Ar_home_b_search
 

Forgotten Real Estate The Right Of First Refusal is a consumer's tool you may never have heard of.

The right of first refusal, is a type of option agreement, unlike a normal option, the purchased right to purchase, where the seller is obligate to sell for a fixed price if and when the option is excised. The right of first refusal, neither obligates the seller to sell or sets a price if the seller agrees to sell! The right of first refusal, oblates the seller to offer the holder of the right, the opportunity to buy the property for and on what ever terms the seller is willing to accept from another willing buyer.

Why would someone want a right of first refusal? Simple! They might want the property, if the seller wants to sell at a reasonable price. The most common uses are:

Tenants may negotiate a right of first refusal into a lease so that if the seller should decided to sell they have the first chance to buy and retain the property.

You want a property for what ever reason, if the seller decides to sell.

You've rented a house for years, it's your home!

Your lease creates the value, such as an anchor tenet in a commercial project.

The property would add value to your existing property.

You can't afford to buy the property today, but want it if the seller decides to sell it.

The seller doesn't want to sell today.

There are as many reasons to purchase the right of first refusal as there are to purchase real estate.

Like any other option there must be a consideration! The potential seller must receive something of value!

     The most common non-cash consideration is a tenant, where the right of first refusal is included in        a lease to induce tenancy.

     I've used the right of first refusal to protect my clients when buying part of a sellers property, as in buying a farm where the seller retains the homestead, this gives the buyer the potential to reunite the property. In which case the original sale is the consideration.

     I've used the right of first refusal to induce private lenders io invest in a property. Where the loan is the consideration.

     I've used the right of first refusal to induce investors into a minority position.

     I've used it to sooth family members when one heir inherits a family home. Here the settlement is the consideration.

Why would a property owner sell a right of first refusal on his property? Because they want the money! Because it cost them nothing, if they find a ready willing and able buyer, someone is going to buy.

What should be included in a right of first refusal?

You need to state the consideration and acknowledge it's recite.

You need to define the time allowed for the holder to exercise the option.

I've only once represented a seller offering the right of first refusal to the buyer, but I did once suggest offering one to a tenant for an extra $10,000.00 up-front.

From the buyer's point of view:

The right of first refusal must be recordable! Although, since I want signatures when I'm presenting the offer and rarely have a notary and witness available I included a paragraph allowing for me to record a memorandum.

          The right of first refusal must not be waived simply because it was not exercised on any given offer. If the proposed sale does not close your right continues.

(My REALTOR® friends are not going to like this one, but I'll make it up keep reading.)

Included that your right to purchase be based on the net proceeds from any offer, not including any concession, considerations, or brokerage fees! This will require the seller to exempt the holder on any future listing agreements, and accept any offers contingent on the right of first refusal not being exercised.

When you're acting as a REALTOR® I've included my commission, to be paid at closing if the option is exercised. (Am I forgiven?)

There is only two determents to a seller granting a right of first refusal.

     It will ad what ever time allowed for (normally 10 to 30 days) to the time necessary to close. The time to exercise the option starts when the fully executed offer is presented to the option holder.

    Some buyers are going to be put off by the extra time necessary to know if they've got a deal, but in this day of short sales taking months for approval the option period should pose little determent.

There is one big incentive, buyers knowing that a low offer will stimulate the option holder should make their highest and best offer.

Forgotten Real Estate. The Right Of First Refusal

is rarely seen today, it may be forgotten professionalism by residential REALTORS® that's a shame. Every one renting a single family house should ask for it.

Bill

William J Archambault Jr

The Real Estate Investment Institute

wja@reii.org      Cell 832-259-7078,      Houston 832-582-8415,       Las vegas 702-516-1569

     http://www.reii.org  Back Cover One House At A Time http:www//reii.org http://www.flippingforfunandprofit.info/ http://www.billarchambault.com   

From my past: GRI 1975, FLI 1974, Catalyst from a client 1974 an agent that makes things happen, REII, The Real Estate Investment Institute 1995.

http://www.reii.org

©William J Archambault Jr   ©The Real Estate Investment Institute   ©REII

 
This post has been included in Texas Real Estate News
Post is included in group: America's Best Agents
Post is included in group: Art of Professional Salesmanship
Post is included in group: Silent Majority
Post is included in group: The Ninety-ninth Percentile
Post is included in group: "Whacked"!!!

53 Comments on Forgotten Real Estate The Right Of First Refusal

DEC
10
2009
848,742 Points 153 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

I have a question?

I have a listing on 10 AC, nice house. There is a 10 Ac vacant parcel next door.

Almost every buyer that looked and considered purchasing wanted to buy the land next door. The seller doesn't want to sell.

But, he wrote a letter to my sellers on behalf of any new buyer purchasing his house, giving them right of first refusal if he decides to sell.

Is this binding or not?

I have it in writing.

11:37am • #1
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Missy,

You make my point! Thank you. I'm looking at a house now with the same scenario.

"Is this binding or not?"  It's not likely, there was no consideration. It's probably not witnessed, ether.

Offer the man a couple hundred bucks for a proper recordable right. If you haven't closed put it in the sales agreement, then the first sale is the consideration. Be sure to have a proper form executed at closing.

It's a great inducement for the house buyer and cost the seller nothing.

Bill

11:53am • #2
848,742 Points 153 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Thanks Bill we will do that.

No not witnessed but he typed it and then signed it. I will forward this post to my seller.

 

12:00pm • #3

Good information here Bill, not something that I come across a lot but sounds like you have some experiance with it.

12:03pm • #4
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Missy,

Any time!

I'm very comfortable talking about Michigan real estate, my offices were in Kalamazoo and Paw Paw for many years.

Good Luck.

Bill

12:03pm • #5
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Thanks James!

Yes, I've done many over the years. It's not something you'll ever do often.

Bill

12:06pm • #6
Attended Rain Camp

Hmmm.

I do wish I had seen this post a week ago.  I closed a deal Monday in which the buyer would have liked to purchase a corner cul-de-sac lot in front of his house, but could not do it financially at the time.

I belive I could have negotiated a first right for him and he would be protected.  Maybe I'll approach him about the posssibility.

12:42pm • #7

I just took a listing and which put a first right of refusal on for the neighbors.  Thanks!

12:50pm • #8
548,980 Points 110 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Sir William...

You're on a roll. Great topic. The right of first refusal has bought and sold many homes in our area. It's one of those little tiny facts learned in real estate class. The knowledge seems to slip away from most Salespeople. Leave it you to bring this front and center. Good for you. The past is sometimes the best way to go forward :) 

TLW...ROAR!

1:10pm • #9
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Jean,

Sorry. I'd been thinking about this for awhile.

It may not be to late for your buyer, but it will cost him more, I'm sure. Talk to him.

Good Luck!

Bill

1:27pm • #10
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Well done Jeff!

You're welcome.

Please keep us all informed when this sells and the affect of the option.

Bill

1:29pm • #11
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Reverend Billy,

I've been rolling for several decades, but it's always good to be recognized by one's pastor. Thank you.

Real estate is all just "little tiny facts"  the big thing are how they're combined by and for people.

I'm often concerned over those real estate classes.

Bill

1:35pm • #12
Outside Blog

very informative not something I come across much but I learned something today ;-)

2:03pm • #13
937,499 Points 361 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Bill, Right of First Refusal in quite common in my area. Mostly used when a buyer has contingencies in a contract that the seller feels will be difficult to remove. i.e most close on another property before they can close on this one. The seller may very well agree to sell to them but if they find another buyer the original buyer has 48 hours to remove the contingencies and move towards closing or the seller can sell to the new buyer.

We also have First Right of Refusal on Disney timeshares. Disney reserves the right to step in and purchase any resale. They do this to keep the values up. They won't allow a sale that's too low. This s a great deal for the owners as it keeps values very high.

 

2:08pm • #15
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Bryant,

That's a great use I've done the same giving 48 or 72 hours to preform or get off the pot.

I've gone through allot of time shares to make change or sweeten an exchange, but never brokered them. I have used this to to buy back subdivision lots and condos to keep out other builders out. I've used it on development projects to keep clients from double escrowing me. It's just a tool to use for yourself and your clients.

As to keeping prices up, I'm not so sure a sale is a sale even one to the holder of a right of first refusal.

Bill

2:22pm • #16
210,150 Points 1 Featured Post Called Shot Master

Good to be reminded of such little tools in our bag that we don't often use, but should know how to use and pull out when appropriate.  Thanks for sharing.

3:13pm • #17
1,049,678 Points 177 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Good for bringing this up. You brushed up my real estat eknowledge this afternoon.

3:37pm • #18
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Drick,

You'e welcome. Glad you enjoyed it.

Bill

4:05pm • #19
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Loreena,

Always good to hear from you.

A little brush up is always good for all of us.

Bill

4:08pm • #20
924,788 Points 97 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Bill the "Right of First Refusal" was very common in Condo Complexes around here, and even thought I understand the advantages to the "Right of First Refusal" it was a major obstical on FHA Loans.  Come Febuary it will no longer be an obsitcal, but right now with Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac making Condo Loans very hard to do unless the Borrower has 10% or more to put down, it is causing problems for Condo owners who can't seem to find Buyers with that kind of money.  Even with 20% Down Fannie is still hitting the Borrower with .750 points regardless of how good their Credit Scores are.

4:48pm • #21

Bill,

My husband uses this frequently for land and farm deals but I never thought about its potential for residential real estate. Thanks for enlightening us!

4:59pm • #22
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

George,

I'm baffled! How is the right of first refusal a problem for the lender? By the time the lender sees the loan package they are only dealing with one buyer.

Bill

5:06pm • #23
202,016 Points 14 Featured Posts Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

You raise a good point that all contracts for real estate must be in writing to be enforceable and must be recorded to properly put the public "on notice" of your right of first refusal.  However, most lawyers would agree that you need to add some "teeth" to the RoFR to make sure that the other party presents the property to you in good faith and at the same terms (or better) than they would any other third party in an arm's length transaction (not bad for a non-lawyer, huh?).

Developers that use RoFR for timeshares and condominiums are indeed trying to support (and inflate?) prices for unsold units.  It's not good to be the last one holding a RoFR when the Developer sells out, because market values often fall suddenly and deeply.  Just another form of market manipulation that the average Joe can't get away with, but the Developers can.

5:06pm • #24
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Irene,

Yor're welcome.

I learned to use it from Chapter # 1 of The Farm and Land Institute. Those FLI brokers didn't know it use was limited! They only knew it solved a people problem.

Then I went to the CCIM's marketing group and they taught me to do it right.

When I got home there ware always home buyers, so I used what I'd learned!

We can learn allot from each other! That's why I love AR.

Bill

5:16pm • #25
688,780 Points 117 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Called Shot Master

Bill,

I used to be in the building business, and I tied up more than one property with a Right of First Refusal, to the seller's joy and my benefit.  Congrats on the feature!

Mike in Tucson

5:17pm • #26
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Martin,

Love your logo.

I'm not an attorney ether! Just a simple old banker, REALTOR, developer, mortgage broker turned teacher. I have written more real estate contracts than most attorneys and they do hold up! I've never had one beaten and attorneys have tried.

I didn't included a contract, I can't do that unless I'm part of the deal, sorry. See your attorney or if you have the experience a legal forums store.

Good real estate attorneys know "teeth" scare off the other side! This requires only a friendly contract with all the right information. When you record it you cloud the title and that's all the bight you need.

Thanks for your comment.

Bill

5:32pm • #27
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Thanks Mike!

It is a simple but extremely powerful tool powerful tool, that works to every ones benafit.

Bill

5:40pm • #28
144,532 Points 1 Featured Post

Wow!  Very interesting Missy & Bill.  Thanks for the informative post and the comments.  Definitely something to keep in mind for the future if this ever arises.  Thanks again and Happy Holidays to both of you!

5:58pm • #29
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Joyce,

Please, allow me to say thank you for both Missy and myself.

Bill

6:01pm • #30
924,788 Points 97 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Bill because in order to do a loan on a Condo the Condo Complex either needs to be FHA approved or it needs to meet the requirements for a Spot Approval.  In both cases the Condo Management Firm will have to fill out a questionnaire before the loan is approved, and one of the questions is do the Condo By-Laws contain a "Right of First Refusal" clause.  If it does FHA will not insure the loan, because they view the "Right of First Refusal" as a restriction on Buyer to Sell.  Therefore if they should have to foreclose, it becomes a restriction on there right to sell.  This obstacle is being removed once the new FHA Condo Guideline Approval goes into affect in February, but up until now it has been a major headache.

6:14pm • #31
368,302 Points 38 Featured Posts Outside Blog Hit Router Called Shot Master

Bill - That is a thorough study and presentation.  Thanks for bringing "Right of First Refusal" to light again.

7:14pm • #32
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

George,

This is one of those "Well DA!!!!" moments!

I knew that about FHA. I just didn't think about the condo HOA.

This is why comments make these blogs so much better!

Thank you for responding to my mistake.

Bill

PS: Brenda allows me two mistakes a month I'd saved up 9 this year until this. Darn!!

7:33pm • #33
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Wendy,

Thank you! But, it's tit for tat (Can I say that to a lady?) I follow your short sale blogs!

I see you and Bryant are doing another class, I'd highly recomend it, but he left Houston off his little red balloon map and I'm miffed.  >:)

Good luck anyway!

Bill

Check it out and reggester at:  Are You a Serious Short Sale Professional? If so...come join us.  Please tell Bryan, Bill deserves a balloon!

7:37pm • #34
1,178,409 Points 133 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

ROCK ON!!  I was just remembering this yesterday, from my days of being licensed in Nebraska!  I have one threatening to fall out again and I can't wait to use the 72 hour first right of refusal on the next contract.  I bet agents are going to say "huh?"

9:05pm • #35
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Renee,

Over the last 21 years lots of Las Vegas agents said  "huh?"  to offers I influenced! But, they closed!

I spent 4 years on their eduction committee have you ever heard 23 people say "huh?" in three part harmony?

Please keep us informed.

Good luct.

Bill

9:13pm • #36
379,177 Points 49 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Called Shot Master

Bill, Excellent post. My first broker taught me to add a rider to condo and coop subleases that gives the renter/tenant first right of refusal if the owner decides to sell during the term of the lease. My commission is included in the rider if a sale is consummated. Twice I've had renters end up buying the unit and I got paid without having to do any work on the sale.

I know what George is referring to. In NYC 99% of condos have in their bylaws that the condo board has first right of refusal. A condo sale can't close until the condo board issues a waiver. I only know of one condo that has excersized their right of first refusal. The condo board has to buy the unit from the seller for the same price and terms in the contract of sale. Because of that restrictive contingency, FHA loans have been a problem in NYC. Some of the new construction condos that have applied for FHA financing are removing the first right of refusal from their offering plans.

9:23pm • #37
290,486 Points 14 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

I thought most of this information was common sense, but I admit I've never seen a specific blog about it.

9:47pm • #38
1,007,488 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

This is definitely something worthy of consideration, especially in the situations you have discussed above.  It makes a lot of sense for a tenant to request the right, particularly when it doesn't cost them anything.

11:44pm • #39
DEC
11
2009
418,899 Points 3 Featured Posts

I think that most landlords are very reluctant to grant a right of first refusal to a tenant because it does severely hamper their attempt to market the property. I sometimes have had success in negotiating a right of first offer, which means that when the landlord wants to sell that he must first negotiate with the tenant, and if an acceptable price is not negotiated, then the landlord may then attempt to sell , but only for a price greater than the offer made by the landlord. Typical provisions include providing that the landlord is not required to resubmit an offer, once rejected by the tenant, except for specific threshold changes (such as a price reduction by more than "x"percent), and the reduced offer from the third party must be submitted to the tenant essentially as a right of first refusal at that point.

This often is much more palatable to a landlord, as after negotiating a potential sale with the tenant ( who the landlord should be willing to negotiate with first as they are the logical buyer for the property ) but with no sale agreed to, if the landlord believes that he can sell the property for more than the tenant is willing to pay,  the landlord is free to market the property with the knowledge that he can market the property unencumbered as long as the price exceeds the last offer extended to the tenant.

3:15am • #40
320,285 Points 5 Featured Posts Outside Blog

You are so right in the fact that we don't see this much anymore. In the past it was much more common.

4:59am • #41
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Mitchel,

Thank you!

You had a good broker.

I too know what George was talking about. When I read his first comment I totally missed the point. But, bloggs get better with the comments and George regularly improves my bloggs.

Bill

5:51am • #42
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Aaron,

Most real estate bloggs are just "common sense" remembered.

Thanks for saying so.

Bill

5:57am • #43
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Maureen,

I think most landlords have never heard of the right of first refusal. I also think most tell the potential tenant they don't intend to sell, that's the key to presenting this, it doesn't obligate the owner to sell or set a price! It only grants the holder an opportunity if the landlord should decided to sell at a price someone would pay.

I'd have to study your proposal it sounds overly complicated, but I'm in favor of anything that helps your client.

Bill

6:08am • #45
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Laura,

Thank you.

It's a shame that more people don't understand and use it.

Bill

6:10am • #46
DEC
12
2009
118,333 Points 2 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Great post.  Things to remember for sure.  Thank you!

12:08pm • #47
JAN
05
2010
402,631 Points 40 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Hi Bill...Didn't think of a Contingency with a Kick Out (used when the buyer needs to sell another property first) as a First Right of Refusal.  I have certainly used the Cont K/O.

Thanks for the post.  Very interesting.

Kate

10:14pm • #48
JAN
06
2010
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Kathleen,

"a Contingency with a Kick Out" I've never heard it expressed this way, but what ever we call it, it's a powerful tool.

Bill

7:00am • #50
518,492 Points 5 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

THis is interesting. I'll try to find a reason to use this soon. It looks like a good way to get people moving.

10:58am • #51
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Larry,

Please let us all know, what you do with it.

Bill

11:09am • #52
447,918 Points 36 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Readers,

Larry got me thinking. You might want to read: An Idea For Reluctant Sellers

Bill

12:31pm • #53

This blog does not allow anonymous comments

 
Ar129174692605647 Ambassador_large

William J Archambault Jr

Houston, TX

More about me…

The Real Estate Investment Institute

Address: The Real Estate Investment Institute, 448 W. 19TH St. Suite 245, Houston, TX, 77008

Office Phone: (702) 516-1569

Cell Phone: (832) 259-7078

Email Me

Sage real estate and mortgage information, from the man at The Real Estate Investment Institute.

http://www.twitterbuttons.com
By TwitterButtons.com


Listings

Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find TX real estate agents and Houston real estate on ActiveRain.