Many times, over the last few years, in my experiences on Trulia and Zillow, someone will ask the question of we Realtors "What's the standard commission in your area?"

Most of the time, good agents jump in and state: "There is no 'standard', real estate commissions are negotiable"... and go on to expound on the value of finding a good Realtor, and not allowing the commission to be your largest criteria in selecting a Realtor. We can go into more of that, but that's a different post than this one.

Almost without fail, at some point or another on that thread, some idiot Realtor will say... "standard commissions in our area are 6%, but I'll do it for 5%, call me!!" or "everyone in our area charges 5%".  A few of us will try to explain to them that even the discussion of commission amounts, in public (and social media IS public) is a violation of Sherman anti-trust laws, and we inevitably get into a heated discussion over whether indeed that's true or not.  In some of those conversations, I've been told by Realtors who've been in the business for a long time (so, what I'm saying there is ... not some "newbie")... that I don't know what I'm talking about... that we're just talkin' in generalities... and there's nothing wrong with that.

One agent went so far as to tell me that he'd been playing in the Sherman Anti-trust sandbox for 32 years, and he knew it better than I did...so basically shut-yer-pie-hole.

Well, in a fairly recent "thread that wouldn't die", we had that same hackneyed conversation (deja vu, deja vu, deja vu vu).  But this time, one of the Trulia regulars (a non-Realtor) decided that he would find out the truth, and sent a copy of the conversation off to a Washington advocacy group.  They, in turn, turned it over to the Department of Justice, who contacted him by phone, confirmed that it was an illegal discussion, and asked a lot of pointed questions... (including the url for the conversation) and are now monitoring.

I imagine there will be handful of interesting phone calls to managing brokers.  What you say on a social media website, especially as a professional Realtor, is there forever (and ever and ever)... make sure that what you say is correct, and legal.

ALAN MAY, Realtor®
Specializing in Evanston Real Estate and North Shore Real Estate

Coldwell Banker Residential Real Estate, 2929 Central Street, Evanston, IL 60201
847.425.3779      Cell: 847.924.3313      Email: Almay@aol.com

Evanston Real Estate & North Shore Real Estate
Licensed in Illinois

   

Do not copy the content of this blog, without first contacting the author for permission.  Reblogging is allowed. All other use is strictly prohibited without express permission from me. This blog is tag-resistant... Do not tag me, I don't participate in tagging, no MeMe's don't even think about it

 
Post is included in group: Diary of a Realtor
Post is included in group: M.A.N.C.R.O.W
Post is included in group: Realtors®
Post is included in group: The Vent
Post is included in group: "Whacked"!!!

212 Comments on what you've said on the internet about Commission is there forever, forever, forever

20 Most Recent Comments Displayed Show All

DEC
01
2009

The Sherman anti trust laws talk about anti trust a wide range of issues from price fixing to monopoly's,But I don't see any mention of exchanging information to RE licensees from state to state. as a matter of fact it didn't specifically talk of Real-estate but all commerce in generalThat would fall under state licensing laws. I started marketing for a title company also and the prices are regulated by the government the allowed fees are regulated yet enough for them to make a decent profit. Of course that doesn't pertain to the junk fees that some of them tack on. I wonder if the Government will some day step in and say all fees must be uniform in order to protect consumers and how NAR and other industry groups will react to that. How would we on the board react to this hypothetical situation. interesting. 

Thomas
7:42pm • #195
237,566 Points 5 Featured Posts Called Shot Master

You are correct Alan. Some Realtors are to dense to get this.

11:46pm • #196
DEC
02
2009
1 Featured Post Attended Rain Camp

Real estate commission is negotiated and not a fixed amount and thats all folks!

8:41pm • #198
DEC
03
2009
Outside Blog

Can you say till infiniti? Some people just don't know when to shut up.

10:51am • #200
DEC
04
2009
1,346,816 Points 71 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

It is amazing that in this day and age people still don't realize that you have to THINK before posting things on the internet! It WILL come back to bite you!

12:13pm • #202
MAY
29
2010

If Realtors are so crooked and stupid and spend all there time trying to figire out right from wrong they need to become lawyers.  Do the right thing all the time every time.

12:13pm • #204
JUN
29
2010
698,000 Points 15 Featured Posts Outside Blog Called Shot Master

Commissions are sacred.  Trust me.  There is no "standard" commission, given our business model, however, we tend to hover around ^% or whatever that is....Let the undercutters and undelivers offer whatever they want. I recently had a client who had had his home listed for nearly 9 months with a big box for &%. And, when I listed it, and got him an offer that he accepted within 8 days, told me that other agents would have listed it for 4 or 5%.  Right.  I told him.  But, could they have sold it?  Your more expensive agent didn't and she had more incentive to sell it.  Nuff said. 

6:03pm • #205
879,825 Points 224 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Suzanne - whether there is, or isn't a standard commission, isn't really even the point.  The point is that there are sacrificial lambs out there, who are willing to stand up on the mountainside and announce at the top of their lungs, that the standard commission is X%!  And once those feathers have been let out of the pillowcase, they are impossible to put back in, and are permanently out there in the world for all to see.

7:28pm • #206

I dont want to talk about commisions anymore, Talk is cheap ill just collect as many as I can.

Thomas Preston
8:55pm • #207
SEP
06
2010
8 Featured Posts Called Shot Master

Alan, I know this post is coming up on a year old already, but it will remain relevant forever! I am often amazed at how openly agents from different brokerages talk about commission structures. My commission structure is my business and the business of my clients. I don't even talk about it with my wife because, not being in the business, she might misquote or misrepresent what could be perceived as a 'standard commisson'! Great post, and so much more good info in the comment thread too!

4:09pm • #209
SEP
16
2011
136,401 Points 1 Featured Post Called Shot Master

"the discussion of commission amounts, in public (and social media IS public) is a violation of Sherman anti-trust laws"  Thanks for reminding us....I found your post because someone reblog it and I'm glad he did.

10:52am • #211
OCT
27
2011

I think we should all stop talking about commission and go out get us some, Whos with me on that ?

10:32am • #213

20 Most Recent Comments Displayed Show All


What does the graphic say?
Leave a response…


(optional)
Spam Prevention:
 
Moviealan Ambassador_large

Alan May, Coldwell Banker Realtor® Evanston, Illinois & Northern Suburbs

Evanston, IL

More about me…

847.425.3779 almay@aol.com

Address: Attn: Alan May, Realtor®, 2929 Central Street, Evanston, IL, 60201

Office Phone: (847) 425-3779

Cell Phone: (847) 924-3313

Email Me



Listings

Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog