Regrettably, many people have come to identify Matthew Cox as the face of greed in the industry.  I'm pretty sure that everyone reading this post has heard of him.  While it's true Cox is an infamous and notorious criminal, his profile more closely resembles that of a street thug than it does the typical white collar criminal. 

The truth about real estate fraud is hidden in countless files, in countless offices, in countless cities and towns across the nation.

 A recent arrest in California accurately illustrates the fraud that routinely infects real estate transactions.  A 34 year old woman stands accused of abusing her notary privileges.  She notarized a single document that was ultimately recorded even though it contained a forged signature.  The authorities place a great deal of importance on a notary commission, as should you.  Notary abuse, a common element in fraud cases, undermines the integrity of court documents.

The California case is notable for a number of reasons.

They are:

  • The arrest was initiated by officials for a local jurisdiction, San Bernardino County.  Until recently, real estate crime was primarily the purview of federal authorities due to it's sophistication and the prosecutorial intricacies. 
  • The press release mentions nothing about a financial loss to any individual or financial institution. 
  • The criminal charges stem from a single act, not from a pattern of actions affecting a number of properties.
For the real estate professional, the appearance of impropriety is equivalent to committing a crime.  This woman's career has ended regardless of the outcome of the proceedings. 

No one wants to believe that the person sitting in the adjoining cubicle is capable of committing a crime.  They are after all a colleague and a friend.  We eat lunch with them while talking about the things that everyone talks about over lunch.  Mortgage fraudsters look like us, live in the same community as us, and go to the same church as us.

Fraudsters often believe that they won't get caught or that they can talk themselves out of any situation.  Sometime they convince themselves that an act isn't serious enough to elicit a consequential response by authorities. 

Many corporations now closely examine a prospective employee's driving history before making a hiring decision.  A patten of past parking tickets or moving offenses often points to an "above the law" type personality trait.

Women, like the notary mentioned above, go to prison every day for committing white collar crimes.  Often, they're mothers leaving children behind.

There's a general misconception that real estate fraud is prosecuted only when it's highly orchestrated, involves major losses, and has wide spread implications.  It's simply untrue. 

 

30 Comments on The Ambiguous Face of Greed

JUL
10
2007
141,523 Points 14 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
Wow- add some fuzz to the guys face and he's a ringer for Charles Manson, don't you think?  I had a neighbor's son stop in to do some work on the house, and he mentioned that his friend, new to the mortgage industry, was looking to partner with real estate agents.  He said that his friend would pay the real estate agents for business directed to him.  This is a KID talking innocently- I have to wonder if his mortgage broker friend (also 21 or 22)  is aware of the implications.
4:41pm • #1
And not to mention the selfishness at puting co workers and the whole business under investigation...Hopefully better licensing will help.
4:43pm • #2
409,999 Points 72 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Ed...

For as many years as I have been in this business I have come to understand that will always be someone willing to committ fraud for the sake of the almighty dollar.

We used to live next door to a guy that committed forgery on a life insurance policy. The guy turned states evidence and the charges were dropped.

Yah. I know that sucks. He's still out there and more than likely learned nothing more than how to use his free "get out of jail" card.

TLW...ROAR!

4:48pm • #3
582,473 Points 95 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router
Ed, that is a shame and I know it happens daily. Do you think most people are innocent ? Not the experienced agents and lenders but new ones.
4:56pm • #4
42 Featured Posts

Laurie

This guy Matthew Cox is the prototype of a notorious criminal.  I encounter people all the time that seem to have no clue that they're committing fraud.   Even after learning otherwise, they often remain indifferent.  As you suggest, awareness of the consequences is hopefully the key.  Thanks for stopping by.

4:57pm • #5
42 Featured Posts

Chuck

Thanks for raising a number of great points.  Mortgage fraud has far reaching implications and hurts many innocent people.  And, tougher licensing and continuing education requirements definitely makes sense.   

5:00pm • #6
4 Featured Posts

Wow, fascinating article on Cox.  We see a lot of potential fraud with hard money.  I'm guilty of being very trusting and am continually surprised when I find someone has lied.  Thanks for a very interesting post.

5:15pm • #7
42 Featured Posts

TLW

I have to agree.  The stories that I hear are truly frightening.  Thanks for sharing your thoughts. 

5:16pm • #8

Thanks for the info. I got totally immersed in the linked article on Mathew Cox. What a character.

5:22pm • #9
42 Featured Posts

Missy

Unfortunately, I believe that most people are very guilty.  There is, of course, a fine line when novices are improperly trained. 

5:28pm • #10
42 Featured Posts

Melody

I'm very guilty of trusting others as well.  It has gotten me into more trouble than I can say.  Thanks for commenting. 

5:32pm • #11
42 Featured Posts

Grant

You can say that again about Matthew Cox.  He's dangerous, that's for certain. 

5:36pm • #12
105,124 Points 2 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Ed - What a charachter......I have to admit I had not heard of him. The abuses in our industry have become rampant in recent years. I have seen those who started in real estate imagining they would have a very lucrative career, then turn to small acts of dishonesty for the almighty dollar. Once a person turns that corner, it is another small step to more serious crimes.
8:17pm • #13
42 Featured Posts

Paula

There's no question that small acts of impropriety often give way to more heinous types of behavior.   We see it all the time in title company's when employees think nothing of forging signatures and all of a sudden money's missing from an escrow account.  Corporate boundaries are so very important.  There's a right way and there's a wrong way.  Thanks for commenting.

8:40pm • #14
173,945 Points 17 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Ed,

I can't imagine any of the people I know in my real estate market committing any kind of fraud, but statistically it's gotta be happening.  Thanks for continuing to stress the importance of being on the look out for fraud and abuse.

Fran

8:48pm • #15
JUL
11
2007
42 Featured Posts

Fran

You're very welcome.   White collar crime is very difficult to accept because the perpetrators look just like us. 

5:23am • #16
370,774 Points 62 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Funny that you post this.  I had a past customer ask me for listing to take to a friend he is visiting out of state.  I said no problem.  Then he asked for a finders fee, and he's unlicensed.  Uh, no way!
6:00am • #17
149,877 Points 7 Featured Posts Outside Blog

What is amazing, is the number of people willing to trust a stranger for the promise of a quick buck.

 

10:37am • #18
109,021 Points 11 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Hi Ed,

I saw your comments on another blog and decided I had to come for a visit. I read your interesting profile. I think that we are headed for a major crack-down on mortgage fraud and they are going to use the short sale process to gather evidence. I've writen a couple articles on short sales. I would really appreciate your visiting my blog and commenting.

Thank you for what you are doing.

Bill Roberts

11:48am • #19
215,238 Points 16 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Ed, Thanks for this enlightenment.
Interesting, I didn't realize mortgage fraud was that widespread.  We have just started learning about it and taking courses on it in the past few years here in Ontario.  Now it seems I am constantly reading about new mortgage fraud schemes to watch for in our industry's journals and enewsletters. Some of the scenarios are very frightening !

Jo 

1:03pm • #20
42 Featured Posts

Chris

The improprieties are everywhere.  Matters are getting worse, not better.

4:02pm • #21
42 Featured Posts

Tom

That's a great point.   

4:04pm • #22
42 Featured Posts

Bill

You're very welcome.  I'll take a look at your blog. 

4:05pm • #23
42 Featured Posts

Hi Jo

There's definitely a worsening problem in Canada.  Last fall, I sat on a panel at an international symposium where Canada was well represented. 

4:07pm • #24
JUL
12
2007
13 Featured Posts
Ed - good post.  But the link was fascinanting.  I had not heard the story. I'm always amazed at the creativity out there.
10:24pm • #25
JUL
15
2007
144,154 Points 7 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Ed,

Thanks for the post. Unfortunately, greed gets the best of far too many people. Hopefully, this young ladies p[light will help to be a disincentive.

I also wanted to thank you for stopping by To Be 50 Plus In The Rain. 

 

 

7:48am • #26
100,090 Points 20 Featured Posts
Ed. Never quite understood what part of conflict of interest is so difficult to understand..
2:51pm • #27
42 Featured Posts

Chris

I'm glad you enjoyed the post.  Matthew Cox is definitely an intriguing and frightening character. 

3:24pm • #28
42 Featured Posts

William

Thanks for the comment and I always look forward to your posts. 

3:28pm • #29
42 Featured Posts

Kaye

It's clearly a more elusive concept for some than it is for others.  Thanks for stopping by. 

3:30pm • #30

Leave a response…



(optional)
What does the graphic say?
 
Rainmaker_large

Ed Rybczynski

Havre de Grace, MD

More about me…

Jos. A. Bank Clothiers

Email Me

Havre de Grace

zenith

lantern queen

Twitter me @edryb

Facebook me!

View Ed Rybczynski's profile on LinkedIn



Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find MD real estate agents and Havre de Grace real estate on ActiveRain.