There is no surprise across the nation that the inventory of the number of Atlanta homes for sale is down considerably.  While many in real estate are rejoicing in the streets over this supposed sign of recovery, they are not allowing themselves to consider why this has really happened.  It is not an anomaly, and it does not mean that the lack of inventory bodes well for the near future of Atlanta real estate.  For those that are informed, there is an acknowledgement that Atlanta home buying patterns are being refined and will not return to what many in real estate are expecting. We may not see things return to the way they were for quite some time...if at all.

First of all there are many reasons why there are fewer Atlanta homes for sale for sale. Here are just a few: 

  • Foreclosures: There is a much higher shadow inventory of already foreclosed homes that are on the sidelines because if they were all on the market at the same time - home prices would collapse.  The Federal government has introduced neighborhood price stabilization plans to prop up the values of homes - to protect the banks from failure.
  • No Equity:  Homeowners have refinanced their homes and there is no equity for them to sell and move up or trade down.
  • Negative Equity: Homeowners have refinanced their Atlanta homes and effectively re-affirmed bad debt.  They have refinanced for more than the home is worth (125%), and they still have negative equity in neighborhoods were prices are declining.  This pool of buyers is locked out of the real estate market until home values rise once more.
  • Unemployment: Underemployment and those that fear they may soon be unemployed are not in the home buying frame of mind.  These buyers are locked psychologically out of the market until jobs are created and unemployment has gone back to normal levels.  Full employment as we were used  to is not expected again for another 10 years.   The real unemplyment rate nationally is estimated at over 16-17%.
  • First time buyers - the pool of buyers has been exhausted.  The concept is too narrow in focus and limited in scope to really work.
  • There are no buyers: and Atlanta home sellers have resigned themselves to the fact that trying to sell a home in this current market is suicide.  Sellers have taken their home off the market in hopes that some future date many be more advantageous for them to sell their home on their terms.  (If buyers are not coming into the market in droves with historic 30 year fixed rate loans are available with tax credits - we're in big trouble!)
  • Real estate speculators and flippers have gotten a reality check - they cannot sell in this current market and break even.  Fewer seasoned investors are entering the market - many have opted to rent their properties.
  • Lease Purchase Agreements: Many desperate Atlanta home sellers think they have an opportunity in lease purchase.  They do not, since it has been my experience that over 95% of all lease purchases will never close.  That applies even more in this current market - bad or damaged credit will have an even rougher time obtaining a mortgage in the coming years.
  • Poor advice from Realtors:  The markets in the past few years have been inundated with many new Atlanta real estate agents that have no experience to draw on.  They are offering advice that is not sound, and the sellers and buyers are following it.  This plethora of new Atlanta real estate agents during our Atlanta real estate bubble has added a  hugh dysfunctional component into this current real estate market.  Homes are still selling, and many sellers are still in positive equity positions.
  • Rentals: - Homeowners that have rearranged the deck chairs on the Titanic have decided that they will rent their homes until times improve.

Jim Crawford REMAX

RE/MAX Greater Atlanta  770-238-0122 Direct

Or  888-992-5546 Toll Free Office

Atlanta Real Estate & Atlanta Homes for Sale

 
This post has been included in Georgia Information Fulton County, GA Information Alpharetta, GA Information
Post is included in group: The Optimist
Post is included in group: The Ninety-ninth Percentile
Post is included in group: RE/MAX Active Rain Bloggers
Post is included in group: Realtors®
Post is included in group: Real Estate Rookie

23 Comments on What's Really Behind Less Home Inventory?

NOV
09
Outside Blog Hit Router

Jim - Could part of the lack inventory in Atlanta also be that first time buyers have gobbled up a lot of the inventory?  It is definitely the case in the Louisville Kentucky Metro market.

8:47am • #1
284,468 Points 4 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Jim, telling it like it is!! Love it. So very true.

8:54am • #2
595,600 Points 80 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Bob Murphy (Real Living Realty Services)  No not in the least.  Unemployment is too high, and first time buyers area also many times first time hires.  There is an old saying, "Last in, first to go!"  Fear is keeping them out of the market.

9:01am • #3
595,600 Points 80 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Susie Blackmon-Maggie Valley Waynesville Horse Person/NC Broker/Realtor (Susie Blackmon LLC)  LOL!  Thanks Susie.  It was great seeing you in Cary last weekend.  I have a great time there.

9:02am • #4
103,914 Points Outside Blog

Jim, good point.  From MLS, does anyone publish expired or canceled listings reports.  That stat for period over period would give you the picture of what you're talking about.

 

9:02am • #5
2 Featured Posts

Then there are those that are scared of what the future holds and sitting out. It is strange how many times have you seen low prices AND low rates... the FTHB Tax credit is merely robbing future clients in the hopes that something will change so tomorrow, in home buying terms, will never come. That said I have logged a pretty good year and you just gotta keep your head down and keep slogging.

 

Good post!

9:02am • #6
174,134 Points 12 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Jim  -Good points. I do believe there are now fewer homes being held directly by banks. I think they're just delaying foreclosure and allowing homeowners to remain in their homes to protect the bank's asset. It's still a "shadow inventory," but just being held differently.

9:04am • #7
595,600 Points 80 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Mike Michaud (North Texas Help-U-Build)  Our MLS statistics cover this monthly, but very few agents follow it.

9:16am • #8
595,600 Points 80 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Perrin Cornell, ABR (Windermere RE/NCW)  It is scary when you think about the real lack of activity given the opportunites.  We also have had an excellent year.

9:17am • #9
595,600 Points 80 Featured Posts Outside Blog

John Mulkey, Housing Guru (TheHousingGuru.com)  An acquaintance of mine who is a foreclosure listing agent shared about the drop in available foreclosures.  However...he then shared that one of the conference calls he was on... shared the massive about of already foreclosed homes that are sitting on the sidelines.  They will not be there forever especially if unemployment keeps rising.

9:23am • #10

Could I borrow your phrase, rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic?

Thanks for straight-shooting Jim.  Tax-credits and low interest rates are not going to cause an market reversal.  What you say about the Atlanta market applies to mine as well (Southwest Chicago suburbs) and they just raised the property taxes in Cook County.

Linda Metallo, Re/max Impact, Lockport, Il. 

9:30am • #11
1 Featured Post Outside Blog

I heard somewhere that I shouldn't expect a real recovery of the housing market until 2017, when the estimated number of available homes meets the actual population growth.

Agents who don't like working this market might consider that, because it's going to be here for awhile, especially in hard hit areas like yours.

9:43am • #12
275,583 Points Outside Blog

Jim, you know you and I share a lot of the same thoughts. Many Realtors don't understand from a lack of experience in various markets what it takes to last through times like now and the next few years.

10:06am • #13
595,600 Points 80 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Linda Metallo (Re/max Impact)  Sure go ahead.  In many ways there may be more issues ahead in our economy than issues we believe are behind us now.  We have declining tax bases in local economies, rising unemployment only compounds it.  So the inevitable?  Taxes, millage and adjustments to local fees are going to have to rise.  Those jobs the government says they are saving or creating?  They are over 95% public sector government jobs.  Taxpayers will have to pay those wages as local governments refuse to cut budgets and programs.  Guess what?  The money comes from property owners not renters.

10:23am • #14
595,600 Points 80 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Rich Cederberg- Northwest Albuquerque Real Estate Expert (RE/MAX Elite)  The sad thing is that most in our industry do not get it.  Real estate is very dysfunctional today because many of the participants have no knowledge at all about the economy, trends in the business, pricing, and how to sell a home...  yet they advise others everyday.

10:25am • #15
595,600 Points 80 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Frank Rubi Kenner/Metairie LA Real Estate (Frank Rubi Real Estate Licensed in Louisiana)  Frank I agree.  It is also very obvious when many of these persons share online. A few share actual knowledge.   It is very obvious who are the real achievers, and who is just very visible.  Empty barrels make a lot of noise.

10:27am • #16
NOV
10
1 Featured Post

Here in Nashville-

If it's priced right and looks great it's pending.  The exception is the High end ( Brentwood, Tn) market ($300k+) where buyers MUST sell an existing home to acquire their next.  Although there were signs of life there in October.

All the areas where home sales were solid ( we were up in the Nashville area 26% over oct. 2008) share one commonality.

Affordability! they are all at or near the median national price ( $175,000 approx.).

I expect the market here to stabilize to about 75% maybe 80% of what it was in 2005. Where do you project your bottom in Atlanta?

 

 

1:08pm • #17
595,600 Points 80 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Jim Wood Nashville Real Estate (Crye-Leike Realtors, Inc.)  At this point I could not make any projections on the Atlanta market.  We have many issues...job losses, high foreclosures, speculation building, high unemployment, and many home owners are upside down because they purchased the home with no money down.

1:20pm • #18
171,460 Points 14 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Great post, and you have to be happy that the inventory is dropping. In spite of foreclosure and unemployment it's still a step in a slow but hopefully real recovery!

2:37pm • #19
171,460 Points 14 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

One more thing, In the late 80's and early 90's Austin went through an equally severe time due to the S&L Crisis and though slow and in fits and starts, we managed to climb out! Hang in there, it's not going to happen overnight but folks like you who are it it for the long haul will prosper in any market!

2:38pm • #20
210,656 Points 39 Featured Posts Outside Blog

I have not done that many first time buyer loans - we certainly have them available. One thing you said really sticks out to me as a banker and that is lease purchase. So many of them are done so wrong that we cannot use them to convert to a sale of the property. It seems no matter how many classes we offer or how many blog posts we write about lease purchase inception by the time they get to me they are wrong, wrong, wrong. Stay dry.

3:16pm • #21
595,600 Points 80 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Ken Cook, FHA Home Loans 678-439-8683  Lease purchases no matter who says they work, don't.  They are something to be avoided at all costs unless a major amount of non refundible cash is put up.  I agree with your observations.

8:05pm • #23

Leave a response…



(optional)
What does the graphic say?
 
1 Ambassador_large

Jim Crawford ~ Atlanta Real Estate-ABR E-PRO

Atlanta, GA

More about me…

RE/MAX Greater Atlanta

Address: REMAX Greater Atlanta, 1585 Holcomb Bridge Road, Roswell , GA, 30076

Office Phone: (770) 238-0122

Cell Phone: (770) 664-9516

Email Me

Atlanta real estate broker associate, real estate columnist for www.RealtyTimes.com, real estate speaker. Real estate marketing, Internet marketing for real estate, real estate coaching Feedjit Live Website Statistics


Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find GA real estate agents and Atlanta real estate on ActiveRain.