Special offer

Struggling Homeowners Considering Strategic Defaults

By
Mortgage and Lending with American Capital Corporation

1

Many homeowners whose loans are underwater have considered strategically defaulting on their homes. Of course, underwater loans are when a borrower owes more on their loan than their home is worth. This means that many of these homeowners are discouraged and don’t see the point in continuing to pay for a loan that is far greater than the value of their homes.

In a report by Fannie Mae, numbers show that homeowners are more likely to consider a strategic default if they know someone who has already walked away from their home. Is this so hard to believe when you see a friend get out from under their loan with (relatively) few consequences while you struggle to pay for your underwater home? Additionally, 24% of surveyed homeowners believe that their homes are underwater.

However, even though these homeowners have considered defaulting, the large majority do not see it as an acceptable solution to their financial situations. In another poll, Fannie found that seven of ten delinquent homeowners believe they need to live up to their financial agreements and that defaulting on purpose is not an option. Most of these homeowners decided that if there was a way to stay in their homes, they would.

In a corresponding study by Fannie Mae, it was found that homeowners who are underwater were more likely to be delinquent on their payments and more likely to consider walking away from their homes. When a home is underwater, it can be very difficult, if not impossible, to qualify for any kind of loan modification or refinance program. Again, when your home is worth half of what you owe on the loan, it is easy to see why some people may think about defaulting.

Of course, if at all possible, borrowers need to live up to their commitments. Defaults and foreclosures not only hurt the neighborhood they occur in, but the housing economy in general. Lower home values and an excess in available homes will only further serve to delay the recovery of the housing market, whose recovery is vital to the overall economic progress.

 

Jim Cheney
Saint Francis Property Santa Rosa, CA - Santa Rosa, CA
Rincon Valley Realtor 707.494.1055

Well put Christine!  I have a hard time standing behind a client who want to walk away just because their home is a "bad investment".  However, if doom is imminent, what's the point of giving every last dime to the bank?  Some times the line the divides the two can be hard to determine.

Apr 08, 2010 09:41 AM
Christine Hynes
American Capital Corporation - Laguna Beach, CA
Orange County Senior Loan Consultant

I agree Jim, determining when or even if it is acceptable to walk away from a home can be a tough debate. Although intentional defaults hurt the housing around them, people will always look to their individual needs first.

Apr 09, 2010 02:32 AM
Todd Clark - Retired
eXp Realty LLC - Tigard, OR
Principle Broker Oregon

This doesn't surprise me at all. With the banks not listening to home owners, the home owners are just giving up on their property and their credit and saying "Heck, I just give it up and in 2 years I'll buy another home at 1/2 the price." Who can blame them, they certainly haven't been given the help from the banks that they so desperately need right now.

Apr 12, 2010 04:36 AM
Christine Hynes
American Capital Corporation - Laguna Beach, CA
Orange County Senior Loan Consultant

Todd - In the grand scheme of things it is the money from we tax payers that bailed out the banks, it is our money in the depositories, and finally can I say, it is really all our money anyway, the banks are just borrowering it, lending it, making money and more money.  I wonder where all that money is that they made a killing on for over 8 years?

Apr 13, 2010 02:20 AM