About ten days ago, I read with great interest a post by a Florida real estate agent and member of AR who wrote a very convincing blog post which argued that new Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke will single-handedly rescue America from the "laxity" of the Greenspan era.  And if you didn't know anything about economics or how the Fed works, you might actually have believed what that blog author was writing.

Spend an hour listening to former Federal Reserve Economist Edward Lotterman and you'll learn how inaccurate and misleading that AR blog really was.  Lotterman spent nearly a decade as a regional economist for the Fed in the 1990's.  During that time, he was responsible for preparing the Ninth Federal Reserve District's section of the Beige Book, the briefing which is compiled for every meeting of the Fed Open Market Committee.  So I think it is safe to say that Lotterman understands the workings of the Fed better than most Americans.

Lotterman says that "the most common error in reporting on the Fed is to overestimate the power of the chairman of the Board of Governors".  Regardless of who occupies the Fed Chair position, the job carries with it far less power than the public has been led to believe.  "The Fed is not a dictatorship", he writes.  Lotterman goes on to state that power over key market decisions at the Fed is "diffuse and not readily apparent". 

A couple of other informative points were provided in a recent Lotterman newspaper column:

  • If the Fed decides at a particular meeting not to lower interest rates, it is because there is not a clear majority of members of the Open Market Committee who are in favor of such a rate cut.
  • Bernanke has no authority to change monetary policy by himself. He must secure a majority vote in either the Open Market Committee or the Board of Governors, not an easy task.
  • The Fed Chairman is bound to adhere to the Tax Laws handed down by Congress and the White House.

Former Chairman Alan Greenspan did NOT single-handedly ignite the housing "bubble" that developed during his term.  Again, the structure and governance of the Fed does not permit its Chairman to be solely responsible for policy decisions.  Greenspan did a great job of keeping inflation at bay during two tumultuous decades.  And he helped navigate the U.S. economy through a series of boom and bust cycles, under multiple Presidents who gave him a blank check to do so.

I agree with Lotterman when he writes, "Business reporters can be excused for missing details.  Wall Street gurus claiming to be Fed experts have less excuse".

Copyright © 2007 by Eric Kodner, All Rights Reserved

 

10 Comments on Bernanke Doesn't Have a Monopoly on Fed Decision-Making

Hey Eric,

Thanks for that clarification on who is deciding the rates. I, like many people, thought that the FED Chairman made the sole decision.

Sean Allen
The Mortgage Professionals

09/04/2007 12:46 PM by International Financing Solutions


Good point, Eric, and a well written post.  There's a lot of misinformation about how the Fed works.

09/04/2007 12:52 PM by Brian Schulman - Your Lancaster County, PA Real Estate Professional (Coldwell Banker Select Professionals)


most people do not understand the "FED"

09/04/2007 12:57 PM by Jeff Tumbarello (Network Funding Solutions, LLC)


Hi Eric.   Informative post.  I guess most Americans would say they thought that the Fed Chief  does in fact make those decisions.  Seems like the decisionmaking is syronger when it goes through this process.  Thanks for the post.

09/04/2007 01:03 PM by Bill Gillhespy Fort Myers Beach Realtor (Century 21 Tripower Realty)


Eric,

The Fed chairman is more like a point man for the agency. The one who is supposed to possess the diplomacy to deal with the diverse interests of our economic environment. When things go well, he gets credit for it, whether he deserves it or not. And when things go bust, he'll be blamed. Good post about his power. Or lack of it. 

09/04/2007 01:10 PM by Esko Kiuru - Las Vegas NV Mortgage Consultant (Sinifox Financial)


Sean -- it's easy to be drawn into the impression that the Fed Chief or the President alone run the show. 

Brian, Jeff & Bill -- I think Americans love simple answers to complex questions!

Esko -- "Point man" is a good description of the Fed Chair job. It's about diplomacy and leadership in many ways.

09/04/2007 01:15 PM by Wayzata Lakes Realty: Eric Kodner Sells Luxury Homes


Great post, because he is the front man, we assume he has total control. Excellent information, Eric.

09/04/2007 04:40 PM by Missy Caulk Ann Arbor Real Estate (Keller Williams Ann Arbor)


Thanks Missy. I think it's important for people in the industry to understand some basics about the workings of the Fed.

09/04/2007 05:53 PM by Wayzata Lakes Realty: Eric Kodner Sells Luxury Homes


Eric...that first paragraph alone deserved a good rating from me.  Snarky yet authoritative.  Very good!

09/08/2007 02:20 PM by Hemet Home Loan Guy, Joey Aszterbaum (Patrion Mortgage)


Thank you Joey!  I've never had anyone refer to my writing before as "snarky"..

09/09/2007 09:33 AM by Wayzata Lakes Realty: Eric Kodner Sells Luxury Homes


This blog does not allow anonymous comments

 
Real Estate Brokerage: Wayzata Lakes Realty: Eric Kodner Sells Luxury Homes
Eric Kodner, Lake Minnetonka Homes & Madeline Island Real Estate
Minnetonka, MN
More about me…
Wayzata Lakes Realty: Eric Kodner Sells Luxury Homes

Office Phone: (612) 670-2539
Email Me
Currency Converter
View My Stats Locations of visitors to this page


Wayzata, MN (55391) Weather Forecast


Links

Tags (Tag Cloud)

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog
ATOM 1.0 Feed for this blog

Find MN real estate agents and Minnetonka real estate here on ActiveRain.
Disclaimer: ActiveRain Corp. does not necessarily endorse the real estate agents, loan officers and brokers listed on this site. These real estate profiles, blogs and blog entries are provided here as a courtesy to our visitors to help them make an informed decision when buying or selling a house. ActiveRain Corp. takes no responsibility for the content in these profiles, that are written by the members of this community.
© 2007 ActiveRain Corp. All Rights Reserved