Members: 114,089 - 891 Online Now  Login
 

I just returned from a consultation where the counter-tops needed to be changed.  The homeowner was adamant she could get them replaced with granite tile for less than laminate counter-tops.  She is supported by Realtors who say that it would be a good move and they'll be able to advertise, "granite counter-tops"

I tend to believe granite tiles would be a let down for anyone going to view a $500,000 home (in Halifax, that's big bucks!)  I can't help but feel it is "false advertising" as well.  Am I wrong?  Since it doesn't happen very often, (LOL)  I would greatly appreciate any and all feedback.

She has a lot of work to get done and given her $3,000 budget for the whole house I would recommend a light colored granite/stone laminate to coordinate with the kitchen floor, which is blue/creme ceramic tile that has various earth colors in it.  It's not a elaborate and gorgeous as granite but it's real...

 

15 Comments on Need advice: Advertised as granite countertops - but it's really tile

I would guess that you could advertise granite tile counter tops, but tile and a solid counter top are two different things in my mind. I would still prefer the granite tile to a laminate countertop. Just my opinion.

09/10/2007 06:19 PM by Andrew Trevino Wilkes-Barre Homes For Sale (TradeMark Realtors Group)


Tina - It would be deceptive and from what most buyers would want. There is a big difference between granite and granite tiles. Just my 2 cents. 

09/10/2007 06:22 PM by Bill Gassett Metrowest Massachusetts Real Estate (RE/MAX Executive Realty)


If someone comes to view the house expecting granite and they see the tiles instead of the full counter-top they will be disappointed - it always looks like you cut corners with the work.  Buyers will start looking for other corners that have been cut.  With the budget that she has for the whole house it sounds like you have the better solution and a buyer could more easily justify replacing laminate than granite tile.

09/10/2007 06:24 PM by Jon Angevine Calgary & Airdrie Real Estate (Royal LePage Foothills)


I have also seen homes that advertise amenities only to have my buyer let down by the true product. In my experience this only upset the buyer and made them assume that if the seller truly believed what the agent was advertising then there had to be other things the seller was stretching the truth on. I would normally council my seller to put in whatever a buyer in that area would expect to find in a  home in that price range. If the sellers budget will not allow granite, though, I have seen granite tiled counter tops that looked very nice. Just call it what it is!

09/10/2007 06:25 PM by Roy Kotz (NPDodge)


In our area, listings will almost always indicate "slab granite" or "granite tile". This is no different than the distinction between "hardwood" and "wood laminate" in flooring. There should be no cause for deception if features are described properly.

09/10/2007 06:37 PM by RolandoTheRealtor, RE/MAX agent in Frisco/Keystone/Breckenridge, Colorado (RE/MAX Properties of the Summit, Frisco, Colorado)


Tina, that's a toughie- except that if a buyer decides to replace the countertop, it would be less messy to remove laminate.  People equate the granite tiles as a wanna be granite that couldn't afford the real deal.  I put laminate in my kitchen with the idea that when I'm ready for the expense of granite, it's easier to install- I wouldn't consider the tiles.  Now, magazines are indicating that granite (specifically darker colors) is "out"...

09/10/2007 06:38 PM by Options Realty


Look into your solid surface, but not granite options.  Products like Silestone are growing in popularity and with the green movement, granite is losing favor.  There are more than 2 choices for countertops - even though most sellers forget that - explore your options and you may be able to find a cost effective and attractive option that does not require questionable wording choices.

09/10/2007 06:50 PM by Kimberly Wester - NW Indiana Stager (Details Staging and Redesign)


The  main issue here is cost.  While the owner would LOVE to have granite, it is expensive.  Many people instead try the granite tiles....and as long as it is advertised as such, no biggie.  I just consulted on a house which had one island with granite-top and the remainder of the countertops were the same tile as the FLOOR!! Yikes.  And yes, the realtor put it in as granite in kitchen!!  Great. High-end home and misleading advertisement....irks me!!

Usually the word 'granite tile' countertops is used.  Kim has a nice suggestion with the Silestone however, the cost can be more than that of granite. BTW--Warm-colored Granite is still a preferred choice for many higher-end homes....the color Uba Tuba is what is out.  As a home renovator and Home stager, I am always looking for better ways to guide the seller and all I can say is....cheap looks cheap.  There is no getting around it.....and of course, like mentioned above, the buyers begin to look for more homeowner shortcuts!! 

Tina, I would gently advise the realtor to use the words granite tile in the listing if they choose to go that route...citing the possible disappointment from buyers if they see something less than what was implied or expected with 'granite coutertops'.  Good luck!  Regards-Kathleen

09/10/2007 07:12 PM by Kathleen Garvey-- Home Staging Naples & Ft. Myers, Florida (Enhanced Interiors & Home Staging, LLC)


I think frankly it's misleading and it's not going to fool anyone. People get into the home and they will see it. That issue aside, granite is much more expensive than laminate. It's just feels better texture wise. But if it's going to be done terribly they might as well stick with laminate with the limited budget.

Cindy 

09/10/2007 11:17 PM by Cindy Lin @ Staged4more, ASPM, IAHSP,IRIS, CSP (Staged4more Home Staging & Redesigns)


Tina you are absolutely right. It is wrong to advertise the real deal if it is not. I agree with Kimberly about silestone. It is becoming a popular alternative to granite. I would not go with laminate in a $500k home.

09/11/2007 03:49 PM by Ann Krewson, A.L.I. Designs; Staging Houston Homes; Allied Member of A.S.I.D. (A.L.I. Designs, Inc.)


I'm in agreement with what 'Rolando the Realtor' said above.  As long as it's stated that it's granite tile and not slab it's not at all deceptive.  The promotional materials should state "granite tile counterops" so as not to lead people to think it's slab.  If done properly, granite tile can look fabulous...and going this route will certainly save the home seller money.

Nancy

09/11/2007 04:14 PM by Nancy Maurer Whitehall Interiors& Home Staging (Whitehall Interiors & Home Staging LLC)


It's better to say what it really is...granite tile,... or say nothing at all.

 Sometimes granite 'remnants' are an option if there is not too much countertop to cover. If there is room in the budget, that would be a nice upgrade.

Wendy Casey

Vancouver, BC

 

 

09/11/2007 05:15 PM by Wendy Casey (A-List Home Staging & Decor)


Agreed Wendy, Nancy, Rolando, Cindy and others.....

Tile might be a four letter word, but it's accurate.  I don't believe that any amount of fabulous marketing is worth a dime if it sets false expectations for your buyers.  One disappointment in a house these days, and they're out the door!  Tell the truth, the granite tiles still have that sexy look, and no one will feel let down or worse....spoofed!

Just my two cents, with Cheers! from DC...

   Jaynee

09/12/2007 06:00 PM by Jaynee Acevedo, Capital Style Home Staging (Capital Style Home Staging)


Granite countertops can be very costly and I think can also be a very personal design choice for certain buyers. If the counters are NOT THAT AWFUL I always recommend changing things like flooring, lighting, etc. These make huge differences and help keep costs down. Houses have still sold with these other changes.

I only recommended granite once because the owner was a builder and had access to remnants and cheap labor, also his counters were pink laminate. The house sold!

Phyllis Pafumi 

 

09/15/2007 09:35 PM by Phyllis Pafumi-ReStyled to Sell Staging Homes NJ (ReStyled to Sell Home Staging New Jersey)


If you have to use tile get the really big 16" square ones, not the llittle 4".  There are less seams, it can look rich, have the grout match the tiles, it will float as one piece better. 

And yea, it should read granite tiles.

Let us know what gets decided - it will be interesting to know.

Good Luck,

Becky

09/16/2007 07:41 AM by Becky Raike & Nicole Forte -Staging Sells Your Home (Staging Sells Your Home )


Leave a response…

Name:
Notify me of new comments:
Comment:
What does the graphic say?
 
Home Stager: Tina Parker, UpStage Home ReDesign(.ca) (UpStage Home ReDesign)
Tina Parker, UpStage Home ReDesign(.ca)
Halifax, NS
More about me…
UpStage Home ReDesign

Cell Phone: (902) 229-5799
Email Me
As a Certified Professional Home Stager, Tina will combine proven home staging techniques with 20 years experience in design and target marketing strategies, using insight into the minds of potential buyers to produce an effective design approach. Locations of visitors to this page


Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog
ATOM 1.0 Feed for this blog

Find NS real estate agents and Halifax real estate here on ActiveRain.
Disclaimer: ActiveRain Corp. does not necessarily endorse the real estate agents, loan officers and brokers listed on this site. These real estate profiles, blogs and blog entries are provided here as a courtesy to our visitors to help them make an informed decision when buying or selling a house. ActiveRain Corp. takes no responsibility for the content in these profiles, that are written by the members of this community.
© 2007 ActiveRain Corp. All Rights Reserved