I want to share with you on how mortgages work, how they are sold on the secondary market, and the reason why some of these companies are closing their doors.
We have seen some major changes in the lending industry, more so than ever before. What we need to do is to stay positive, focused, and move forward. But at the same time, explain to the consumer what is happening in the market today, educating everyone on the ins and outs of what a mortgage is and how it works.
Just a few days ago, Kurt Jackson gave us some insight on what happened to American Home Mortgage. And then Bob Mitchell gave us a better look and understanding on the Secondary Marketing and how this could have affected American Home Mortgage and other companies like it.
What I want to explain here is how these loans are delivered and where they end up which as you can see, sometimes can affect the companies that are on the front line. **I might be leaving some things out just to make this easier to understand. I might not include all terms.**
The secondary market can be a twisting ball of confusion at times because of how it is broken down. Here is a diagram of the mortgage market process by DiPasQuale and Wheaton from the Urban Economics and Real Estate Markets research.
The secondary market can be broken down into 2 groups. The "whole loan" market and the "mortgage-backed securities" market. You also have bonds backed by loans, but that is for another topic. You need to read Kurt Jackon's article listed above in order to get a better idea of how this works.
The whole market is where mortgages are sold in blocks of mortgages, sometimes as a loan by loan basis, depending on the need. These are usually sold to investors who want to make money from the interest. Why are loans sold as blocks? I might have 10 loans sitting on my warehouse line, eight of which are very good performing A paper loans. Two of them might not be so great, a little riskier. I want to put them all together, as a block, so the investor will buy all of them, taking a chance, because they have 80% that are very good.
Mortgage-backed securities are where you have specific insurers such as Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and Ginnie Mae who have guarantees over promises of other investors. This is usually a more efficient and lower cost of financing in comparison to the other options. These individuals are what is called "pools of money". Your Ginnie Mae pool is for FHA loans which are backed by the government. The other two are for conventional usage.
These pools are based on default risk which is credit risk and interest rate exposure. There is another risk that is factored into this which is the prepayment risk which is called the redemption risk. So many don't understand that it costs lenders that service these loans money when someone refinances. Why? Because they are losing the higher interest of return and because there were initial costs that went into this loan that is now lost. It doesn't hurt the loan officer, but it certainly hurts the banks and the market.
The part that is not understood by so many is that there are other players behind these pools of loans. These could be private investors that will dissect a loan and buy and sell it in pieces, depending on the loan itself. Just like when a company buys junk cars, their goal is to sell pieces of the car, which could bring a larger income than selling the whole car itself. This is what happens on the secondary market. These are basically called securities that attract other investors who would not want to hold onto a whole loan.
What becomes even more confusing is that there is some sort of food chain to this. But it works backwards, as shown in the diagram, working from left to right. Which gets back to when I say investors dissect loans. I will keep this short so as not to confuse you. This is where the subprime market came into play. These would be consider B or C loans within the market. These loans carry more risk but investors are willing to split them up and sometimes place them into the A group, which is normally your good performing loans that have less risk with good credit. When these companies start to close shop per se, they need to be bought up in the market. This is when someone who usually buys A paper ends up buying that B loan and tries to sell it in pieces. This is what ends up driving prices. The video below is from what Mike Mueller shared in his article Asking the Question.
I hope all of this gives you a better understanding of how mortgages work, how they are sold on the secondary market, and the reason why some of these companies are closing their doors. And for another breakdown in layman's terms, Brian Brady wrote : The Mortgage Tax Act of 2007
121 Comments on The Explanation of Mortgages : From the beginning of time......
AUG
07
2007
Jeff, Great post. You really gave a great explanation how everything works. I do agree with you about being positive. I wrote several posts about being positive within the industry.
Great explanation. And I whole heartedly agree that we should educate our clients without reacting to everything we see in the media. All we ca do is keep pushing forward. (Walk by faith and not by sight)
Matthew..... I just have been seeing way too many negative posts about the sky is falling.... mortgage bailouts.. this is dropping, that is dropping. It can get to you. After 15 years of lending, yes, this is the worst for me, but people will always be buying houses. The basic loan programs will always be around.... so, people just need to save a little more.
In any case.... thanks for the polite compliment and for stopping by. I read some of your positive posts. Thanks
Lisa..... education is such a key. One thing, especially now, in a down market.... consumers need to be more aware of advertisements more than ever. Lenders need their phones to ring and are willing to spend lots of money. Who pays for these ads? The consumer..... they need to understand that it's just that, an ad to make phones ring.
It's just scary, I have seen bad in this business before, but nothing like this, I can have all of the business in the world, and with no loan products they are worth nothing...
Looks great. Hopefully we can help to educate the service providers enough that they can help to pass it on to their clients so everybody is better equipped to make their decisions.
Tom W....... hey, after 15 years, yes, this is the worst. But as so many have said, the strong will survive. We just need to be smart when talking to the consumer that is shopping. Those that are desperate will bait and switch... and not educate.
Kurt....... I agree, just educating everyone is so key. Thanks for the compliment.
Aaron.... thanks.... waiting for other money geeks to stop in here and give me their input and feedback on this.
Kaye..... thanks, I appreciate that. I'll go check out that blog and if it relates to this one, please feel free to add your link in here.
Jeff, as always, a very instructive and thoughtful post. Not that I understand a LOT, but I rely heavily on my loan officer to 'splain it as we go. Today we had a class in Short Sales. Now THAT was a true revelation. Our broker teaches GRI, etc., and he was very thorough. It appears most of the agents listing short sales these days in AZ shouldn't be, or are doing it incorrectly. So much to know. Thanks for your insights,
Jeff - this could the best ever post on AR the secondary market is very misunderstood - especially by consumers who really should understand how the market works as much as mortgage bankers need to understand how secondary functions.
I have been at this game 15+ years and this is not only the worst but the scariest I have ever seen it.
Buckle your chin straps, cut uneeded expenses and subscribe to the " last man standing " theory and when the storm clears, you very well could be in the best position ever. That's my theory and I am standing by it! :-)
I agree - best post ever on AR! Very informative. It was great speaking with you in person today. True to your posts, you are very knowledgable and I look forward to building a working relationship.
Tony..... lol Yes Tony, AR has created a monster. I love writing now. But I think it's because I get teach and share without getting in front of others. Seriously, thanks for those kind words.
Teri..... maybe you don't understand 100% of it, but hopefully you are able to get an idea. I would expect short sales to be very indepth, so good luck with that. Thanks for the polite compliments.
Lewis...... wow.... thank you very much. I guess the comments reflect that.... lol It will be my 15th year next week and it's hard to imagine, but I have loved every minute of it.
I agree, buckle those chin straps. I am so looking forward to the challenge and I hope it knocks out a lot of unwanted loan officers in this business. It might sound cruel, but I am tired of selling against true sales people that just sell, but don't explain. Who bait and switch or tease those clients with false hope.\
Again, thank you very much for that awesome compliment.
Chrissy.... wow....and thank you very much also. I wish I would get more comments from some of those money geeks here on AR to see what they think. And yes, it was great talking to you... refreshing. I also look forward to building a working relationship with you. thanks again.
Jason.... thanks a lot for that polite compliment. You don't need to be a true money geek to understand the basics of how a mortgage works and where it comes from and or goes to.... thanks again...
Jeff, this is a really detailed explanation of how the secondary market works. Many homebuyers have no clue all these items that happen behind the scenes.
Jeff...You know me, I could go into greater detail, but who would it serve? I think this was a great way of explaining it in as much detail as the consumer needs to know. Good job.
This was a good post for me to learn from. My eyes usually glaze over, when anyone starts talking about mortgages or money or numbers or there are no graphics to look at.
I just want to educate people about mortgages and the process.
In regards to lending, I am very creative, intuitive, honest, and one who communicates information, may it be good or bad. I am a loan officer that looks out for your best interest.
Disclaimer: ActiveRain Corp. does not necessarily endorse the real estate agents, loan officers and brokers listed on this site. These real estate profiles, blogs and blog entries are provided here as a courtesy to our visitors to help them make an informed decision when buying or selling a house. ActiveRain Corp. takes no responsibility for the content in these profiles, that are written by the members of this community.