new concept (or maybe not so new concept) - I have sellers still asking (at times) for print ads. I just try to educate them and with blogs like yours it helps even more - thank you!
This is really good information. I actuallly thought the internet would have ranked far higher. There may also be geographic differences in how people find their Realtor. The sellers who still like the print ads are the sellers who are subscribing to the Newspaper and they want to see their house in print. I havn't had a call from a print ad in a LONG time and virtually have stopped doind them except for a few niche markets and specialty magazines that people keep.
Such valuable comments, here, and very appreciated! I work in a secondary home marketplace, with no local buyer at all. In the past (as in before 2007), I did find quality niche magazine ads of some use in garnering the initial attention. That's what put them onto the website. I think there's been another shift, though, since 2008. I'm finding that a traditional website is now a basement or attic storage item, where a consumer can drill down for hard information, IF they want to. Otherwise, I think microblogging is where it's suddenly "at" -- because we're all in time famine? Trained to "hear" in bytes? Something different is afoot, though, and it's not about brand or agent loyalty.
I think the internet will continue to drive traffic for our industry. Referrals will always be important as well as social contacts that we leverage for business.
Absolutely. The ways of communicating with the consumer may shift/change, but the solid "good business practices"/knowledge always remain as a constant. We are a service industry.
It is still important to place ads in mags. People might not find the house they are looking for there but many find there realtor through other listings through the mags.
under 1% most likely doesn't look at the correlation between how a realtor is selected and the home they buy
real estate, b.c. real estate, salt spring island real estate, Canadian real estate, luxury real estate, waterfront specialist, private islands specialist, estate style properties, secondary home marketplace, active rain, Li at Sea to Sky Premier Properties, Mayne Island, Galiano Island, Pender Islands, Saturna Island, Salt Spring Island, southern Vancouver Island.
Disclaimer: ActiveRain Corp. does not necessarily endorse the real estate agents, loan officers and brokers listed on this site. These real estate profiles, blogs and blog entries are provided here as a courtesy to our visitors to help them make an informed decision when buying or selling a house. ActiveRain Corp. takes no responsibility for the content in these profiles, that are written by the members of this community.
This is interesting information-with the Internet many people are changing the way they do business and think of business in general. A good Internet presence is essential.