Special offer

The Seller Wants Your Highest & Best Offer--Or So The Agent Says

By
Real Estate Agent with Coldwell Banker, Franklin,MA/508-369-5131 9017020

What does the "highest and best offer" mean anyway?  Is this just a scam?  Why can't the seller just focus on one offer at a time?annoyed sign

These are common questions especially with first time buyers.  I had a recent situation in which my buyer clients were looking at homes in a very desirable town just west of Boston.  It just so happens that this town was ranked as one of the top small towns out of hundreds around the country by a prominent magazine.  Of course, there was great competition amongst buyers to have the privelege of owning there so prices reflected this and multiple offers were unfortunately quite common. 

When my buyers wanted to submit an offer on a home on its first day on the market, we were told there were many offers being submitted.  The listing agent asked for my buyers' "best and final offer" (same as highest and best).  This was extremely frustrating for my clients to hear and they felt that it was unjust--they expressed their belief that everyone should have multiple chances to purchase.  I explained that given the competition, this method is the only FAIR way to determine the best buyer for the home.  They would have one chance to give their highest number bid on the home.  Needless to say, they refused to give their highest bid and did not get the home.

There is no doubt about the fact that this can be very stressful on buyers who do not want to overbid.  (The chance of overbidding is kept in check due to the bank's appraisal must reflect the accurate value of the home--accurate appraisals were not necessarily the norm a few years ago.)  The unfortunate reality is that there are presently not enough homes on the market so it can be competitive for each good home a buyer pursues.  During the spring market, the inventory will increase so maybe there will be less competition amongst buyers however indicators point to higher interest rates and maybe higher prices.

If you need tips on buying with less stress, give me a call or email. 

Posted by

************************************************************************************************ 

Kathy Stankard of Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage can be reached by cell at 508-369-5131 or via email

Kathy has been a top producing REALTOR since 1996 helping buyers and sellers in the Franklin, MA and metrowest of Boston area.  Feel free to check out her website for more resources and information.

 

 

Franklin MA Real Estate News

Joe and Molly Murphy
Coldwell Banker - Bradenton, FL
Put our Team to work for your Family

Highest and best is the universal answer to mulitple bids, which are becoming more frequent.  Not very often a year ago though.

Nov 16, 2009 09:45 AM
Barbara Todaro
RE/MAX Executive Realty - Happily Retired - Franklin, MA
Previously Affiliated with The Todaro Team

Kathy.....highest and best offer is happening more often now.....that's a good indication that the market is improving in our area.

Nov 16, 2009 09:53 AM
Dan Pinson
International Realty Partners - Phoenix, AZ
Broker,ABR,GRI,RSPS,SFR,TRC

Since we have an increasingly competitive foreclosure market here in Phoenix, I suggest that a buyer write their "highest and best" if I hear this phrase and I know the property is already priced right. To wit, one recent property had 17 offers (including ours; we didn't win) but the buyers lived with the outcome because they knew they had gone as far as they could. Luckily, my investor clients use their spreadsheets to calculate how far they'll go and it's not an emotional decision for them.

Nov 16, 2009 09:59 AM
Bill Gassett
RE/MAX Executive Realty - Hopkinton, MA
Metrowest Massachusetts Real Estate

Multiple offers will always be a boon for the seller and frustrating for the buyer!

Nov 17, 2009 07:25 AM