Special offer

Listing agents: Do you purposely try to keep a buyer's deposit?

By
Mortgage and Lending with Seacoast Mortgage Corporation, RI (20021119LB & 20031576LL), MA (MC2107) & CT MLO 10920

As a listing agent, one has the responsibility to protect the seller's interest.  But how far should one go to protect? Should you try to keep the buyer's deposit?

On a recent transaction, I had a buyer who was purchasing a 2 unit home to occupy one of the units.  He was being financed by an FHA loan.  Per FHA guidelines, the buyer must take occupancy within 30 days.  The condition on the P&S was to have one of the tenants vacate the premises.  The seller was not able to meet this condition by the mortgage contingency date, so I requested an extension from the buyer's broker.  The buyer's broker attempted to contact the seller's agent for two weeks.   The listing agent did not return the calls. We needed to go around the agent to obtain the extension.  The listing agent grew angry over this and called a meeting complaining of the buyer's broker going around him.

When asked why he did not return the calls of the buyer's agent, the listing agent responded "I wish to obtain leverage in the transaction by NOT extending mortgage commitment dates.  Thus, I did not want to obtain an extension.  By threatening to hold a buyer's deposit money, I can force them into a purchase, in case they wish to back out."

What do you think of this "strategy" by the listing agent?

Is this even legal?

Is this an ethical practice?

What are your thoughts?

Posted by

Ann Sabbagh, President

"The BEST compliment is a client referral: Thank YOUUU!"

Seacoast Mortgage Corporation

401-305-6906 or 508-243-1190

Residential & Commercial Financing

MLO10920

RIAR: teacher for "The Mortgage Course"; "Valuation of Commercial/Investment Real Estate"; "Reading Financial Statements"

 

"When you choose me as your mortgage consultant, you also choose a financial planner who cares about YOUR financial strength."

Cindy Jones
Integrity Real Estate Group - Woodbridge, VA
Pentagon, Fort Belvoir & Quantico Real Estate News

I'd say their statement just hung them with their local RE board. You can't hold a buyer hostage by hiding out.  Going to the agent's broker is the right thing to do when the agent is unresponsive. 

Jul 30, 2010 03:18 PM
Mick Michaud
Distinctly Texas Lifestyle Properties, LLC Office:682/498-3107 - Granbury, TX
Your Texas Lifestyle is Here!

Being fair to all parties involved.  Seems an ethics violation may have taken place. 

Jul 30, 2010 03:50 PM
Wade Kawahara
Dominion Real Estate Partners, LLC - Phoenix, AZ

I think Cindy is right.  Everyone involved in the transaction, including agents, have to act in a timely manner.

Jul 30, 2010 05:40 PM
Song San
Coldwell Banker Dynasty - Rosemead, CA
Broker, MBA

 Wow, I would be scared of not returning the check in a quick manner. It is not worth to lose our license for this.

Jul 31, 2010 08:37 PM
Kathleen Ann Pacheco-Corbett
(FIRST Exclusive Buyer's Office Providence-RI) - Providence, RI
Realtor, RI-MA, CEBA, Master, e-Pro, ABR, ABRM, GR

Ann. I definitely agree with Mike this is an ethical violation. Agents are by law to treat all parties in a transaction fairly. You did right is contacting that agent's broker, I would have done it after 48 hours with no contact. That Listing agent is playing with dynamite and JEOPARDIZING HIS/HER LICENSE.

Feb 12, 2011 01:18 PM