Special offer

New Legislation Proposing an Increase in FHA Down Pament from 3.5% to 5% - To Keep Home Owners from Defaulting on Loans.

By
Real Estate Agent with RE/MAX Key Properties - Luxury Homes, Golf Course Homes

How will this Effect the Central Oregon Housing Market? New Legislation Proposing an Increase in the FHA  down payment from 3.5% to 5% - To Keep Home Owners from Defaulting on Loans.

According to a recent article on Yahoo News "More cash down proposed for FHA-backed loans,"

...the administration wants borrowers to have a stronger equity position on their loans. One possibility would be raising the current 3.5 percent down payment requirement. Proposed legislation in Congress would raise the down payment required to 5 percent.

The rational behind the increase is two fold:

...to get homeowners more invested in their property and therefore less likely to default on loans....and to better protect the FHA...

At first glimpse this makes sense, then again maybe not.  If a homeowner has more equity in their home are they really more likely to not default on the loan in a period of financial hardship?  Using my recent and current clients as an example, the FHA loans have been on properties under $300,000.  Most of then have been on properties under $150,000.  Let us take a look at the math.

FHA Loan Down Payments 3.5% vs. 5%

 

Bend Oregon FHA Loans$300,000 x 3.5% = $10,500 down payment

$300,000 x 5% = $15,000 down payment

Difference on $300,000 Loan = $4,500

 

$150,000 x 3.5% = $5,250

$150,000 x 5% = $7,500

Difference on $150,000 Loan = $2,300

 

Is an additional $2,300 to $4,500 going to keep home owners from defaulting on their loans or will it keep potential first time buyers from being able to afford homes? If a homeowner falls into financial hardship would the extra money serve the homeowner better in their bank account or in their equity?  I'm not sure that $2300 in equity is going to save the day.

Congress, be honest, the increase in down payment is to protect the FHA. Which may be important too.

"FHA's reserves have fallen to $3.6 billion, compared with $685 billion in outstanding insured loans for the fiscal year ended Sept. 30. That 0.53 percent ratio is far below the 2 percent threshold required by Congress."

How will this Effect the Central Oregon Housing Market?  Are you financing your next home with an FHA loan?  How would this change effect you?

 

Posted by

Thanks for reading my Bend, OR Real Estate Blog! Kryste Adams, Broker

 
Search the Central Oregon MLS with RE/MAX Key Properties
 
 
cell: 541.706.1556 | email: adamskryste@gmail.com
 
Check out this weeks favorite lunch spot in Bend, Pastrami Old World Deli.
 
Karen Fiddler, Broker/Owner
Karen Parsons-Fiddler, Broker 949-510-2395 - Mission Viejo, CA
Orange County & Lake Arrowhead, CA (949)510-2395

dumb, dumb, dumb....they have to QUALIFY....if someone was truly qualified, then they can afford the home. I don't think it makes any difference about the amount of down payment. Maybe if we moved to 10-20% but not 3.5-5%. More of Washington doing "something" instead of the right thing.

Dec 03, 2009 03:06 AM
Mary Lockman
Windermere Real Estate Methow Valley - Winthrop, WA
Methow Valley Real Estate

For the first time in a very long time I am seeing FHA loans back in our little world.  I have such a different market here.  Great blog.

Dec 13, 2009 08:08 AM
Anonymous
tj

They are trying to keep people from doing strategic defaults.  The risk of strategic default goes up radically the further underwater the buyer is.  Since it takes 6% to sell your house the buyers who only put down 3.5 or 5% are underwater immediately.   With property values still predicted to drop for the next few years in Bend (PMI says there is a 96.1% chance home prices will be lower two years from now:http://www.pmi-us.com/media/pdf/products_programs/eret/ERET_Appendix_1109.pdf )  we are setting these buyers up to fail.   I agree with Karen that it's doing something instead of the right thing.  Doing the RIGHT thing would be requiring 20% down.   That would have the effect of driving home prices down quickly, but I feel they are going to go there slowly now.   A quick, sharp decline would allow for a quicker recovery than the years of slow declines we are looking at.  

As a potential buyer I would love to see 20% down required, higher interest rates - in line with historical averages, and no stimulus for buying.   All of these things are attempting to hold up home prices and I feel they will fail at it.    I had hoped to buy again by now ( I sold in 2007), but won't until I see us being closer to the bottom.    Hopefully the buyer stimulus will expire next summer, and we see a severe decrease in the number of homes going into default sometime in the next few years.

Dec 14, 2009 09:21 AM
#3