Special offer

Senators Give Facebook the "Middle Finger..."

By
Services for Real Estate Pros with Virtual Pictures Corp. (VPiX)

 

Facebook has 400 million users. This is more people than every man, woman and child (including illegal aliens from Mexico) living in the United States right now.

I've chronicled a few of the problems facing Facebook and now it's getting a lot worse. This last week, New York Senator Charles Schumer wrote a letter to the FTC demanding they develop guidelines for how Facebook information can be used.

Oops. Here it comes. 

Since Facebook is experimenting with and placing every American's Facebook personal information at risk by pulling stupid stunts like last week's changing of Facebook FAN Page icon to LIKE -- it's opened up a whole new can of worms for those concerned about security over people's personal information on any social media network.

What's started of as a joke for Facebook and their fans (no pun intended) has turned into a real 3-Mile Meltdown of trust and resentment by highly visible "early adopters" of Facebook such as Bill Gates, Mat Cutts of Google and Serge Brin.

We've discovered parts of your Facebook personal information has come face to face with a serious security loophole over their Graph API release last week. Also known as the LIKE Plug in code. Which replaced Facebook's Become a Fan button.

And Sen. Schumer isn't alone in his rants against Facebook. He's teamed up with Sen. Al Franken (former Saturday Night Live comedian), Sen. Michael Bennet (D. Colorado) and Sen. Mark Begich (D. Alaska)

 

Facebook screws Up

 

What This Means for Online Advertising

Privacy regulation for online social networks means firms like Twitter, Facebook and others may soon have to adhere to a stricter set of privacy standards and be open to having their networks scrutinized by the U.S. Government. 

Because right now, a lot of people including a few Senators are giving Facebook the "middle finger," with last weeks screw up. Matt Cutts, a high profile engineer with Google has shut down his Facebook page and is recommending that everybody else do the same thing until Facebook fixes their blatant privacy (security) loophole.

I stopped running my ads on Facebook this week when I received my Facebook stats. My traffic was down -37% this last week. Apparently hundreds of thousands of people are not visiting or hanging out at Facebook as a result. I'm not running any ads on Google, Facebook or any other network until June. The Bartman wants to see what happens here and there's no sense in wasting my ad dollars on networks with customers that just aren't hanging out there for a while. 

 

Why is this bad news for Social Media networks?

Because 20% of online ads target you based on online behavior. Newcomers like Foursquare and GroupOn are new names in targeted content marketing. Google on the other hand has been doing this now for a few years.  Today's sophisticated cookies track your movement. Stumble Upon sort of falls into this same new category, too. 

Did you use the computer at work to go shopping, or maybe to a porn site?

Well congratulations. That data is now being shared (sold) with lots of companies you never heard of. It won't track you per se all of the time, but it does track your computer's IP (Internet Protocol) address.

Who you are connected to.

What you did.

What websites you visited.

What you bought.

How many times you Tweeted what you watched on TV or had for breakfast.

All of this information is being collected up and sold to God only knows who or where.

All of this collection of you, your computer and what you're doing online is being being sold to the Credit Bureaus: Trans Union, Equifax and Experian, too. I covered this in a previous blog post a few months ago. Insurance companies have to be in that mix, somewhere too. 

Right now, the issues of online privacy are being pitched to members of Congress by various special interest groups. The FTC is currently looking into the problems and will release it's report to Congress sometime by the end of the year. 

 

What You Should Do Now

Facebook is Yin & Yang.  50% good. 50% evil. Some might argue 75% evil. 

Just remember that your birthday, your real name, your family members, friends are now at some degree of risk right now. This is a documented fact. It's not brought about by any fear mongers here.  Facebook really screwed up. Your personal security is now at risk, and you've been so informed if you've read this blog. 

You have to decide whether the risk is serious enough to shut down your Facebook account until the company comes out with iron clad, bullet proof security systems that can let us sleep better at night.

 

Posted by

Bart Wilson | CIO
..................................................................
Virtual Pictures Corp (VPiX®)  
iPhone: (719) 645-9940  |  Skype:  vpix360 

Drick Ward Property Management / Broker Assoc
NEPTUNE REALTY - Virginia Beach, VA
"RealtorDrick" - Experienced Representation

Some of us have been warning against the evils of facebook data sharing for a long time. I just don't want to hear any complaints from people who actively participated in facebook and have their identity stolen or houses burgled while they are away from home. They provided the info in the first place so they have no room to cry. If people will slowly pull away from facebook and return to spending real life time with actual friends - in person (gasp!) then facebook will implode on itself.

May 03, 2010 06:17 PM
Frank Castaldini
Compass - San Francisco, CA
Realtor - Homes for Sale in San Francisco

I have my reservations about posting anymore on Facebook.  I may be in the same camp as those who have chose to pull their pages.  Time will tell.

May 03, 2010 06:28 PM
Ray Garrett, Jr.
Realogy Holdings Co - Richmond, VA
Director of Productivity and Innovation

Bart, the article sufficiently scared me, but I came away unsure how the "like" feature effects me. I understand that people are upset about it, but I'm not sure why this new feature reveals more of my privacy than previous efforts by Facebook.

If you get time, could you explain this further in a new blog or here on this one for those of us who are a little slow catching up.

May 03, 2010 11:56 PM
Tim Maitski
Atlanta Communities Real Estate Brokerage - Atlanta, GA
Truth, Excellence and a Good Deal

Any links to other posts or articles that explain what happened with Facebook?  Exactly how is my privacy and my friends' privacy at risk?

May 04, 2010 12:03 AM
Kathryn Acciari
Central One Federal Credit Union - Shrewsbury, MA
Mortgage Loan Originator

And my kid wants to know why I won't let him have his own FB page.  "All my friends have one."  Well, their parents are naive.

May 04, 2010 12:11 AM
Joe Pryor
The Virtual Real Estate Team - Oklahoma City, OK
REALTOR® - Oklahoma Investment Properties

Your on the pulse of the social media Bart. 

May 04, 2010 12:55 AM
Missy Caulk
Missy Caulk TEAM - Ann Arbor, MI
Savvy Realtor - Ann Arbor Real Estate

Facebook is changeing.

They didn't hire Grady Burnett from Google for nothing.

 

May 04, 2010 01:04 AM
Brian Madigan
RE/MAX West Realty Inc., Brokerage (Toronto) - Toronto, ON
LL.B., Broker

Bart,

I never really thought that Facebook would have had the type of success that it has enjoyed, even surpassing Google. However, with that comes responsibility.

 

Brian

 

May 04, 2010 01:14 AM
Silvia Dukes PA, Broker Associate, CRS, CIPS, SRES
Tropic Shores Realty - Ich spreche Deutsch! - Spring Hill, FL
Florida Waterfront and Country Club Living

Facebook has gotten confusing as far as I'm concerned and when users don't have the time anymore to figure out the changes, they'll leave.

May 04, 2010 01:21 AM
Ron and Alexandra Seigel
Napa Consultants - Carpinteria, CA
Luxury Real Estate Branding, Marketing & Strategy

Nice post, thanks for the information.

May 04, 2010 03:17 AM
Shanna Hall
Real Estate Solutions - Kirkwood, MO
I love selling houses!!!St. Louis, MO 314-703-1311

Thank you for the information!  I think I am going to go and pay my facebooka a visit and see what I need to strip off of...

May 04, 2010 04:26 AM
Michael J. Perry
KW Elite - Lancaster, PA
Lancaster, PA Relo Specialist

I've been dragging my feet on accepting my likes that keeps popping up everytime I'm on FB !!!!

May 04, 2010 05:33 AM
Bartley Wilson
Virtual Pictures Corp. (VPiX) - Monument, CO
VR Software and 360° Solutions

Thanks everybody!  Yay! My 9th Featured Post. Facebook targeting is certainly an issue today because a lot of you... a lot of us out here have no clue what Facebook does with your personal information and preferences.

For example, who READS the fine print on any Facebook, Twitter or Microsoft Office installation button? You just want to click a button and see stuff happen. You click and boom. Tons of Legal Text we have to read. Reading it will take like 3 hours.  Meanwhile, you're still waiting to USE Facebook's new widget. Or start creating your next Powerpoint.  

Who is ever going to spend 3 hours to read this BEFORE you click the ACCEPT button?

Are you kidding me? 3 hours? You click NO - I DO NOT ACCEPT and you just can't use the software or online service. NOTE: There's no way for you to Modify the Agreement.  You get FORCED to click ACCEPT or you simply can use the online service or install the software.

NOBODY READS THIS STUFF. And lo -- here we go, proof in the pudding as Barbara Corcoran likes to so often say -- we have some of you asking for more questions. And all of this was covered in the Fine Print you NEVER READ. 

This is what Facebook and every other firm out there is BANKING on.

The Fact that we DON'T EVER READ the fine print. Can you imagine how long a closing would take if every home buyer you ever had sitting across the closing table from you would read every word of the contracts you shove under their noses?

The single ACT of clicking a LIKE button will land you in a lot of trouble. My wife has a Facebook page. She comes in today and says, "Wow where did all of this crap come from?" On closer inspection, I went to her Preferences and noted she had gushed a lot of things on line. Favorite movies. Favorite hobbies. Things to do. Favorote Music. Wow. Lots here.

So, Facebook targeted her with a ton of Facebook content for TV shows like the Mentalist. And tons more of stuff shoved under her nose she didn't really want. This is what Targeted Profiling does. 

If you READ Facebook's tiny print... for 3 hours, you'd know this was just one of the things they CAN do to target you to buy stuff. 

Reading the legal-ese on these things would take the average joe home buyer a week. You'd be lucky to sell 3 homes a year if everybody did that. Truth in Lending Act. Fair Housing.  Title binder. Disclaimers. Mortgage papers.  

AAAaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh.

Nothing would EVER get done. 

May 04, 2010 08:47 AM
Duane Murphy
Expert Real Estate Partners LLC - Appleton, WI
Broker- Owner-Real Estate -

Sometimes it would be good to just leave good things alone. They will find a way to charge everyone yet.

May 04, 2010 09:07 AM
Bill Swanson
Berkshire Hathaway Home Services Ambassador - Omaha, NE

Wow! I had no idea, and it sounds like millions of others didn't either. Thanks a ton!

May 04, 2010 10:21 AM
Noelle Blazevich
John L. Scott - North Bend, WA

Bart,

Changing the lingo of becoming a Fan to Like is not the larger issue.  The larger issue is the linking of your profile information to community pages based on specifications of hometown, current city and schools attended as well as the PRIVACY SETTINGS on your profile.  Facebook recently changed the way information is shared and changed the various privacy setting options.  When they did this they defaulted the new privacy options to more open or freely shared defaults.  What people really need to do is pay attention to the privacy settings on their pages.  I have private pages and public pages.  If someone is a fan of my public page or has clicked "like"  it does not mean I have automatic access to their personal information.  I can communicate with them on my public page but if I go to view their profile I can only see what they have decided to make publicly available.  Some are wide open some are shut tight.  The same goes for others who choose to communicate with me via my public page.  They only get access to what I make public.  Check your privacy settings folks and think before you post.  I agree that facebook pulled a fast one on us but you have to understand how information is shared.    There are options for how much you are willing to allow your friends and applications that you use to share about you.

Also I think that we must remember that facebook is out there to make a profit.  Of course they are going to continue to evolve and find more ways to do that.  We as consumers who enjoy and use their services need to understand that for every opportunity there is a cost be it monetary or in this case the sharing of our information.  The important thing is to understand the cost of using the service.

May 04, 2010 10:33 AM
Bartley Wilson
Virtual Pictures Corp. (VPiX) - Monument, CO
VR Software and 360° Solutions

Well said Noelle,

I salute you on your contribution and a very professional journalism style, too.

The changing of privacy rules with firms like Facebook is more akin to watch the monkey. Watch the shell game. Where's the privacy policy you want? Is it under this shell? Nope.  This one? Sorry. 

There's nothing wrong with Facebook or any other firm's wanting to make a buck. But at what cost?  Firms that write up so much "legalese" should be shot. Mortgage and REALTORS excluded of course, as we certainly kill a lot of trees as we continue to bury every closing with lots and lots of paper.

But the fact is, we've let Wall Street run anywhere they wanted unchecked. Same with the Healthcare in America. What's next? America's privacy is at risk now and the name of your pain is Facebook. Twitter. Google and countless others.

We might not like socialism very much but we already have it. The post office. Your public schools. The local library. Your local police and firefighters. Every one of these organizations is (Oh My God!) socialized. 

We see the government cleaning up the financial mess, the housing crisis, our healthcare industry and now... privacy. We're used to socialism. And the mere root word: Social as in Social Media.

Think about that for a minute...

-- Bart

May 04, 2010 10:43 AM
Noelle Blazevich
John L. Scott - North Bend, WA

Bart,

I think you said it best yourself when you brought up the downfall of Myspace.  Facebook will need to be wary of competition and competitors that provide a more appealing options to consumers.  If facebook over commercializes they will loose the very thing that attracted us all in the first place.  The opportunity to make social connections.  To much marketing clutter and people are going to stop using the site. I think its going to be interesting to say the least.  We are a free market society and while many of us follow like sheep there is a reason we follow.  The shinny red ball is appealing to us.  If the ball becomes hard to follow or we have to wade through too much junk to get to it we drop out.  Facebook is popular because it's easy and fun and lets face it a bit voyeuristic.  They mess with the formula too much and they will be their own downfall.

So a question.  Are you a fan of govenment regulations for social networking sites?  While I resent having my privacy attacked I am also wary of government red tape and government involvement. 

May 04, 2010 11:05 AM
Damon Gettier
Damon Gettier & Associates, REALTORS- Roanoke Va Short Sale Expert - Roanoke, VA
Broker/Owner ABRM, GRI, CDPE

Bart and Noelle, if my profile is private for everything, just friends and not friends of friends.....am I ok?

May 05, 2010 05:07 AM
Noelle Blazevich
John L. Scott - North Bend, WA

One way to check is to logout of facebook and do a google search for yourself.  See what pops up.  You can also reset your privacy settings then look at a preview of what your publicly viewable profile will look like. 

I am not an expert on Facebook and I couldn't say if anyone is "safe" or not.  I just know what I have read in various tech articles and by checking on my own privacy settings.  I think the safest thing to do is think before you post.  Don't post things that you aren't comfortable with having shared publicly should there be a leak in your privacy. 

May 05, 2010 06:07 AM