As an Italian American, I always felt very proud that Christoper Columbus discovered America.  There's usually a big parade in South Philadelphia, where I grew up, and there's even a park named after the famous explorer.  The public school system where I live now does not give the kids a day off and Max has often come home to tell me that they do not teach that Columbus discovered America anymore, I think Leif Ericson is given this honor and rightly so..  Max is half Italian and is affronted by this fact, if only because he doesn't get the day off!  According to Wikipedia, Columbus day became an official federal holiday in 1934. although it says the Americans have celebrated this day since the Colonial period. 

According to Wikipeida, the influx of Catholics in the mid-nineteen century induced discrimination from activists against immigration such as the Ku Klux Klan.  There's a shocker.  The KKK was against immigration... I wonder if they stopped to think where their parents had been born?  But I digress. To help struggling immigrants, Catholics developed organizations to fight discrimination with groups like the Knights of Columbus, a name chosen in part because it saw Christopher Columbus as a fitting symbol of a Catholic immigrant's right to citizenship.

While doing some reading to write this post, I came across disturbing facts about Christopher Columbus, most shocking to me is that it's claimed that he is the founder of slavery in the Americas. 

According to this article, Columbus, in his log, noted:

"They brought us barrels of cotton thread and parrots and other little things which it would be tedious to list, and exchanged everything for whatever we offered them...I kept my eyes open and tried to find out if there was any gold, and I saw that some of them had a little piece hanging from a hole in their nose. I gathered from their signs that if one goes south, or around the south side of the island, there is a king with great jars full of it, enormous amounts. I tried to persuade them to go there, but I saw that the idea was not to their liking...They would make fine servants... With fifty men we could subjugate them all and make them do whatever we want."

Well, this is kind of a kick in the head to me and further proof that ignorance is certainly bliss. They certainly didn't teach this part of the life of Christopher Columbus to little Italian school children was I was growing up. 

Living and learning is part of growing up, I suppose.  As a 50 year old woman, I also suppose it's time I grew up.  But rather than be serious, I'd rather tell you something funny.  When I was younger, Dean Martin used to host celebrity roasts.  I loved them, and loved all of that silly humor.  Red Buttons did a skit and I've always remembered it and laughed.  He said that Christoper Columbus, while trying to convince Queen Isabella to let him explore said... "the world is round, you're the only one who's flat"! 

Rather than enslaving the indigenous people Columbus came across, I would have much rather he'd left them laughing.  And free.

 

 
Post is included in group: Diary of a Realtor
Post is included in group: "Whacked"!!!
Post is included in group: Square Pegs
Post is included in group: Club Chaos

27 Comments on Columbus Day,

OCT
12
428,454 Points 59 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Hi Susan!  Beautifully written and I have to say, AGREED!

Have a great day...

7:48am • #2
158,947 Points 5 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor

We basically believe what we were taught... then we grow up and question, seek for answers, and sometimes find out the truth.  Sometimes we don't find the truth and just ponder.

Many from my race of people do not have the full knowledge of our roots for they are vague.  This is a very interesting article you have written here... ripe for controversy!  Have an enjoyable day!

7:58am • #3
106,064 Points 1 Featured Post Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Susan, so much is left out in our history books....we probably wouldn't be proud of many of them past, present or future! Just think of what will be left out of the history books that will be written about the current history of our country!!

7:58am • #4
8 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router

Susan:

An interesting look at Christopher Columbus.  I guess we have to learn to take the bad with the good.

I remember those Dean Martin Roasts (and his show). He was a great talent and a very funny man.

 

8:00am • #5
224,480 Points 6 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Debbie, live and learn is so right.  I do that every day, whether I want to or not!

Debe, thank you. xxoo

Diana, it was very troubling to me to learn this.  I shouldn't be surprised, but I am.  I will never understand how a human being can look upon another human being and not see themselves.  Enjoy your day as well.

Caren, you are right.  In 100 years or so, I don't think we would be proud of some of the things that will come out about the last 50 years of my lifetime. 

Claudette, I used to love the roasts and all of those long gone comedians.  Their humor was sharp and cutting and they managed to do it without the use of one single F word!  Amazing!

 

 

8:22am • #6
341,947 Points 4 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Susan - I don't think they had a lot of humor in 1492, at least not after a long voyage on those tiny boats. Just shows that what we are taught in schools isn't the whole picture, and often not even the accurate picture.

8:24am • #7
224,480 Points 6 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Mike, you are right about that.  I get extremely seasick, so I doubt I would be laughing, even at Red Buttons after a long voyage at sea on a little boat with a bunch of smelly seaman.  Gross!  History does have a way a shedding a light where a light, while it needs to be shone, is not usually complimentary.

 

8:30am • #8
169,839 Points 10 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor

Hi Susan, well it appears from everything I have read recently about CC is that he was not a nice guy- I liked the fairy tale in our (old) history books better - but now we learning more about how it really was.  Sadly, it's like finding out there's no Santa Claus. :-)

 

9:07am • #9
266,173 Points 59 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Susan -  Just goes to show that many of our history books are not entirely the whole picture.  It's unfortunate, however if you want to know the whole truth... many times you'll have to do the digging yourself.

9:22am • #10
200,708 Points 1 Featured Post Outside Blog

Susan, if it makes you feel any better, the Spanish think they discovered America, because Columbus was using Spanish ships, and Spanish Sailors, and the Queen of Spain paid for the 'trip'. :)

I think every country talks about the 'nice side' of each and every person in History.  I don't think we're ever taught any bad things about our heroes.  The same thing happens with the History I learned of my country and its explorers and discoverers.  Ignorance is bliss, for sure ...

1:35pm • #11
216,637 Points 4 Featured Posts Outside Blog

I'm going to choose to just remember that I'm free because "WE" Americans not matter if Italian, Irish, French, African or otherwise fight for our freedom.  Sadly the fight has still to continue for others in America today.  But if we fight long enough, someday hopefully injustice will be rare and not the norm and not accepted.  So I'm still blissful.

3:01pm • #12
221,018 Points 19 Featured Posts Outside Blog Hit Router

Susan,

I find it difficult to judge someone's actions from over 500 years ago. Fast forward 500 years in the future and society will be looking back at us thinking we were barbarians.

As they say, "the winners get to write history."

Rich

4:24pm • #13
228,563 Points 1 Featured Post

Hi Susan, great bit of history, really enjoyed it. And now in our quest for original ancestors, the former fossil  Lucy is being edged out by the much senior Ardie.

4:50pm • #14
181,905 Points Localism Sponsor

Susan..Lets  try to remember the good in people.The poor man did end up  in prison where he did die..if I am not mistaken..something I could never understand as a child..And the Music goes round and round and it comes out here..

HELPFULHANNAH your friend in Philadelphia

4:50pm • #15
462,389 Points 28 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Susan, They taught us VERY little about our "Founder."  For one thing, I'm not sure how he "founded" America when there were people already living here!  And I was reading about the unpleasant diseases he brought with him as well.  Those books certainly leave out a lot of information, don't they?

4:50pm • #16
284,918 Points 5 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Susan.. Our history books are just like the newspapers.. ONLY PRINTING WHAT THEY WANT US TO READ.  Thank goodness we now have minds of our own, and can think outside the box.  Moreover, we question things.. just to assume them to be true.

valerie osterhoudt

7:49pm • #17
224,480 Points 6 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Mary, how is it that I never heard any of this in my lifetime?  Sad.

Jason, you don't understand.  I don't want the whole truth!  Only the nice things!  lol!

Sylvie, my biggest hero is Abe Lincoln and I don't think I ever read anything really negative about him!  If you know something, please don't tell me!

Tammy, I prefer to think only the best of people, which is why I was disappointed to find that info today.  We are free to think and feel as we want, thank God!

Rich, you are so right.

 

8:10pm • #18
Outside Blog

Susan - Very interesting history facts - I guess the truth is not always a pretty thing. 

8:17pm • #19
224,480 Points 6 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Hi Janice!  I'm sorry I missed you at the open house last week!

Hi Hannah, after enslaving his fellow human beings, prison appears to be too good for him.  But he didn't die in prison, here's what it says in Wikipedia: On 20 May 1506, at about age 55, Columbus died in Valladolid, fairly wealthy from the gold his men had accumulated in Hispaniola. At his death, he was still convinced that his journeys had been along the east coast of Asia. According to a study, published in February 2007, by Antonio Rodriguez Cuartero, Department of Internal Medicine of the University of Granada, he died of a heart attack caused by Reiter's Syndrome (also called reactive arthritis). According to his personal diaries and notes by contemporaries, the symptoms of this illness (burning pain during urination, pain and swelling of the knees, and conjunctivitis) were clearly evident in his last three years.[39]

Carole, I miss my old presumptions about Christoper Columbus, that's for sure! 

Hi Valerie, you are right!

8:22pm • #20
345,887 Points Outside Blog

Susan

Thanks for sharing your thoughts on Columbus Day.

Good luck and success.

Lou Ludwig

8:50pm • #22
595,452 Points 63 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Susan, I'll take the joke anytime too. I think they said Thomas Jefferson had slaves. Slavery is a big part of the world's history and obviously even talked about in the Bible. Human bondage of another is bizarre and primitive to say the least but the world keeps changing, never ever stopping. Columbus also never set foot on North America but just down in the Caribbean if I have my facts straight.

9:28pm • #23
OCT
13
187,944 Points 19 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Hi Susan...Wonderfully written.

There are so many things that we were taught that were not the whole truth and so many things that were omitted.  I guess there's not much we can do about that other than to keep an open mind and continue to learn.  Looks like you share that view.  Good for you.

Kate

12:00am • #24
238,718 Points 2 Featured Posts

Susan,

Thank you for the history lesson.  I knew some of this but not the part about slavery...;-(

Ann Hayden in cold cloudy Wildwood,MO

10:46am • #25
224,480 Points 6 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Hi Lou, you are welcome.

Gary, not sure about the never setting foot in N. America, but you are probably right.  Slavery is a stain on our history and sadly is still going on today in some parts of the world. 

Hi Kate, you are right!  xxoo

HI Ann, it was beautiful here today but it's starting to cloud up nowl

4:45pm • #26
OCT
15
188,132 Points 2 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Susan, there are letters in Columbus' handwriting where he states that he rewards his men by giving them Native American girls.  He notes they especially enjoy the very young ones.

My daughter loves history, so I am very careful to supplement what she's mislearning in school so she has a better picture.

Janice - My daughter recorded a two hour documentary about Ardie, she's already watched it and loved it and has saved it to watch again with me.  Should be interesting.

12:18pm • #27

Leave a response…



(optional)
What does the graphic say?
 
Rainmaker_large

Susan Mangigian, West Chester PA Realtor RE/MAX Preferred, ABR

West Chester, PA

More about me…

RE/MAX Preferred, West Chester, PA, RS152252A

Address: 1450 E. Boot Road, Suite 600-A, West Chester, PA, 19380

Office Phone: (610) 719-1700

Cell Phone: (610) 299-6237

Email Me



Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find PA real estate agents and West Chester real estate on ActiveRain.