The American Dream, Let's Share It

Thank you Maureen, Christopher, Dawn and Marcus.   William, thank you for your comments.  Your point about non citizens buying property here is important - even if they don't have resident status they can still buy. There are a number of countries that don't allow foreigners to own land, or have restrictions.

I'm sure we probably disagree on enforcement, whereas your position is "those who don't should meet the long arm of the law and be denied ever seeking citizenship".  I would probably be less harsh.  Hypothetical example: Someone comes here legally on a temporary Visa. Their status changes and they are now illegal. They own a business, own real estate and are extremely productive and valuble members of our society.  But they are illegal immigrants and they get caught. Do we deport them to uphold the law, despite the loss of their valuble presence in our country.  My solution would be: fix their status and make them legal.  Even if someone comes here illegally for a better life, I think denying them citizenship or entry to our country for life is a bit harsh.  However, I think the laws should be strictly enforced to deport criminals and prevent reentry.  Fortunately, people come here for opportunity, not to commit crime.

Interestingly, I can walk into Mexico, no questions asked, but have to wait in long lines to come back to the U.S.  We have much higher crime rates then Mexico, and most of the rest of the world for that matter.  Logically then, other countries should be more restrictive of American visitors then we are of them.