OK, have you heard this one before?

"Good morning....Tutas Towne Realty. This is Broker Bryant how can I help you today?"

"Yes....hi Broker Bryant we are interested in selling our house."

"Excellent! You have called the right man. I too am interested in selling your house. Tell me a little bit about your house and why you want to sell."

"Well...we bought our house in May of last year. It's was a brand new 4 bedroom Maronda home and we paid $275,000. We want to move because there's too much traffic in Poinciana and we don't like it here."

"OK....you know this is very bad time to try and sell a house. How much do you owe on it?"

"We owe $273,000 and know we won't get that much for it but we read that we can get a short sale."

"Well a short sale is for folks that are having severe financial hardship and are facing foreclosure. Based on what you have told me about your house it's probably worth about $200,000. After selling expenses you will have about $185,000 to apply towards your mortgage which means you will be short by about $88,000. Are you currently behind on your payments?"

"No.....but we don't want to live here anymore. If that's all we can get for our house then our mortgage company will just have to accept it."

"Folks, you really need to discuss this with your lender and then seek legal advice. There's really nothing I can do for you at this time. You can't just get a short sale because you don't want to live here anymore."

Now folks, I get these calls a couple of times a week. These people really believe they can just sell their house and the lender will automatically take what ever is left over. What's wrong with this picture?

  • I wonder how many folks are applying for a short sale that have the capabilities to make the payments?
  • I wonder why they didn't spend some time getting familiar with the traffic in Poinciana BEFORE they bought a house?
  • I wonder why they have NO incentive to keep their home?
  • I wonder if after talking to their lender they will decide to miss payments so they can become delinquent and claim hardship?
  • I wonder if since it was so easy to get the zero down loan to move in they figure it's just as easy to move on?
  • I wonder..................

This post was inspired by Bill Archambault's post "Politically Correct Entitlement"

All content copyright © 2007 - Broker Bryant Real Estate Ramblings

 

39 Comments on I wonder.............

Reserved Parking For "The Lovely Wife"...TLW...ROAR!

Blog Boy...

Okay. This situation is unflippin' believable.

Knowing our market the way I do...I will not be surprised that folks will skip payments to create hardship.

This is going to get worse before it gets better.

TLW...ROAR!

09/17/2007 03:49 PM by "The Lovely Wife"...Broker Bryant's Wife... (Co-Owner Tutas Towne Realty, Inc.)


They had better rethink selling.  But, of course, their home will get listed shortly, probably for $299,900.

Someone will list it.

 

09/17/2007 03:53 PM by Lenn Harley, Homefinders.com, MD & VA Real Estate


Broker Bryant (I think I have finally mastered the name) - I receive similar calls. I can only add that I do believe that generation of owners that have nothing invested in a home, fell no compulsion to try and keep it. I have always believed that a lot of these people did not comprehend the enormity of the purchase and just like marriages, plastic bottles, unwanted pregnancies, plastic bags and every other throw away item, they have no guilt about tossing the house.

Lenn may be correct about it showing up in the MLS for $299,900 but no one in our industry has come up with a sure fire way of getting a price that is 33% out of line.

09/17/2007 03:59 PM by John MacArthur The MacArthur Group (Long and Foster Real Estate, Inc.)


Boker Bryant, I was laughing at the beginning thinking this was a joke. Well in a way it is a joke. People need to learn that when they are buying a home they are making one of the biggest purchases of their lives. It is not like buying a pack of gum that when the flavor is gone you can just toss it out and go for another one!!!!

09/17/2007 04:11 PM by Camarillo CA Real Estate Agent/ Mana Tulberg (Beach View Real Estate)


I've gotten calls like that too.  I think it just shows how ethically void our culture has become that people are willing to become deadbeats.  Buying a home is investing.  Losses can happen, its a fact of life.  It is our job as Realtors to make people aware of this ahead of time!  

But in today's world of modern medicine they can replace joints, fix the heart and bring people back from the jaws of death but they still CAN'T FIX STUPID!

09/17/2007 04:19 PM by Daniel Sundberg Foreclosure Specialist (Crystal Springs Real Estate)


Broker Bryant,

Its really unbelievable how everyone wants a short sale now...they think because they heard so & so did it that they can too! I'm glad they called you, but I think Lenn's right someone else will list it for $299! LOL! :)

09/17/2007 04:24 PM by Suzanne Sands-Somerset, MA Real Estate (Century 21 Associates Realty)


I'm pretty picky about the listings I'm accepting right now. Too often, my short response is "you can't afford to sell". Even my magic wand can't fix this kind of mess :)

09/17/2007 04:29 PM by Portland Oregon Real Estate Broker * Jennifer Bukaty * (RE/MAX equity group, inc.)


WOW.  Are people really so willing to wreck their credit?  Just to move when they don't really have to??? 

To quote my brother, SHOCKING. 

09/17/2007 04:42 PM by Sarah Cooper (Real Estate Shows)


I am working with someone right now that will have difficulty affording their home soon, but can for now.  They were counseled to sell for short sale to get out (start missing payments), or to just buy the new house and let the current one go into foreclosure....  my immediate response to that was NO! 

09/17/2007 04:53 PM by Illinois Mortgage Lender | Kim Murphy (1st Advantage Mortgage, LLC)


BB- You are so right.  My phone is ringing off the hook with people wanting to know about short sales.  When I ask about their financial situation, most can afford to pay but don't want to.

09/17/2007 05:20 PM by Bradenton Florida Real Estate - Dan Forbes (Sarasota Metro Properties)


BB, I have writen so much on this subject, all in the Don't Do Short Sales vein. I'm glad to see you also taking that position. We all need to be responsible. A broker should not contribute to this deceit.

Bill Roberts

09/17/2007 05:57 PM by Bill Roberts - "Baby Boomer" Retirement Planning (Brooks and Dunphy Real Estate)


These people are DREAMING.  First of all, by the time their late payments are recorded, their credit is SHOT- slow pay can be worse than bankruptcy and foreclosure.  Secondly, the banks are often in LALA land with house valuations- they are WORSE than sellers when it comes to understanding the gravity of the situation, but by the time the sellers figure out that there WILL NOT BE A SHORT SALE, they're already in the throes of foreclosure.  The banks, at this juncture in my limited exposure, are continuing to play ostrich- and until they pull their heads out of their-oops- the sand, sellers considering this avenue may as well learn to write letters explaining why they have a foreclosure in order to obtain that 35% interest Visa with a bank balance required.  How's that for an opinion from a cranky person? :)

09/17/2007 06:12 PM by Options Realty


Bryant,

I love it.  becareful I got labeled a curmudgeon. Some people think they're entitled, just because they want it.

Bill

09/17/2007 06:34 PM by William J Archambault Jr (The Real Estate Investment Institute )


I surely hope this doesn't start to be the norm around here. We have been emailing our clients about possibly refinancing if their rates are going to adjust upwards in a few months. Tow calls a week is alot.

09/17/2007 06:34 PM by Missy Caulk Ann Arbor Real Estate (Keller Williams Ann Arbor)


Hey everyone, Took me awhile to get back here. Been pretty busy today. I appreciate everyone stopping by.

If you haven't already stop over and read Bill's post. The link is at the bottom of mine and was the inspiration for this post. He's an old "CURMUDGEON" but wrote a very good post:) What the heck is a curmudgeon?

I'll be back.

09/17/2007 06:41 PM by Bryant Tutas-Tutas Towne Realty, Inc


BB,

I have one right now where she just wants to give up and abandon the property after stopping payments.

09/17/2007 06:45 PM by Neal Bloom-Realtor ® Assoc.-CRS-Weston FL (RE/MAX Premier Associates)


I wonder how many scumbags will come out of the woodwork to show these folks how to work the system.  This could also be called conspiracy to commit fraud, but who's counting?

09/17/2007 07:22 PM by Rich Kruse (Gryphon USA, Ltd.)


You should also consider the people who can no longer afford the payments with Florida's increasing property taxes and insurance rates. Then if you add someone who's lost their job ...

09/17/2007 07:28 PM by Sharon Simms St Pete Florida CRS CIPS CLHMS (RE/MAX Metro)


I wonder how many of them really understand what a short sale is going to do to their credit report?

09/17/2007 08:12 PM by Chico CA Real Estate by Sandi Bauman, Chico CA Realtor (Chico Homes Real Estate)


Haven't had this experience myself, Bryant, but I know people who have. Some sellers just want to give the house back to the lender, who does not have to agree to do so. It's hard to reconcile this attitude with those who really ARE in a hardship situation and stuck with payments they cannot make. They clearly have no clue about the implications of what they would like to do.

Jeff

09/17/2007 08:21 PM by Jeff Dowler ~ Carlsbad Real Estate (RE/MAX Associates)


So many people make big decisons without giving it much thought.  If traffic was such a big pet peeve that should have been checked out prior to buying the house go figure.

09/17/2007 09:39 PM by Jennifer Fivelsdal, Rhinebeck NY (Keller Williams Realty)


Oh gosh..... It is just so sad that consumers only get half the information correctly and they try to use it to their advantage.... just because. I wish sometimes people think seriously before they act.

09/17/2007 10:05 PM by Loreena Yeo - Realtor(R)/Broker proudly serving Frisco TX Real Estate (3:16 team REALTY)


Bryant,

Rich was right.  You did say it a bit nicer, but your point is loud and clear.

09/17/2007 10:42 PM by Fran Gatti - Crescent City CA Real Estate (RE/MAX Coastal Redwoods)


BB,

Once again you have satisfied the masses with a blog....Thanks for writing and I look forward to the next one....By the way what happened to TLW she's been missing from active rain for 5 count them 5 days now?
I hope you haven't done anything crazy Byrant....Like sending her on a vacation by herself or something!

Anticipating your next BLOG>>>

Brandon

09/17/2007 11:12 PM by Brandon Causey Realtor Coastal Palmetto Realty LLC (Coastal Palmetto Realty LLC)


A listing I just withdrew was a failed short sale, but it was with clients that were in financial hardship, facing foreclosure, and were more than a year late on payments. I never would have thought that people would actually try to mimic this situation to get out of a home.

I starting laughing as soon as I read this but then I realized "Wow, this really is not funny. They were serious."

This little couple just put the the LIE in cLIEnts!

09/18/2007 12:06 AM by Joshua Lazaro, serving New Orleans and the Greater New Orleans Area!!! (Prudential Gardner, Realtors)


this one made me laugh pretty hard - these are too funny for you to make them up -

09/18/2007 01:31 AM by Central Oregon Real Estate | Thesa Chambers, Broker (RE/MAX Sunset Realty La Pine)


Bryant,

I just wrote a post yesterday about a sale I have going on right now where the seller's ARM is adjusting and he's treied everything he can to hang on, including refinancing his residence (this is an investment property) to help pay for it. He's truly in a tough spot, but he's fighting for all it's worth to keep everything above water. It makes me sick to think of this seller you have wanting to do a short sale because they don't like where they live.
Where do you think they learned about short sales?

09/18/2007 06:53 AM by Andrew Trevino Wilkes-Barre Homes For Sale (TradeMark Realtors Group)


BB,

I still hear this everyday, people looking to just give away their homes regardless of what they owe!! Just not Realistic at all!!

 

Tom Weiss

09/18/2007 09:03 AM by Thomas Weiss (Thomas R. Weiss)


Broker Bryant- You nailed it once again.  Little money out of pocket..looking for the quick fix, and lack of understanding if certain situations apply.  If we do a better job of educating consumers perhaps we can help them.   

09/18/2007 09:10 AM by Allison Stewart REALTOR ®St. Cloud Florida (Florida Pines Realty, Inc)


BB: Someone will list it and Poinciana's overpriced inventory levels will continue to grow. It is a situation repeated throughout the country.

09/18/2007 09:14 AM by Roberta Murphy ~ Carlsbad Real Estate (Villa Sotheby's International Realty)


It is utterly amazing that people do not understand that buying a home is a commitment.  You are married to the house.  It doesn't just disappear with no ramifications.

You want to lose $95,000 because you don't care for traffic?????????  Heh????????????? 

Do they plan on purchasing another home...EVER??????

But I have seen it as well.  I had a client who hadn't paid the mortgage in four months and truly, didn't know why his credit score dropped "THAT QUICKLY."

How could you just not accept some responsibility for a commitment that you made? 

09/18/2007 09:15 AM by Virginia Halter Broker, ABR, CRS (RE/MAX Signature Properties)


BB, I just don't understand people's attitudes today.. Just don't get it at all

09/18/2007 11:44 AM by Lysa Napolitano, Call Coordinator ~ Century 21 Sundance (Century 21 Sundance)


Amazing how many people think they can just walk away from their obligations. I had a similar call last week. I recommended they speak with the lender. Have not heard from them yet and don't really expect to anytime soon, at least for 90-120 days!

09/18/2007 12:42 PM by Gary Waters - Real Estate Agent Viera Suntree (Century 21 Baytree Realty www.moving2brevard.com)


BB - Wow that is amazing that you get a few of those calls a week...how depressing! It is a wonder you are able to keep such a positive attitude.

09/18/2007 02:55 PM by Bill Gassett Metrowest Massachusetts Real Estate (RE/MAX Executive Realty)


Bill, Yep I get a lot of these. It's so easy for folks to walk away when they have no money in the deal.

Gary, I guess they figure in a couple of years they'll be able to buy another house anyway. And you know....they're probably right.

Lysa, Folks just don't care. No responsibilities. We live in a disposal world. Contracts and obligations don't mean squat.

Virginia, I think the divorce rate is well over 50% so why should they stay married to their house? 

Roberta, You're right about that. Probably won't disclose the short sale either.

Allison, I sold a house last year(my listing) and 5 months later it was back on the market as a preforeclosure. The buyer made 1 payment and then stopped paying!

Tom, Thanks for stopping by. Folks were buying homes and treating them like rentals. Actually with 100% financing and the seller paying closing costs it was cheaper to buy than rent. A rental requires a couple of thousand to get in. They could buy with nothing.

Andrew, I have sellers like that too. A short sale should be the last resort before foreclosure not just a way to move because you don't want to live there anymore. 

Thesa, I spend quite a bit of time in business shaking my head in disbelief.

Hey Joshua, Good to see you. Short sale is the new buzz word.

Hi Brandon, Stay tuned. TLW is posting tonight. It's a good one!!!

Fran, Rich is not one to mince words. He's EVIL you know? :)

Loreena, It's up to us to educate as many consumers as we can.

Jennifer, You think?

Jeff, Calls like this actually piss me off. It's hard to be polite when I tell them no thanks.

Sandi, The ones I talk to certainly don't get it. They truly believe it's no big deal. Hopefully an Attorney can clue them in.

Carole, I agree. Too many folks right now that really need my help for me to waste time on these types of listings. 

Sharon, It is getting expensive to own in Florida. I have a seller on a fixed income and NO mortgage who is paying almost $700 a month for taxes, ins and HOA dues on her little 2 bed townhouse. By the time she adds in her utilities she can barely afford to eat. That's sad when you're 80.

Rich, That's a good point. I wonder of it fraudulent? I wonder how they prove hardship without lying?

Hi Neal, More and more of my sellers are just giving up and walking away. They are too depressed to even try and save their home.

09/18/2007 04:41 PM by Bryant Tutas-Tutas Towne Realty, Inc


Odd...but the same people making these types of calls are the same ones that will complain about others that scam the system.  Do they not see themselves as doing that?  Maddening.

09/18/2007 11:24 PM by Carol Smith, ReMax Preferred, REALTOR®, Toledo, OH (www.calltoledohome.com)


Carol, I guess they just don't get it. And that's a shame. 

09/19/2007 02:31 PM by Bryant Tutas-Tutas Towne Realty, Inc


Leave a response…

Name:
Notify me of new comments:
Comment:
What does the graphic say?
 
Real Estate Brokerage: Bryant Tutas-Tutas Towne Realty, Inc
Bryant Tutas Broker/REALTOR(R) Tutas Towne Realty, Inc
Poinciana, FL
More about me…
Bryant Tutas-Tutas Towne Realty, Inc

Office Phone: (863) 438-9003
Cell Phone: (407) 873-2747
Email Me

Buy Poinciana Real Estate Sell Poinciana Real Estate Poinciana Real Estate Poinciana Real Estate Poinciana Real Estate Agent

All original, all the time.          Broker Bryant's ramblings on    Real Estate in Poinciana, Fl

 


Tutas Towne Realty, Inc
Tutas Towne Realty, Inc
Visit Poinciana Peeps Community Network


Links

Tags (Tag Cloud)

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog
ATOM 1.0 Feed for this blog

Find FL real estate agents and Poinciana real estate here on ActiveRain.
Disclaimer: ActiveRain Corp. does not necessarily endorse the real estate agents, loan officers and brokers listed on this site. These real estate profiles, blogs and blog entries are provided here as a courtesy to our visitors to help them make an informed decision when buying or selling a house. ActiveRain Corp. takes no responsibility for the content in these profiles, that are written by the members of this community.
© 2007 ActiveRain Corp. All Rights Reserved