Special offer

Virtual 3D Designs - Which Looks More Realistic?

By
Home Stager with Beyond the Stage Homes

I love interior design programs and have been using them for years. Last year I found a website that allowed me to create virtual 3D designs for clients and I fell in love with it. Unfortunately, it wasn't a great program for my computer and it took me hours to do one room because it kept causing my computer to crash. So, I found a new software program by Chief Architect which allowed me to do all of the other things I could do in the previous program plus exciting things like creating actual walk through's of the home showing the newly designed spaces.

On our website under Virtual 3D Designs is a before and 'after' of a room using the old 3D program which looked fairly realistic but which still seemed to be obviously a computer design. At least to me. I can't attach a copy of it here because in that program I could only save it as a pdf file, not a jpeg file. I hope you'll take a moment to look at it and then compare that to the designs I am attaching below.

The reason I am doing this is because a builder contacted us last week to do the virtual 3D designs for four of their condo units by this Friday and then when they saw the preliminary designs I had created then they said they didn't want them anymore. They wanted me to use the other software program because they could see a significant difference and they wanted a photo quality to the designs, as if they had really staged it with furnishings and taken a picture. They didn't want it to appear .. 'fake'. I'm sure their are programs out there that do that. Neither one of the programs I have will create that kind of 'photo' finish. My advice to them at hearing this? Stage it for real, then take a photograph.

Keeping in mind that I had already logged eight hours creating the designs from their floorplans and had finished two units. I was honest from the beginning that I had just gotten a new software program with lots of great new features. The builder wanted the designs because of the new features in this software program which allowed me to give them virtual walkthrough's on a CD and 360 degree views of the space. I couldn't have done this with the other program. 

Am I billing for my time? Yes. I believe after the hours it took to complete the designs for two of their units that I should be paid for my time. 

So here is one of the newly designed units:

I am in the process of updating our website now with the new completed designs so that clients will know what to expect when we talk about virtual 3D designs. What have I learned from this whole process? To send examples before I start working! 

Virtual 3D designs aren't widely known - or accepted. I prefer the real thing over a computer generated image anytime but when it comes to design projects or for clients who don't want to furnish vacant homes then this at least gives people an idea of how the room could look. It's not a fill in for the real thing, but it's a good visual representation for people who need to 'see it' first. All our designs are done from floorplans with exact room sizes, measurements and room scale. 

So I hope you'll offer your feedback and thoughts!

Posted by

Heather Cook  is Co-Owner and Principal Staging Designer of the award winning Rooms in Bloom Home Staging & Design Inc. based out of Kitchener-Waterloo, ON.


 

Contact us today so we can help you create the WOW Factor in your home.

     

Comments(4)

Kathy Streib
Cypress, TX
Home Stager/Redesign

Heather- there's always a lot of discussion about virtual staging.  I think it can be a great tool for a stager or designer (eg.  to give a client an idea of what a redesign or staging will look like).  But you're right it reminds me of the latest wave in television commercials that use animated characters rather than "live" humans.  That being said, I'm always looking for new tools that I can use in my Staging kit.

May 05, 2010 08:07 AM
Maureen Bray Portland OR Home Stager ~ Room Solutions Staging
Room Solutions Staging, Portland OR - Portland, OR
"Staging Consultations that Sell Portland Homes"

Heather -- I'm glad to hear you're billing for your time in creating these images -- they look great, by the way.  Although this type of 3-D design makes sense for a design client, I wouldn't personally use it for staging because for me, the staging process is more organic ... I select the furniture I'll be using, and then put it in the space on staging day.  Only then do I decide exactly how it will be placed ... staging is a creative process for me, but one that works best when I can "feel it" in place.  It may sound strange, but I let the house tell me what it needs .... (OK, I'm a bit odd that way....:-)

May 06, 2010 08:35 AM
Janice Ankrett
Burlington, ON
Staging Professional

I can see it would be useful for redesign and if you have the time to convince a client about a staging plan. I don't really like it as a substitute for staging.

Looks great though ;). Glad you charged for your time when they backed out.

May 08, 2010 09:21 AM
Heather Cook
Beyond the Stage Homes - Kitchener, ON
Delivering beautifully staged spaces

I agree - I don't like virtual staging as a substitute for staging. The real thing is always better. 

Kathy - It is a great tool and like all good tools it has its uses and limitations. As we are the 'toolmasters' we need to know when its applicable .. and when its not.

Maureen - I understand exactly what you mean .. I guess I'm weird as well lol! At least I'm in good company :P

Janice - Its very useful for redesign projects and we seldom use it for staging at all. When it comes to designing a space for clients however this kind of visual gives them confidence in the overall design plan.

May 10, 2010 12:28 PM