Ar_home_b_search
 

Dreaming of a new homeAs Green Building begins to reach out and grasp the attention of consumers, builders, lenders, etc. - The terms commonly used appear to be getting used interchangeably.  I think this is creating confusion and misunderstanding.  It is very important to understand the marketing behind the words. 

I was speaking with a builder earlier today about Residential Construction in the Green Community and we were talking about the differences between certain products.  I thought it would be a good topic to write on.  Here are the items that jumped out at me.

When Green Building first started it brought together many topics.  Environmentally Friendly, Energy Efficient, Recycled Products, Low Toxin and other products that are considered to make a Healthier Environment.  Now that the number of products available grows, we are seeing various new categories develop:

  • Energy-Efficient- a good example would be Energy Star
  • High Performance- a good example would be one built with ICF's
  • Green- built with a variety of products
  • Homes with a mix of these.  One example would be LEEDwhere it starts with design like a High Performance Home and can use Green products such as Low VOC Paints, Recycled Flooring, Solar Tube, Solar Panels, etc.  Follow the link above to learn more about LEED Certified homes.

Now, for the difference between a High Performance Home and a Green Home.  Can a home be both of these, absolutely, and often times they are.  The purpose of this post is to be able to understand what the difference is between a home marketed as a High Performance Home and  Green Home.

JaneAnne Narrin of EcoSteward Realty in North Carolina wrote and excellent post on High Performance Homes that I invite you to read.  To summarize, the High Performance Home starts with design.  These homes are going to be a very Tight Construction called the "envelope".  Due to the tight "envelope" the home will need more attention to Air Circulation and transfer of indoor/outdoor air.  Indoor Air Quality (IAQ).  Here are the some of the key points for a High Performance Home:

  • Energy Efficiency
  • Water Efficiency
  • Indoor Air Quality Efficiency
  • Site Planning and Lot Development
  • Homeowner Education

These homes are what I would call, with my slang, an Ultra Efficient Home.  You will see a difference in your Utility Savings and there should be a significant reduction in allergy and asthma symptoms.  Believe it or not High Performance Homes built with Insulated Concrete Forms have shown that the larger the home, the more efficient it is.  Typically these will not have Wood Framing which also makes the Fire Rating of these homes amazing.

Now, a GREEN Home.  We have gone in past years from GREEN being only Environmentally Safe Products, then Green was affected some by Greenwashing, and now Green Products are even more environmentally safe than typical products (i.e. recycled, less wasteful manufacturing, etc) and we are finding they are better for us too.   Thus making the difference between a High Performance Home and a GREEN Home.  Here are some things you might find on/in a GREEN Home:

  • Some WILL have wood framing
  • Bamboo or Recycled Flooring
  • Perhaps Recycled Insulation
  • GreyWater System (capturing rain water for household use)
  • GeoThermal Technology
  • Special Roofing Materials

This is just a SHORT list.  But you will see that a GREEN HOME uses materials that are really GREEN, like the recycled products.  These will also be Energy Efficient while utilizing Environmentally Friendly Products.

As I said earlier, there will be homes that combines features from both systems. I hope that I have cleared up some of the confusion so that now when you see High Performance Home or GREEN Built Home, hopefully you will have some ideas on what to look for.  If you are wanting to build, pick out the aspects that are most important to you.  It doesn't have to be one or the other.  It could be Hybrid so to speak.

For an update on this post, Please CLICK HERE.

 

45 Comments on The Difference Between High Performance and Green Homes

JUL
18
2007
200,475 Points 57 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Let me know if you have any questions. If I don't know the answer, I will find one.  :)

Thanks Mary for your help!

5:23pm • #1
2 Featured Posts

Stephanie! It looks great! I'm glad you posted this because these terms do tend to get confusing! 

You make a very important point, "If you are wanting to build, pick out the aspects that are most important to you.  It doesn't have to be one or the other. "

What works for you in Texas where you have a lot of heat may not work so well for me in Michigan where we have 4 seasons and very little sunshine during the winter months!

Excellent post! 

5:29pm • #2
200,475 Points 57 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
Thanks Mary, this is so true...about the seasons.  We have 2.  REALLT hot summer, and spring.  :)  Thanks for your help, I really appreciate it.
5:31pm • #3
200,847 Points 11 Featured Posts
Stephanie, I thought these terms where the same, I am so glad you wrote this post. I am getting educated here.
7:47pm • #4
200,475 Points 57 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
Hi Mana, many of these terms were the same at one point in time...but we are starting to see separate subjects now.  That was my conversation with the builder.  I guess the point was that in the future it could be misleading...?  I'm glad it helped explain it.
8:08pm • #5
1 Featured Post
Stephanie - thanks for being "my" eco-broker - you are a wealth of GREEN info for the Houston Marketplace
8:24pm • #6
200,475 Points 57 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
Thanks Jack!  I got a bunch of GREAT Blogging info from builders this week.  I'll be having fun with it.
8:26pm • #7
482,702 Points 53 Featured Posts Outside Blog Called Shot Master
Stephanie--This is great information! Thanks for explaining. They are running a series on Green homes on a local news channel and it is very interesting the many different processes and products that are being used in new and remodeled homes.
8:38pm • #8
200,475 Points 57 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
Hi Teri, that would be interesting to watch!  It is all fascination to me. 
8:42pm • #9
1 Featured Post

Stephanie,

A lot of these products are great products whether they are green or not!  Bamboo floors are just beautiful.  Geothermal heat can slash your energy bill in half or more depending on where you live.  I hope some of these like geothermal heat become more accepted so that the initial price comes down.  Right now the high initial cost of some of these items deters many buyers and builders from using them. 

9:45pm • #10
200,475 Points 57 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
Hi Rita, I agree.  :)  That's why I say these procucts are designed more for the consumer than the environment.  In a way.  The positive points compliment each other.  Thanks for stopping by.
10:10pm • #11
128,653 Points 2 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Stephanie - Thanks for educating on "Green" I had not heard much about it before AR. It is fascinating!
11:11pm • #12
JUL
19
2007
315,612 Points 12 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
Stephanie - I'm not sure the line is as easily set.  There's an awful lot of crossover between "high performace" and (subsequently) "green" homes.  To me, a "green" home is designed to work against the high consumption of energy resources...that's the simple answer.  A "high performance" home also fits that bill, just for slightly different reasons.  The processes and materials you cite can be incorporated into both models. 
12:21am • #13
308,624 Points 28 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp
great info Stephanie, I am fortunate enough to have an ICF builder in my back yard.... great information
1:14am • #14
198,363 Points 12 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp
Stephanie, Great information, but spawned a bunch of questions in my mind.  A couple right off the top...why is bamboo a greener choice than wood and are tankless water heaters showing up in these green homes?  That seems to be one of our largest shifts and people don't appreciate them as much as I think they should...
7:44am • #15
200,475 Points 57 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Hi Paula, I'm glad it helped.

Hey Thesa, you are very fortunate. :)  Thanks.

Hi Chris, I still think there are a lot of misconceptions regarding green..like price.  For instance, one can buy a High Performance Home for about 10% more, sometimes less.  So, on a 200,000 home it would be 20,000.  (just because I like round numbers) ...how much would that affect mortgage?  and the utility bills would be maybe...I've seen different reports..45% less.  I think it is all about educating the consumer. 

Ok..Jeff,  I waited because I thought this might be a long one.  :)  My conversation with the builder yesterday morning was along the same lines.  It really is not that clear cut.  I agree. There are many homes that have both characteristics.  We were talking about how green and high performance homes were being thrown in to the same basket....which is starting to give a misleading name to "green" homes and how High Performance Homes are really breaking off on to their own group.  I challenged this a little as well, but it made a lot of sense.  Should I change this somehow.

8:39am • #16

Stephanie,

Thanks for clarifying the two. I see a lot of builders advertising green homes now I can really pick out which ones are green and which ones are high performance.

9:20am • #17
2 Featured Posts

Hi Stephanie -

I'm just reviewing notes from my conference with Mike Holcolmb. Mike was instrumental in putting together Green Built (TM) Michigan.

We had a very similar discussion and when I asked his definition of "Green" his reply was,

"Green is a collection of things. A system for energy efficiency. "Green" homes are designed and constructed to ensure

  1. thermal performance,
  2. occupant health and
  3. reduced environmental footprint.

The program used for certification will have recognizable and measurable controls to insure that it meets a set standard." Standards for programs are derived by consensus from a community of individuals.

A Green home must address the needs of the occupant, as you said in your article. Mike feels the biggest factors to the occupant would be

  1. budget
  2. family health

(not neccesarily in that order).

Again, just one individual opinion.

I think your article creates a very good awareness that we all have different ideas about "green" and "high performance". The comments you have received also reflect that.  We need to be careful not to become too specific in our classifications.  It's all good!

10:18am • #18
200,475 Points 57 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Hi Mary,  I agree.  I thought this would be a good way for people to know the difference when a home is being marketed as either a "High Performance Home" or a "Green Built Home".  There are many builders that are going in between, which is great. 

I just wanted to put this out there.  With all of the recent talk regarding High Performance Homes I thought people may want to know a little about why it's somewhat different.

By the way, did all of you read the article regarding ICF's in EcoStructure Magazine this month?  It's a GREAT article. 

10:37am • #19
566,349 Points 79 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Stephanie~ 

Now THIS is quite an interesting and informative post...I know a batch  o' REALTORS (of the ECO kind) who would love to see this all plotted-out and numbered and with a rating scale attached.

3:42pm • #21
890,447 Points 20 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master
Stephanie thank you for the clarification.  I think most of the customers I encounter and who express a desire for a green property is really looking for a Hybrid based on criteria given to me.   I live down the road from the Greenest house in the Northeast, and I have had the opportunity to tour it several times.  Based on your post it is really a hybrid.  I might be getting the opportunity to work on a green project so don.t be surprise if I call you with a question.
3:47pm • #22
880,148 Points 210 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Called Shot Master
I have sooo much to learn! I guess Hawaii would really have a different criteria as well.
4:05pm • #23
200,475 Points 57 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Thanks Wayne and Linda!

Hi JaneAnne, that would be a great idea wouldn't it.  :)  I am working on some pretty neat posts right now.  I have had an amazing week and received a lot of GREAT blog fodder. 

Hi Jennifer, you are probably right.  Homes can have BOTH features, but because of instances like what you are saying...it's exactly what the builder was talking about the other day.  Hybrid Homes is a builder in MI but he has THE PERFECT name for it.  You can contact me anytime with questions.  I'll help the best I can.  Good Luck with it.

Hey Sally, I bet Hawaii is doing some great stuff too.  I'll try to find a good product for you to go see there. 

5:33pm • #24
312,577 Points 11 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Stephanie, I'd like to invite everybody who is reading this to push themselves into learning more. I went to the Sellsuis Blog tour yesterday and everybody instantly identified me as "The Ecobroker". A few people asked me great questions or shared their information with me. But education is the key! And to be perfectly honest I'm not sure there is one correct answer - this is why we need push to learn more.
6:00pm • #25
1,254,469 Points 242 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

This is a very educational post. Thank you for all the work you put into this post. 

Chris- Bamboo is a greener choice because it is a renewable energy source. It can be harvested and regrows very fast! I am not sure of the stats but it is amazing!

We have the tankless water heaters and love them! We live in Florida and they work very well here because the ground temp water is warm. The same is true for Hawaii. In fact the company we bought them from are in Hawaii and Florida.  

6:56pm • #26
200,475 Points 57 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
Thanks Katerina.  Glad to hear you like your Tankless Water Heaters.  I want one.  :)
7:35pm • #27
312,577 Points 11 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Nestor and Katerina, (if I may Stephanie) Bamboo is great stuff and that is why you see it being used in so many ways around the world. But for a green choice make sure your flooring, furniture, blinds or what ever are put together with VOC free products like finish and glue.
7:35pm • #28
9 Featured Posts
Thank you Stephanie for some great info - more and more buyers are "green" aware and this a nice presentation.
8:11pm • #29
200,475 Points 57 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Hi Dena, by all means...please!  :)  I'm learning more about Bamboo floors right now.  Add anytime.  My fellow EcoBroker!

Hi Beth, Green is hitting many areas of the nation right now so it's important that we as agents stay informed as well.  You never know when you might get a green question.  :) Thanks for the great compliment.

8:14pm • #30
679,738 Points 18 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master
There are not a lot of "green" or "high efficiency" builders in So. New Hampshire.  We have a lot of educating to do with both builder and consumers.  New Hamshire is a bit behind the curve -- I think it is going to take many years before NH builders and consumer jump on board.
9:24pm • #31
200,475 Points 57 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
Hi Joan, you would be surprised.  :)  I said the same thing before I jumped in to find that there is much more happening in Houston than I realized. 
9:31pm • #32
JUL
20
2007
122,017 Points 6 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Great post.....I didn't realize there was a difference between the two. Thank you!
12:54am • #33
JUL
21
2007
430,343 Points 71 Featured Posts Called Shot Master

Stephanie,

How about "High Performance Green Home" as a hybrid term.

I actually had not thought Green and High Performance were different. Thanks for making me aware of the difference. This is a great blog!

I have been a high performance building guy for a while now. I got into energy auditing as a new branch of my home inspection business. So saving energy and building performance have been my focus. It did not occur to me this was in fact not Green.

Someone had discussed cost. This is where many people lose interest in having an energy audit because they can not understand investing in their home. They want to lower their energy bills, but when they find out a professional assessment of the home cost several hundred dollars, they opt out.

You had said a Green home on average costs about 10% more to build than a conventional home. Is there a pay off over the life of the mortgage that makes this a good investment? Do people balk at spending more money up front to be Green?

The pay off for high performance is lower energy bills which out weigh the higher mortgage payment. I would guess the same is true for Green.

Again great educational blog. I'll be visiting here often.

7:52am • #35
430,343 Points 71 Featured Posts Called Shot Master

Stephanie,

You blog is great, don't second guess yourself. Writing is an evolving process. I have revised so many pieces I have written. Just part of learning.

Geothermal is costly here, but has been used. I have not personally seen a house with a system installed.

ROI is the key to any of these types of homes. There comes a point where the upgrades do not justify the expense.

8:56am • #36
200,475 Points 57 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Hi James, I agree about costs.  Mary Bigelow yesterday related this to CD's and CD Players.  Once the demand came around the prices dropped significantly.  Also, there is a point (like was mentioned to me yesterday by a builder) where since the products are still new that there will be vendors that feel the need to price gouge. 

Thanks again.

9:02am • #37
198,363 Points 12 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp
Stephanie, Great job on the star  It was a highly interesting post that certainly caught a lot of attention!!!
6:17pm • #38
200,475 Points 57 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
Thanks Chris!  I appreciate it.  Thanks for stopping by.
6:58pm • #39
AUG
18
2007
6 Featured Posts

This is an amazing post and one of the many reasons why I keep coming back to your blogs. I learned something and it was painless. :)

I look forward to many more blogs like this.

1:07am • #40

Stephanie, amen to the "hybrid" of the two.  Being GREEN has more to it than simply being environmentally wise.  Being GREEN is also about being economically wise.  We love our GREEN earth, but we are wise to watch how much GREEN is leaving our pocket books as well.

So watching all aspect of the GREEN issue is truly the only way to go.  We must remind ourselves that being GREEN is a very BIG and complex issue, and we should do all that we can to be educated on as many aspects of it as possible, or be sure to hire those that we trust to be that professional for us.

DJ Breckheimer
SW Mpls Specialist
www.djBreck.com

 

2:46pm • #41
AUG
20
2007
103,963 Points
Just a small thing I wanted to point out to help to confuse this issue, bamboo, while the fastest renewable "hard wood" (it is of course more of a grass) most of the bamboo that we find in the states is made in China and most of that uses some very toxic glue in the manufacturing process. I am looking at doing a floor in my house right now and I'm studying this stuff. 
8:37pm • #42
AUG
22
2007
200,475 Points 57 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Thanks Pamela,  what a great compliment!  I am glad it was helpful.

Hi DJ,  Absolutely!  It is complicated and very important to hire the experienced and educated when building/buying green.  These homes work as systems and it is imperative to make sure the systems work/installed properly.  Great comment!

Hi Michael,  You bring up a very good point.  It is very important to make sure the glues have less/no toxins.  Thank you for bringing that up.  Good luck with your flooring!

7:59am • #43
AUG
25
2007
130,227 Points Outside Blog
Thanks for the explanation! I am going to pass this information along!!!
9:52am • #44
SEP
15
2007

This blog does not allow anonymous comments

 
Rainmaker_large

Stephanie Edwards-Musa, Realtor ® Spring/Woodlands, TX Real Estate

The Woodlands, TX

More about me…

Prudential Gary Greene, Realtors ®

Address: 9000 Forest Crossing Dr., The Woodlands, TX, 77381

Office Phone: (281) 367-3531

Cell Phone: (281) 635-9444

Email Me

Green Mountain Energy

<!-- Start of StatCounter Code -->

hit counter
code
<!-- End of StatCounter Code -->

Digg!

Blogarama - The Blog Directory

Blogarama - The Blog Directory



Listings

Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog