Special offer

Making Your Mortgage Payments Faithfully May Be Hurting the Economy

By
Real Estate Agent with RE/MAX Properties SW, Inc.

A recent Rismedia article speculates that paying your mortgage on time when you're underwater may not actually be the best thing for the economy. The reason is that most of these homeowners are paying higher interest rates than the current national average and despite the fact that they have jobs and can afford the payments, the debt load is keeping them from refinancing, moving to a larger house or a different neighborhood, spending money on a new car, and so on.

The article states that there's an estimated 15 million upside down homeowners and roughly half of them owed at least 25% more than their properties were worth in March of 2010. More than 4 million are upside down by more than 50%.

These people are essentially trapped and probably won't see positive home equity values for years. They can either quit paying and suffer the loss of credit and be forced to move, or they can continue to fore-go spending money that would help the general economy in order to make their mortgage payments. The question is, which course would help the economy recover more quickly?

Source

Greg Cook
Platinum Home Mortgage - Temecula, CA
Mortgage Consultant NMLS ID# 283159

Eric, it's probably un-ethical for us to recommend someone quit making their payments when they can afford them, but your point is well taken.

Like your market, ours is flooded with foreclosures and as a result the overhwelming majority of homeowners are underwater.

My advice (off the record) is if you're bleeding, stop the bleeding! Your credit will come back before you equity does.

Nov 06, 2010 09:41 AM
Eric Martell
RE/MAX Properties SW, Inc. - Orlando, FL
Ph.D.

Thanks for the response, Greg.  I'm in agreement with you that we shouldn't recommend that someone stop paying. 

If you'll notice, I carefully didn't take a position either way.  I was hoping for some discussion in the comments favoring both sides. 

The take-home message that I got from the original article (click on Source in the post) is that the crash in real estate values and the massive mortgage mess are going to require some thoughtful action and sacrifices on the part of all involved parties and not just the home owners before some sort of equity is achieved.

Nov 06, 2010 11:09 AM
Anonymous
Greg Cook

The "to default or not to default" is the 800 pound gorilla (Magilla?) in he room. I would be interested to know how many clicks you have because it seems like you and I are the only ones who think this is important enough to discuss.

I guess your other readers are only worried about whether or not they should take an overpriced listing. :-)

Nov 07, 2010 01:16 AM
#3
Eric Martell
RE/MAX Properties SW, Inc. - Orlando, FL
Ph.D.

Greg,

Thanks for the interest.  Only 67 views after 3 days and about 5 of them were mine.  No one much seems to be interested, not counting the people who actually read the post and start to think about the issue.  I've been posting on the mortgage mess for some time now and normally don't get much interest, save for a post where I suggested some possible steps to begin to reset the system - that really got a bunch of people upset.  I'm of the opinion that we're going to see change whether we want it or not.

Nov 07, 2010 09:19 AM