How Would Have Thomas Jefferson Voted? Really, how?
I never studied the History of USA. I am picking bits and pieces as I go... I learned the History of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union, and I knew nearly by heart all 600 page course book when I was taking the exam for my post graduate course...
So, I am a first grader in the history class here. And it is OK for me to ask stupid questions. Like how would Thomas Jefferson have voted on the Health Care bill?
Thomas Jefferson, who said "If we can prevent the government from wasting the labors of the people, under the pretence of taking care of them, they must become happy." (Jeffersonian Cyclopedia)
It was written in 1802. Written By Thomas Jefferson, who in 1801 became the 3rd President of the United States of America. Well educated, he, between other things, "read lawwith George Wythe and was admitted to the Virginia bar in 1767.
In 2008, 207 years after writing this letter, another educated lawyer became the 44th President of the United States. And he advocates for a strong government "wasting the labors of the people", wasting billions and trillions of dollars on the way. If this is the opposite of what Thomas Jefferson wrote - remember "they must become happy" - does this mean that they will become unhappy? If we agree with the first statement, then it does. Is this Obama's goal, or he simply does not care what is going to be tomorrow as long as he fashions today?
Jefferson was a great man and a visionary. Not everyone, not even every President is. Maybe we can understand that the 44th President of the United States of America does not see the nightmare ahead of us...but how come he can't look back and recognize the nightmare behind?
115 years after this letter was written, and 92 years ago, in 1917 to be exact, another lawyer took over the power in another great country. He believed that it was possible to correct the course of history and expedite it. That strong government could make the progress happen much faster, and that all they needed was strong government that could lead people to happiness. He declared capitalism evil and promised to abolish money. Bringing people to happiness turned out to be tougher than they thought. Stubborn subjects refused to see the far fetched goals. They needed to be brought to the future with a little force. And that's how the Red Terror started.
Lenin might have read Jefferson, but somehow did not get it. He thought he would rival Jefferson. But Lenin at least was looking ahead and thought he saw the bright future. There was no precedent yet... But decades later and millions upon millions dead, there is now...
We can't see the past in the future. It had not happen yet. But every future bears the seeds of the past, and looking in to the past, you can better understand the future. This is how we learn. On mistakes made by others.
But does he understand the past?
Does Barak Obama see the future or does he want to make his own mistakes? With dire consequences?
Which part of Jefferson's writing an educated lawyer does not understand?
Jon - Few in this country are familiar with the writings of Jefferson, Madison, or any other of our founding fathers. Most, especially politicians, see the constitution and other writings as inapplicable to today, and unfortunately, we'll someday pay a dear price for ignoring the principles upon which our country was founded.