Ar_home_b_search
 

Dan Lowery posted a following question: “Why the attack against realtors?” http://activerain.com/blogsview/130113/Why-the-attack-toward

In Poland where I was born we have a proverb "there is no fire without a smoke". It certainly applies well to our (agents and brokers) situation. There are many reasons (often justifiable) why people pick up on real estate professionals. The interesting question is, why now? Why now Realtors became a "hunt of the day"?  Here are some reasons as I see them:

  • Perception that Realtors hold a grip on the real estate market and do not allow low cost alternatives (it is irrelevant if it is true or not – the perception is out there).
  • Launch of companies such as Zillow and Trulia demonstrated that there are alternatives to sometimes rude agents and brokers and uncooperative MLS (by the way – MLS feels the heat – there are many positive changes happening and the quality of MLS service is improving).
  • Proliferation of Internet empowered clients and enabled them to do their own search and research
  • Resulting perception that agents do less now (as clients do some of agents’ “old job”), but still charge the same commission.
  • Lack of understanding of tremendous competition between for listings (and thus lower commissions) due to the influx of new agents over the period of last several years).

So, what is the solution? In my opinion – we need to do more for less. It means that we have to provide more service – beyond house search, negotiations and the closing (yes it is a lot, but let’s face it. With the tools we have now and will have in the near future, it is easier and takes less time). What service should we provide? It is up to us to define it.

Regarding the commissions, will they go down to $500? I don’t think that it will happen anytime soon.  They are down to 5 – 5.1% now and probably 5 years from now the average commission will be in the range of 3.5% to 4.5%. At the same time, we will have many competent low service providers as many transactions will qualify for it, and agents and brokers who still will be able to charge 6% or more. Will their service resemble the service we provide today?  In some cases it might, but I believe that to earn high commissions in the future we will have to provide more service.

What do you think?

 

4 Comments on Why the attack against realtors? - My reply to Dan Lowery

JUN
26
2007
3 Featured Posts

Artur,

I believe that we have created an income model that will sustain the changes coming to our industry.  I anticipate vast changes to how agents are compensated, but am entirely against the $500 (just an example) fee for MLS type of business.

Competent agents will always be valuable to the consumer, but the consumer will not pay as much in the future.  I think the selling agent (representing the buyer) should be paid more than the listing agent, and our company is set up that way.  Our goal is to get FSBO money into the real estate agent's pockets, and have the FSBOer still feel like they are getting a great deal.

Todd Murphy, Founder, Zero Commission  Real Estate, Inc.

5:06am • #1
387,988 Points 5 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Arthur, I think you have provided a very well thought out analysis of the reasons Realtors(R) are under attack.  I believe you're right in your conclusion about future commissions as well.

I would add one more reason we are under attack at this particular time:  The incredible increase of home prices in the last ten years has Realtors making twice as much for selling the same home, so long as commissions are based on the same percentage of the sales price.  The public perceives this as a ripoff.

5:32am • #2

Flex models will be the the next part of the compensation in real estate. I do however think that we can look at the deregulation of the Securities industry and see that all the Big Boys are still in the game and that the flat fee and discount stock brokers have helped the entire market by adding people to the rank of investors.

 

8:32am • #3
Outside Blog

Todd, Very interesting. Good luck.

Thank you Brian. 

Paul - I definitely agree. It is a really exciting moment. Many creative things are happening out ther and it will benefit both, customers and our business.

12:06pm • #4

What does the graphic say?

Leave a response…



(optional)
What does the graphic say?
 
Urbanski2a Rainmaker_large

Artur Urbanski

Burlingame, CA

More about me…

Cimpler Real Estate, Inc.

Address: 533 Airport Blvd., 4th Fl., Burlingame, CA, 94010

Office Phone: (650) 401-2245

Cell Phone: (415) 672-5051

Email Me

MLS evolution, key driving factors, new companies providing innovative services and products, local news from Burlingame and the San Francisco Peninsula.


Listings

Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog