In Northern Virginia we have a large number of neighborhoods with homeowners associations (HOA) and the closer you get to DC the more condominiums (COA) you will find. Our contracts spell out the delivery and receipt of documents and the time-frame for review of these documents for buyers.
Unfortunately many agents misinterpret the time-frame and advise their clients they have three days AFTER the deliver of documents to respond. This is incorrect. If you read the contract it says WITHIN three days. If the documents are delivered at noon on Friday the clock starts ticking then. Not on Saturday. So the time-frame to respond and possibly withdraw your contract without penalty is on the following Monday by noon not Tuesday by 9 PM.
Why do I bring this up? Recently in a contract review continuing education class only 2 of us had the correct interpretation of this statue in our Virginia contract. That was out of a class of close to 40 agents and brokers with varying length of experience in our market. The instructor brought up numerous court cases where buyers had tried to use the HOA and COA contingency to break their contracts and lost due to the misinterpretation by their agents of the timing. In addition I've run across a couple of blog posts recently written by local agents giving buyers the impression they had an extra day.
Certainly I don't know what happened after the court cases and whether agents found themselves filing claims with their E&O carrier to cover lost earnest money deposits. However if you are an agent in Virginia please double check the language in the Virginia Jurisdictional Agreement and speak to your broker. Don't leave your buyer holding the bag due misinterpreting one word in our local contract.
What I also find interesting, was in VAR's recent issue of its magazine was that the resale package doesn't have to be complete in order to start that clock. That was VAR's perspective.
There is a world of difference between AFTER and WITHIN, and you have just pointed out how costly it can be!
Great information here Cindy not only Buyer beware but agent beware ..READ!
HelpfulHannah
What I have also found is courts are very forgiving on the days. If you were to run over one day, the court is unlikely to say the buyer didn't have the right to cancel. The law is not as black and white as we may hope. Of course, that's no excuse not to adhere to a time frame. Just sayin.'
MAR often changes the language on these important documents and it is imperative that we, as agents keep up. Scary that such a few percentage got it right.
Chris Ann-just read that this afternoon. That's a different spin and does every know what is a complete HOA or COA package?
Andrea-though I can't cite court cases the instructor did have some hefty examples of what it cost the buyers when they took it to court.
Hannah-it was surprising how many agents and brokers in the class got it wrong. Don't think they will from now on.
Elizabeth-I guess it also depends on how tough the seller wants to be. If they are willing to let it slide, especially if there are other contingencies in play then so be it. If they want to play hardball I'm not sure how a judge would be able to rule against what is written in the contract.
Ellie-everytime I go to a contract update class I learn something new or something I forgot is brought to my attention again. I usually go more than the required 2 year timeframe as keeping up is critical.
Cynthia-you are right. There are plenty of who don't read the contract. I'm not an expert but I try to keep up with what's going on.
Hmmmmm..... I'll have to double-check the wording on Maryland contracts for delivery of documents.
Cindy,
I'm sure there were one or two lawsuits resulting from the agent mistakes as well.
Rich
Richard-I wouldn't doubt that the agents ended up on the hook if it was determined to be their error.
Steve-the difference between AFTER and WITHIN can be huge if you want to use HOA docs to break your contract.
Comments(18)