Ar_home_b_search
 

Earlier tonight I was on MSN.com and they had a poll on whether the government should "bail out" homeownersFree Cheese for home owners! who are in danger of losing their homes in the current real estate/mortgage banking crises.  The over-all tone of the replies that were posted was very negative.  Very much a "they made their bed, now let them lie in it" sort of thing.

I commented there and thought that it might be of interest to some here on AR, that I had two problems with people dismissing the idea of a government "bail-out" program for home owners who are in danger of losing their homes out of hand.  These two problems are this: 

1)  While it is true that people entered into these loan programs of their own free will, many of them did so with the expectation that they would be able to refinance before their loan program got to the "adjustable" portion of their loan.  With the market dropping in many areas and lenders tightening up their lending criteria, many of these people (who have been making their payments on time) find themselves in a position where they "can't" refinance.  Very few people saw this "correction" to the market coming and even fewer of them could have predicted the crises in mortgage lending.  I for one knew nothing of the ways that Wall Street was structuring these non-conforming loans into mortgage backed securities and how they were mixing all kinds of different non-conforming loans together to make up a security.

 

2) The government is the only entity that has the wherewithal to "fix" this problem.  Lenders have their hands tied and cannot unilaterally change the terms of mortgages in order to "work" a solution out with the borrowers.  It's also the only entity that has the ability to step in and manage the crises across the board.  Plus it doesn't have to be a hand-out.  A program can be created to where people who participate in it have to qualify for the program.

 

Over-all, a government program to manage this crises would be the rational course of action to take and would benefit every home owner by stabilizing the markets.

 

Just my opinion and I'd love to hear yours!

 

Bob Mitchell

ValueList Real Estate Services, Inc. 

 

P.S.  The link to my follow post is  http://activerain.com/blogsview/186034/A-Hand-Up-vs

 

10 Comments on A Hand Up Vs. A Hand Out....why a government program is needed to help homeowners facing foreclosure

AUG
27
2007

... another important thing to keep in mind is that this is just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to foreclosures. The need to refi and the dreaded adjustment period is not over.... most lenders didn't start collapsing until 12/06 and sold 2/28 mortgages and 3/27 mortgages until their demise. Do the math, 16 months and counting....... tick tock, tick tock

or was that click, click, boom?

 

5:55am • #1
187,174 Points 2 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Bob why don't we all ask for a check from the government because of the value we lost in our homes?
5:57am • #2
129,545 Points 5 Featured Posts

Bob,

Being a mortgage professional, I am having a hard time with this one myself. 

I can see the dollar signs in my head of all the opportunities that a government bail-out loan program would create and my heart goes out to these folks in trouble.  So having this program would not be the end of the world.

However,

I am having a huge moral issue with consumers NOT taking responsibility for their own actions.  In 2004-2006, I did put a handful of clients (very few) into some of these subprime loans.  I gave them the best advice based on their current situation, and some consumers moved forward with these loans.  Now in their time of need, I have been calling these clients and trying to refinance them out of these loans.  Some of these consumers may have gotten in over their head, but by their own demise.  

Great Post 

6:05am • #4
937,507 Points 361 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Bob, I keep going back and forth on this one. While I don't like to see folks loose their homes I truly think the market needs to go through this correction on it's own. Most of the folks that I talk to that are having difficulties with their mortgage have already spent their equity on other things. Should we now pay for their mistakes?

Maybe the FHA could come up with an easy qualify mortgage for folks on adjustables BUT make it a condition that they have NOT refinanced in the last 3 years. If they truly need help...give it. It their misfortune is based on foolishness or even speculation then let them fail and learn a lesson.

8:41am • #5
1,180,049 Points 133 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master
I am with BB.  Many have balloons that need bailouts too.  The balloons are coming due and no way to refinance because of equity loss.  It would all have to be determined on a case by case affordability basis.  I am firmly AGAINST a bail out for NOO investors/second and vacation properties.  When you weed those out, very little left and the situation isn't all that bad.
10:23am • #6

Rob, James, Melissa, Gary and Bryant:  I was going to comment on each of your points, but figured that it might be better to do it as a follow up post.  Please look for it.

 

Bob Mitchell

ValueList  

10:26am • #7

Rob, James, Melissa, Gary and Bryant:  I was going to comment on each of your points, but figured that it might be better to do it as a follow up post.  Please look for it.

 

Bob Mitchell

ValueList  

10:26am • #8
3 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Bob,  Based on some of the comments to this post, I really don't think that some people have any idea how bad things are or are going to get. 

Why is it OK for the government to help out the airlines or the stock market but not homeowners?

2:45pm • #9
147,472 Points 6 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Rey:  I thought that putting it in terms of how it is affecting EVERYBODY who owns real estate, well that's not really true because I do think that it's going to eventually get back to normal, but we will lose any appreciation that we would have gotten during this time period while the market is down.  Thanks for the comment!

 

Bob

 

P.S.  If you would like to read the follow up to this post, please check the link that I'm inserting into this post. 

10:05pm • #10

What does the graphic say?

Leave a response…



(optional)
What does the graphic say?
 

Bob Mitchell - Realtor St. Louis

Saint Louis, MO

More about me…

ValueList Real Estate Services, Inc.

Address: 4251 Martyridge, St. Louis, MO, 63129

Office Phone: (314) 231-5478

Email Me

A blog about St. Louis real estate and about real estate in general from a guy who has been selling real estate and doing mortgages since 1984. I'm also the owner of ValueList Real Estate Services, Inc. a discount real estate company serving St. Louis since 1995!


Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog