What's Real in Real Estate?
REO transactions are real. It's just that for home owners and investors trying to sell their homes, the REO market has been the 800 pound gorilla squashing average sellers. Normal transactions have almost vanished from the market as buyers chase the bank owned home bargains they read about. We've been living with this in most markets for at least 18 months.
I'm happy to announce that in Sonoma County, CA, at least for now, the foreclosure properties that dominated the market for most of 2008 and 2009 are finally becoming a minority of transactions. In fact the new listings in the last thirty days in Sonoma County break out as:
- Normal Market Listings: 345 homes
- Short Sale Listings: 143 homes
- REO Listings: 133 homes
It's a welcome change for the 345 people who were able to list their property for sale in a market where REO listings now have less than 20% market share of new listings. Owners still have to price their homes properly, but they're not competing with the banks' asset managers nearly as often.
The chart shows the trend month by month since the start of 2008. REO reporting was sketchy in our MLS, so I don't think we captured much data for the first few months, but it was clear by July of last year that REO transactions were beginning to outnumber traditional sales. The trend accelerated from there, and by the end of 2008 and beginning of 2009, sales of bank owned properties outnumbered traditional sales by more than 2 to 1. The number of normal owner-to-buyer transactions was fewer than 100 per month in January and February of 2009.
By May of this year the ratio was back to 1 to 1 for REO sales vs. open market transactions. During the summer the trend away from REO domination of the market has continued and we now (early October) are looking at REO sales falling towards the 100 per month level. My headline about the "real" real estate market returning after long domination by REO properties is proven by the numbers.
Of course, all this can change. We have rumors of waves of foreclosed properties coming from Option ARMs and other financial instruments due for reset soon. We hear tales of ghost inventory of REO properties just waiting to be dumped on the market. We all know people who are defaulting month after month on their mortgages without bank action. It's nearly impossible to get a clear understanding of the REO market and why banks are not acting more aggressively. What I can say is that if I were a banker with a lot of potential REO properties on my hands, I would have been putting them on the market starting in late spring when buying interest intensified and the REO inventory was dropping.
Keep watching my reo sites to check for active listings of foreclosed property in Northern California areas you are interested in.
Please enjoy visiting any of my sites
;)
;)
Dave, your charts really put a new perspective on the realities of the market. thanks!