Special offer

Home Value Protection Plan, Really???

By
Real Estate Agent with Keller Williams Premier

In reading a back issue of REALTOR (July/August '10) I came across an advertisement for Home Value Protection.  It is supposedly some program that buyers or sellers can buy in which it protects a home's value against local market declines.  They state it "gives buyers the confidence to buy without fear, and helps sellers to sell faster."  I ended up going to the website provided www.workingequity.com/pro but the website said coming soon.  I wonder when that will be since it has been several months since this advertisement was released.

Anyways I did a Google search and found a Wikipedia link http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Home_Equity_Protection  that describes the program a little more in detail.  Basically what the program is, is that the person buying the plan purchases it for about 1.5% of the current value and then the person is required to live in the home for at least so many years, usually anywhere from 3-15 years.  If they move before this time they get no insurance coverage.  Well this might be good for someone moving in 3 years with the current market, this is an absolute waste for someone who stays in their home for 5-10 years.  In 5-10 years the home should be worth at least what it was bought for or more, based on historical evidence. 

Unfortunately I feel this is another way for another company to make some money with small fine print consequences.  If someone it thinking about buying a home and not sure if they are not going to live in the same place for a minimum of 5 years then you probably shouldn't buy.  Owning a home is a long term investment.  It is not considered to be a short term one.  The years of 2000-2005 put different thoughts in peoples minds.  A home is a place to raise a family, the feel of security, a place to change as you change without asking a landlord, and a place to welcome guests.  It is the American Dream but it was abused.  I find this program a joke.  I've never seen declining insurance for my phone, tv, or car's value.  Why don't they offer insurance for declining values on these?

Comments (3)

Anonymous
Concerned

I find your business philosophy a joke. Insurance is offered for declining values on cars, it's call gap insurance, look it up.

May 13, 2011 04:16 AM
#1
Anonymous
anonymous

This post is riddled with typos, maybe you should at least find out what spell check is. Also, you say in 5 years you will get the value you paid for??!! Tell that to all the people who bought their homes in 2006. You are an idiot.

Jun 28, 2011 05:27 AM
#2
Ryan Bretzel
Keller Williams Premier - Stillwater, MN

Anonymous,

I appreciate the comment however if you fully read the post you can see that I also do not believe in this program.  No one has a crystal ball and yes we are in hard times but over time values have always gone up.  At this point people buying are probably good for 5 years out but yes people who bought at the peak are in for a longer road.  As you can see this program recently came out so it would never apply to those homes bought back in the peak anyways.

Jun 28, 2011 09:09 AM