Over the past year or so I discovered an interesting Real Estate wrinkle I call "The $800,000 House Phenomenon." I didn't recognize it at first because I think it used to be called "The $600,000 House Phenomenon" but as the housing market changed, so did the phenomenon. And although I personally find it unique to the Northeast Side and North Shores of Chicago, its probably present in every market in any city at some pricepoint or another. It lays out something like this:

A client, or more accurately a young couple, decides to buy their first big single family home. If they are North Shore buyers then they have visions of a white, Center Entry Colonial built in the 1940s-50s on a 'Father of the Bride', 'Home Alone' or any John Hughes movie setting type of street. If they wish to reside in the city proper (in this case Chicago) then its a beautifully rehabbed brick and lead glass expanded cottage or carriage house, walking distance to the lake, zoo and parks. This is their housing vision. They live in nice, tricked-out condos now but they want 'The House.' And again, this phenomenon is very neighborhood specific. Its a 'location' thing.

The fact that "The $800,000 House" is obviously under a million dollars makes it appear 'do-able' from a financing point of view--after all, who really wants to spend a million bucks on a house when you're still in your early to mid thirties? Anyway, at least once a week I get a request to assist in the search of just such a home..."around the $800,000 range...in a great neighborhood..." And here is the reality:

Two-thirds of the houses I find in this price range are either overpriced by a hundred thousand or so already (sometimes more) or just poorly remodeled little things with low ceilings, average to bad bathrooms and kitchens that if priced more correctly, would already be torn down. And needless to say, you can pretty much forget New Construction. Across the board, my clients are generally a little discouraged by what I send them in this price range because what used to be the $800,000 neighborhood is now the nesting ground of the soon to be built 2.5 to 3 million dollar 6.000+ square foot New Construction House. Its still an $800,000 Neighborhood--it just doesnt include the actual HOUSE. This all has to do with a Real Estate term called 'The Highest And Best Use" of a property which I think is pretty self-explanatory. And I dont think its a bad thing either. I sell a lot of New Construction that serve higher and better uses than what previously stood on the site.

But it is a little sobering when you actually come face to face with what's on the market (housewise, that is) for under a million in Chicago. Simply navigate around my search engine linked at Chicago's Home Weblog and you'll see that  many of the homes dont look enticing enough from the MLS picture to even request a showing. And most, if not all of my clients' condos from which they are moving have better finishes and appointments. Again, I find that these properties comprise about two-thirds of what's out there. One must keep in mind that the 'Location' rules and if the 'Location' happens to have a ho-hum building on it with a bulldozer parked in the driveway, so be it. The truth of the matter is the million dollar plus housing market expands and ticks up every month leaving the $800,000 House that someone might actually move into a little further behind in almost every way. But this too, is a good thing. You gotta have 'appreciation' and on a personal level it makes my job more interesting, more challenging, and more rewarding when I do connect with the perfect house. And they do
exist. Read on.

Most of the remaining third of inventory are correctly priced at land value only and WILL be torn down if they dont fall down on their own waiting to close. The remainder of the remainder--those few rare gems that boast curb appeal, livability and attractive pricing--are what I'm talking about. Now we're in 'the zone' and the scenario plays out like this:

On a weekly basis, a handful (maybe less) of homes in the $800,000 range appear on the market and by "market" I mean a good portion of the Northeast Side of Chicago and almost all of the desirable "upper-end" North Shore communities within an hour drive of the Hancock Building. Many have had new and sometimes drastic price reductions because the now increasingly discouraged owners who originally felt their homes were worth "a million" realized the Buying side of "the market" wasn't responding. This is usually attributed to a combination of timing and simple Incorrect Pricing and is a topic I have addressed at length in a previous Blog. These homes are too nice to tear down and while not without a few obvious flaws; dated baths and kitchens, small closets, no central air, odd shaped or irregular sized lots---they are still, all things equal, solid properties with decent curb appeal worth maybe in the mid to upper 700s as of this writing. Many of these may be a little overpriced but are still able to command a negotiated offer that is acceptable to both the Buyer and Seller. I negotiate more than my fair share of these as well.

And finally, what's left of the above handful are the cream of the housing crop--new on the market with significantly better renovations and curb appeal, on the prettiest streets in the most desired neighborhoods with the highest rated public schools. These go into multiple offers the first day or so on the market with few or no contingencies and virtually No Negotiation. These are the true $800,000 Homes. These are homes that more than one Buying entity likes (loves) (desires) enough to write a contract on the spot and close in 30 days. These are the ones that WILL be worth a million in short order. They are generally priced right for a timely sell as the house is already flush with Equity and the Owner needs to move on NOW--no fooling around, no testing the market. As I mentioned earlier, I have at least one person a week asking me if I know of any of these. And what do I do?

Bubble notwithstanding...I put them in the car immediately and tell them without hesitation about this "$800,000 House Phenomenon" I discovered.


posted by Geno Petro

DISCLAIMER

{I recently posted a picture and an accompanying story on my primary Blog and was informed by another site's SEO that my duplicate content might get me banned from Google! Wow, I had no idea. But I reminded myself that ignorance of the 'law' is no excuse. The content apparently needs to be 25% different (am I there yet?) and thus, a commentary before or after should be in order. (Obviously this is an example of a commentary before a duplicate post.  All previous AR entires I have already submitted will soon have commentarfies after the duplicate post as well---but I suppose they {the commentaries} will each need to be 25% different) I don't know nothin' about nothin'. It wasn't me. Why didn't you tell me? 

The truth of the matter is I stumbled across Active Rain by accident while checking out Sellsious. It wasn't sure anyone in the blogosphere was even looking at my primary Blog since I had a total of 1 comment from a friend and 1 comment from my wife and 1 comment from an insane person (a diatribe, actually) the first 3 months I was up an posting. I didn't think my stuff was that bad so I decided to start posting here as well. So from here on forward and backward, this is my 25% Difference Non Duplicate Discalaimer, and I'm sticking to it...unless its a bannable offense from Google  in which case I'll sell my overpriced Google stock and show them! I'll ban them from my portfolio. See how they like it when I give them no page rank! Now I know 'I'm double dog daring' a big guy on the playground (Jean Sheppard reference for my Philly friend, Brian Brady) but right now according to Google, I'm not even another Bozo on the bus. So Thus I Disclaim and wait for the axe.}

 

 

 

41 Comments on The $800,000 House

NOV
20
2006
185,770 Points 28 Featured Posts Outside Blog
so eloquently written!  in our market, that's the $500,000 phenomenon...may I borrow some of your post and blog around it on my website?
7:17pm • #1
13 Featured Posts

Leigh, feel free. click on "posted by geno petro" and it will take uoi to my Chicago blog site. Lot's of interestingreal estate stuff, I think. Also feel free to link. I went to high school in Charlotte. I love N.C.

 

 

7:28pm • #2
185,770 Points 28 Featured Posts Outside Blog
You're so gracious-thanks!  Where did you go to high school?  I think i'm one of the last three natives in this area. =)
7:29pm • #3
13 Featured Posts
Myers Park. I also spent about 10 minutes at Lees Mcrea Jr College before they politely showed me the door---back in 1974!
7:34pm • #4
7 Featured Posts

Hey...I'm originally from up there, Chicago !!

Great Post Geno !!

8:02pm • #5
3 Featured Posts

Great post Geno!  This is a good conversation for some of my clients.  Where are you in the picture of your profile?  I can't seem to identify the place. 

8:17pm • #6
13 Featured Posts

Thanks Lauren. I'll contact you when all my clients from Texas get sick of this weather (and politics) and want to move back. I've had four relos here in the past 18 mos from TX. They're all Republicans!

 

 

8:17pm • #7
13 Featured Posts

Bianca,  Thank you. That picture is in Cannes.  G

8:19pm • #8
3 Featured Posts
Looks like a fun place.  Is it a naturist place?
8:21pm • #9
2 Featured Posts

Geno, great writing, thank you.  It reminded me of what might be the flip side (no pun intended) phenomenon, what I call the "$10,000 Vega".  A long time ago, Chevy made an unassuming little car called the Vega.  I can't tell you how many of those things ended up getting all tricked out, fancy paint, fancy wheels, big motors shoehorned into them (some with blowers!)... we had one up the street that the owner used to put out on the lawn with the For Sale sign on it... $10K O.B.O.

Right... it's a VEGA, for crying out loud!  It's only worth $800, IF I wanted a Vega.  That silly purple car sat out there with the sign for over a year.  It might still be there.

I see alot of little 1100-1300 sq ft, 3 bed 1.75 bath homes that "ought" to be $160-190K, depending on where in the city it is and how well kept it is.  But for some reason, the owner has gotten carried away with the Parade of Homes look, and these poor little houses have slab granite, wood floors, Tuscan light fixtures, crown molding, carpets deep enough to lose a small child in, jetted tubs, dual head showers, AND the stainless industrial grade chef's appliances in the kitchen.  What were they thinking?  $259-269K in a first-time buyers' neighborhood... it's a classic "$10,000 Vega".

Sometimes this is a really amusing business.

8:25pm • #10
13 Featured Posts

Bill, now that's funny. I saw a headline on 'The Onion' once that read   "$800 Car gets $3,000 Stereo" Same thing.

Bianca, I'm not quite sure how you would categorize the South of France. I guess maybe there is some nature  going on there. I saw a lot of Ferraris.

 

 

8:38pm • #11

It seems like the same is happening here in western wa.

8:49pm • #12
1 Featured Post Outside Blog Hit Router

great article!  Well written with some good advice...

 

 

9:43pm • #13
13 Featured Posts
Thanks guys. G
9:49pm • #14
21 Featured Posts

Geno - If you tire of those $800,000 buyer's send them over here to Naperville... that's a fun price range here (unless you want to be downtown that is)

Moo

10:10pm • #15
2 Featured Posts

We have some of that here in KC but not to that extent.

10:15pm • #16
242,517 Points 11 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Good point Angus - Geno send them to Pueblo and I'll sell them 7-8 houses for that price point.  I see your point, but I'd be grateful to work with people in that price point. But the up side is that people who only pre qual for $80 are grateful to have a home at all.
10:24pm • #17
8 Featured Posts Outside Blog
I'd be happy to entertain some of your $800,000 house clients in the phoenix metro area :)
10:41pm • #18
2 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Wow that house in the picture doesn't look like $800,000!! ;)~
10:45pm • #19
477,401 Points 151 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Geno... I am not a realtor...but some good writing. And it looks like you gave some realtors here a way of thinking of things.

 And Carl.... lol  I actually did a mortgage for someone buying a $500,000 house outside of DC. It was only 1,250 sq. ft. and a co-worker owned the same size house with a yard outside of Philly and it was worth $75,000. It's amazing that certain geographic areas can be that much of a difference.

10:52pm • #20
212,206 Points 56 Featured Posts Outside Blog

As expensive as everyone thinks Miami is, I think Chicago has us beat.  You can still find reasonable homes here for $800K - it's still a good price range - although we are creeping up  the million mark.  That does not at all include waterfronts.

ines

10:57pm • #21
Great post, man.  Here in the Triad of NC, that happens around $350,000.  I could use some more $800,000 loans though.  Can you get some of the folks to invest down here?  LOL.  That majic price break is amazing though.  It's such a psychological thing, and people do not even catch themselves thinking like that.  It's almost a status thing, yet it's also something personally satisfabout feeling good enough to do something bigger than average.  Everybody does that across all levels and puurchase types though. Whether it's homes, cars, or clothes, it just changes the break point in dollars. 
c
11:44pm • #22
NOV
21
2006
8 Featured Posts Outside Blog
One more thought - the concept of your post should be familiar to most realtors.  What might be nice - to compile a list of what the $800,000 house actually equals in different markets??
12:51am • #23
2 Featured Posts

well put Geno, it's unfortunate though, I usually meet the buyer for this house at the same time the phenomenon is listed.  They think it's a sales pitch, don't cough up an offer and are chasing the phenomenon for way too long.

kind of like the sellers you were convincing to list, didn't believe it was a good time, thought the prices would be up in the spring to cash in.

don't it always seem to go, you don't know what you got till it's gone...

2:50am • #24
1 Featured Post
Hey Geno, great point made.  This same thing goes on in Atlanta, but around 500,000k.
6:37am • #25
3 Featured Posts

WOW Gino,

I go to sleep and look at all the trafic you had last night.  Hey, some times you can see a lot of nature in the South of France, where you in Cannes for the film festival?  

7:49am • #26
13 Featured Posts

I just made a  folder of all the realtors and mortgage brokers from the different markets who comment on my posts. When I run across a person getting ready to relo out of Chicago I'll pass on the info and be in touch. So Dana in Pueblo, you may very well be able to take one of these '$800,000 buyers' and sell them 8 properties! A lot of comments are saying the same thing--that every market has its own 'break point in dollars' (Jeff from N.C. Triad). Needless to say, the only reason I even have time to write a blog these days is because everything has stalled a little here. I think its probably due to the 'Believe everything you hear in the Press Phenon..."

 

 

8:40am • #27

Geno --

I'm friends with Leigh but just found your blog and thought it was very informative and you are right on the money here.

 

Leigh and I grew up in CLT in same community.  I am now 15 min's from Lees McRae College, selling a new development.  

 

I love Chicago!!!!  I will keep watching your blogs.

Nicole
9:25am • #28
171,010 Points 4 Featured Posts Outside Blog
That price point is still moving quickly in the Phoenix area - if priced correctly.  We had a few in the last 3 months - including one priced by the previous listing agent at $1,050,000 which naturally expired (since nothing in the neighborhood had ever sold for more than 900K - and if there was going to be a first - this wasn't it!)  The owners paid $680K in April of this year, listed with us in September at $850K and closed the following month at $835K.
9:34am • #29
13 Featured Posts

Thanks, Nicole.

 

Suzanne, that's good to know. The real point I was making and you just confirmed it, is there is still a market frenzy at a particular pricepoint for a certain type of house. The problem begins when someone paid "$680K" a year or so back and feels its now worth over a mil--then lists it at that price, then stalls the market, then reduces the price along with everyone else. There's a another group of people called 'bubble sitters' I refer to on my Chicago's Home Weblog site who are just waiting to 'pounce' when the right property shows up. Unlike a stock market correction or even the 'dot.com' bubble of past (where fortunes can be totally lost), a persons house will almost never be worth '0.' (speculative developments notwithstanding). And when a whole lot of overpriced homes linger on the market  for 180+ days it is quickly reported as bad news. The truth is, in many cases, its someone who recently paid $680 and now wants over a mil....then Suzanne comes along and sells it for $835!

 

 

 

10:24am • #30
3 Featured Posts

So true.... We have the same phenomenon out this way at numerous price points. 150k, 450k, 600k, 800k. It just seems like at all of these price points, what they are really looking for is just out of reach. Fortunately with the current market, there is enough bending room to work things out.

10:27am • #31
395,776 Points 16 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
As Suzanne pointed out - Sellers need to be educated about price.  It's easy to dazzle them with high numbers - but it also is in violation of the NAR Code of Ethics to fib about the value in order to take a listing.
10:29am • #32
186,251 Points 12 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
no matter what th price point it seems that they always want more than what their getting.  In our price market it is the $150K house that they expect to be perfect, and the seller expects to sell it for 180K...  Same sentiment different commissions!!!
8:57pm • #33
13 Featured Posts

Chris, what you say is true. And I must also say the majority of my sales are condos in the $400-500K range so its not all upper level home sales for me, either. I remind myself constantly though that I do represent a client (in their quest for 'perfection' at a lower pricepoint)and my self-interest is further down the list of priorities. Still, it is a little frustrating when a client passes on the best listed property on the market wanting  even more for their money. Especially out of town buyers from the southern states. $500,000 here buys a fairly nice 2 bed 2 bath 1500 square foot, 3 or 4 year old condo fairly close to the lake. Parking is usually another $25-30K. I know that in most other cities you can buy a pretty nice 3,000 sq ft home for the same price.

 

9:12pm • #34
3 Featured Posts
Definitely not just in Chicago.  Value is in the eye of the buyer, not seller.  I think more people are starting to see that.  We have seen that with the tremendous influx of CA people who are tired of shacks for 1/2 mil. 
9:19pm • #35
13 Featured Posts

Angus, I will send any Naperville people your way. Usually they're coming here from there but every month or so I do get
an internet lead requesting your area that I don't know what to do with.

9:28pm • #36
Great post. We had a huge run up in prices in the last 4 years, mostly due to the new University of California campus being built and now open here. Speculators drove up the prices at about 20% year over year for 3 years. But guess what, they are going down just as fast. I just listed a home that is just two years old for $389,950. Trouble is they owe $538,000. My point is things can change just as quick.
9:48pm • #37
21 Featured Posts

GASP! Nobody leaves Naperville...(unless they are being transferred) Say it ain't so.....

 

9:56pm • #38
NOV
22
2006
1 Featured Post
Beautifully written Geno.  I really enjoyed reading this riff.
9:27am • #39
Hey everyone.  At least the ground stays put under those $800,000 Chicago homes.  I have seen crazier stuff in Orange County CA, with no yards and just a steep slope in the back.
c
5:46pm • #40
NOV
23
2006
13 Featured Posts
Thanks Jeff (again!) and Jason for the comments. And Jason, thank you for the post on your blog.
8:32am • #41

Leave a response…



(optional)
What does the graphic say?
 
Rainmaker_large

Geno Petro

Chicago, IL

More about me…

ChicagoHomeEstates.com

Address: 916 W Diversey, Chicago, IL, 60614

Office Phone: (773) 975-2130

Cell Phone: (773) 720-2634

Email Me

Thoughts of a top producing downtown Chicago Realtor. Organic real estate-centric content, updated news feeds, MLS search engine plus an eclectic sidebar of urban lifestyle links to explore, comment, trackback, ping!...


Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find IL real estate agents and Chicago real estate on ActiveRain.