Special offer

Does anybody know of a "BPO Mill" for short sales??? HELP!

By
Real Estate Agent with Keller Williams

For the last FIVE short sales I had an agent that has done EVERYONE of my BPOs.  That made me say hmmmm.....

Then ALL five were DENIED.  So, when the first one went to sale and I lost it I called the bank.  Let me give you an example.  I have the house listed at $110,000.  First offer $95,000 REJECTED.  Second offer $103,000.  It would make sense that the BPO would come in around $110,000.  I have comps to prove it.  The bank would accept roughly 90% at worst....

I called the agent yesterday.  He claims that the BPO company is telling him to use FAIR MARKET comps.  He told me that our market was not REO driven because it was not 50% REO.....

I say that the property is a short sale.......which is a distressed property.  Therefore, the comps used should be REO and short sale comps.

What I think burned me more than anything is he says, "I do 10 BPOs a day."  My response, "In a balanced market there would not be such a high number of BPOs in our area."  WORSE, "I do not care about your sellers.  Let them go into foreclosure.  You aren't doing your job if you cant save them.  I am here to provide for my family and don't really care about your clients." 

Now, for those of you that may say I was trying to influence the BPO.  That was not my objective.  There were no active BPOs to discuss.  I called to come from contribution.  I really wanted to know WHY!!!!!  If his overpriced BPO is going to stand in the way of a foreclosure then I owe that to my seller to let them know there will be obstacles.

THANKS FOR LETTING ME RANT.

Now, HELP!!!!!

1.  What company do you think he is working with?

2.  Would I be crossing the line to call them to see what there "standards" are for short sales?

3.  Any other suggestions would be greatly appreciated! 

4.  He is actually working for the bank, isnt he doing them a disservice to over price the house?  Some of them are a month from foreclosure........

 

THANKS ACTiVE RAIN!

Bill Carroll
Corcoran Real Estate - Westhampton, NY
IN REAL ESTATE, REPRESENTATION IS EVERYTHING

Hi Katie, sounds like your in a rough spot.  What confuses me about this guy is he is probably using the same comps you are. The bank wants fair market comps, but comps are comps,no? Is it permissable to attach comps to the offer?

Jan 21, 2010 11:30 PM
Brian Brumpton
Keller Williams Boise - Boise, ID
Boise Idaho Real Estate

Katie,

Do enough short sales and you're likely to get burned by a BPO agent or two.  Our state law says you have to be a Broker to provide a BPO, however most are agents.  If your laws are the same you could always let your real estate commission have a crack at him.

There are a million companies that offer these services to lenders.  Technically he's working for them, not the lender.  If the lender catches on that after the properties values vs. what they're getting at auction or after and REO sale, the company sending him the business may end up losing the banks BPO business.

I've had pretty good luck with sending in comps to the negotiator to prove the BPO was out of line.  Keep in mind, the negotiator is not a real estate professional, you are.  Sometimes you have educate them just like your clients about the realities of the market.

Jan 21, 2010 11:31 PM
Harry F. D'Elia III
WEDO Real Estate and Beyond, LLC - Phoenix, AZ
Investor , Mentor, GRI, Radio, CIPS, REOs, ABR

Is this agent taking into consideration repairs on the property? It is great to have fair market comps when the property has been updated

Jan 21, 2010 11:35 PM
Katie Evans
Keller Williams - Greenville, NC

Harry, No he is not considering repairs I do not think...cause I seem to get the DOGS!!!  Well, they just seem to be in poor condition.  I will combat this with hiring a home inspector with I list the property from now on so that I know what needs to be addressed.

Brian, It is Safeguard.  I called every bank this morning and asked them who they were using.  They will not tell you value but they will tell you I did call and complain to them about his "lack of ethics"  so I feel a little better....hehehehe! 

You are so right.  I have used those tricks too!  It just feels like sabotage with its effecting ALL your short sale at once!!!

Hampton, I attached my one BPO along with repair estimate and feedback summary. 

Jan 22, 2010 03:11 AM
Anonymous
Sylvia

Many of the BPO companies now ask for fair market comps.  They do not want any short sale comps ! I disagree in many cases but not all.  It looks like many short sales are going to be killed since now on...

 

Sep 01, 2011 04:35 AM
#5