Special offer

Um...I Changed My Mind...Sorry

By
Real Estate Agent with Prudential California Realty

"I've Changed My Mind."  

On Friday at 3:00 pm I put a new home listing on the San Diego market.  By Sunday, we had multiple offers and were over asking price.  Out of the offers, two were particularly strong and the sellers accepted one of them. Before letting the other agents know, I confirmed with the buyers' agent to make sure they wanted the home (yes, they did and even visited the home a second time and "loved" it).  

This morning the buyerschanging mind' agent let me know that the buyers had "changed their mind."  

While I understand buyers canceling escrow for different reasons, a change of heart within 12 hours of getting the home makes me believe they put in an offer without really wanting it.  With short sales and REOs it seems common for buyers to put many offers out there since they have a slim chance of getting any of them.  I have several buyers who have had to put in 15 or so offers over many, many months until getting one, and it's almost anticlimactic when they actually get their offer accepted. I get it. However, this is a traditional sale and the sellers took all offers very seriously, respected the offers' expiration dates, and negotiated in good faith.  

It seems that these buyers were not really committed to buying the home.  If they weren't, they shouldn't have put an offer in.  All this did was create extra work for everyone and an illusion of commitment.  The other buyers who made an offer and were truly committed were probably disappointed that their offer wasn't accepted.  It's not so easy for another buyer to hear that they can now have the home only because the first choice no longer wants it.  

So, to buyers:  An offer is serious and can result in a contract to purchase.  You shouldn't just throw out offers to see if anything will stick.  When you are making an offer you should do this only because you really want the home. Don't make an offer unless you are truly motivated to buy it.  If you don't really want it, don't bother making an offer.  Move on to something you really want.  


Deborah Engel, Prudential California Realty, is a recognized San Diego and Carmel Valley Realtor for top client satisfaction.  If you'd like to learn more about Deborah, visit her website, www.PropertyByDeb.com, email her, Deb@PropertyByDeb.com, or call her at 858-829-1989.

Clark Hitchcock
Re/Max Nyda Realty Inc - Chilliwack, BC
Realtor - Fraser Valley

Hope you can get one of the others back to the table and hopefully the reluctant buyers are not running around doing that to other home sellers.

Feb 22, 2010 04:25 PM
Deborah Engel
Prudential California Realty - San Diego, CA
San Diego Homes & Property

Thanks!  We did get one of the other but not without some additional negotiation. Argh!

Feb 22, 2010 04:31 PM
Dan Tabit
Keller Williams Bellevue - Sammamish, WA

Hi Deborah, I was on the buyers side of a similar situation last weekend.  My buyer made an offer below what I recommended and didn't get the house.

Feb 22, 2010 04:35 PM
Leslie Ebersole
Swanepoel T3 Group - Saint Charles, IL
I help brokers build businesses they love.

It is hard to maintain your cool in a tough situation like this and it seems like you did. Did you ever a get a decent explanation from the agent? I bet they'd written several offers at once and canceled yours when they thehouse they really wanted.

It seems that some "perfect" buyers -- nothing to sell, approved loan, move anytime -- have become especially unruly. Their sense of power has overcome common courtesy. I have a client who last year -- before their home was listed -- would go out to look at homes and randomly add and subtract from the list while we were out. I would always insist on running in to leave a card or the need for respecting showing times, and more than once I heard "well, it's on the market, what do they expect." After months of being on the market with their share of last minute showing requests, no-shows, rude feedback and two pretty ridiculous offers, they sure have settled down. Our trip out a couple of weeks ago was much more sensible and even included a couple of comments like -- "let's stay for 15 minutes, they probably cleaned all morning".

Feb 22, 2010 04:58 PM
Glenn Roberts
Retired - Seattle, WA

It's too bad but in markets like this we a see our share of backouts from both sides of the table. I always try to warn sellers which contingencies in an offer allow for it to prepare them. In some cases we (seller and I) have picked a close second because telling them you took their offer over a higher priced one makes them feel lucky and happy to have the home. The high bidder sometimes feels they have paid too much and they bail. 

Feb 22, 2010 08:05 PM