Special offer

For $15 Million Dollars I'll list homes for sale on my website for free too!

By
Real Estate Agent with Suburban Village Realty

A new twist on the real estate game with old ideas. From Crains Chicago Business --> http://chicagorealestatedaily.com/cgi-bin/news.pl?id=26512

The concept behind listing homes at a lower fee to attract buyers is nothing new -- just the way money is being raised to start these new companies up. What I find most interesting is that these supposedly new ideas are being started up by people new to the real estate business.  Instead of hard work and building a system up that actually makes money, let's just raise the money through an IPO or Venture Capital using other people's money (OPM) on something that loses money. From Crains Chicago:

"Iggys which was launched in April 2005, had lost a total of $7.6 million since March 31, according to a registration statement filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission last month. The firm faces a crowded field of online competitors, including ZipRealty Inc., iNest Realty Inc. and Redfin Corp."

It's the Dot com game all over again except it is being applied to ideas that are nothing new in the real estate business. 

"Iggys plans to raise $17.25 million in the IPO, using the proceeds for general corporate purposes, including marketing and technology, according to the registration statement. Minneapolis-based Northland Securities Inc. is the sole underwriter for the offering."

Wow, we've got it all wrong. Any real estate Broker with a website should just form a corporation raise a couple million in an IPO and list homes for free on their website. It's certainly a lot easier then actually selling real estate.

"This is an industry that desperately needs to be transformed," Mr. Fox says in a recent news release. "Fixing the broken real estate and mortgage industries requires revolution, not evolution." 

There really is nothing revolutionary about this concept and the only thing new about this business model is how money is being raised to fund it.

Personally, I see nothing innovative about using the MLS for something that it was not created to be used for. I'm not going to elaborate on this topic but it basically involves making money off of other people's work.

Rolling the dice in Real EstateReally now, what would stop anybody with a real estate license from applying these concepts? I'll try out the same concept for $5,000,000 of somebody else's money and we actually have experience selling real estate!

 

 

Comments(6)

Hayden Gerson
HPM Financial LLC - San Diego, CA
There was a company in San Diego called I Pay One, they even bought the name rights to the San Diego Sports Arena (turned into the I Pay One Arena) they advertised on TV, Radio, and Newspaper, and they were out of business in less then a year. They would charge a 1% listing fee, then go on the MLS and offer $1.00 to the buyers agent, their thought was that instead of agents selling the house for $1.00 they would refer the client to I Pay One, needless to say they lost millions and are gone.
Sep 27, 2007 01:45 PM
Suburban Chicago Illinois Real Estate
Suburban Village Realty - Barrington, IL

Hayden,

Thank you for stopping in and contributing -- proof positive that the ideas and success rates are hardly far from new. Hmmm... Maybe I should just go public and do an IPO!

Sep 27, 2007 01:50 PM
Hayden Gerson
HPM Financial LLC - San Diego, CA
Old Fashoned hard work and great service are the key to making a million bucks :)
Sep 27, 2007 01:51 PM
David Stewart
On Top of the World Communities, Inc. - Ocala, FL
I'm willing to bet that the boys' experience with the LA real estate agent was something they asked for: They went to a friend, or they told the agent they didn't want to be tied down to one agent, or they wanted to look on their own. Otherwise, the story is unbelievable.
Anyway... what a business model--let me see if I have it correct... They sign up a buyer, have the agent who REPRESENTS THE SELLER present the house, and they write it up. Then they collect the selling side commission and rebate most of it.

A few missing things: What about agency? What about procuring cause? I always ask people who call about my listings who their agent is (not, "Do you have an agent?", because people lie more often in response to that). If they do have an agent, I tell them to have the agent show it, as I do respect their relationship with the agent and I do respect procuring cause.

If they want me to show it, I explain to them that if I show it and they buy it, I expect to get paid for the buying side, yes, as well as the listing side, since I am the procuring cause if I am the one providing the information they used to find it and I'm the one showing it, explaining it, and handling it. This BuySide Realty doesn't do a thing to procure except fill in blanks. They do not provide agency--that is, they do not do their fiduciary duties to either side. And since I am procuring cause, there will be no split paid to another broker.

Now, since it's my listing and as the Fox brothers say I do want to sell it, shouldn't I show it anyway? Sure---and put myself at risk of an accusation later of undisclosed dual agency? Sure---and take the risk of showing a house to a stranger who says they have another agent, and so don't have to do any qualifying with me, for safety or finances? How exactly can I qualify someone who comes in with an absentee agent?

Sorry. This BuySide broker's model depends on transferring all risk to the listing broker, doing nothing but paperwork, and demanding a paycheck for virtually no work or value added. I'd certainly be telling my client that the buyer had 2.25% more money to spend, since they were getting that much back, so counter at a higher price. After the BuySide agent got off his hind and showed the property properly, because no, I'm not going to do it if you do have an agent.
Sep 27, 2007 04:17 PM
Mike Klijanowicz
Cummings & Co. Realtors - Perry Hall, MD
Associate Broker @ Cummings & Co. Realtors
Client Follow Up and prompting for referrals will generate millions in sales and commissions, it just takes a little bit of time!
Nov 21, 2007 11:09 AM
Suburban Chicago Illinois Real Estate
Suburban Village Realty - Barrington, IL

Thanks Michael,

I'll make sure I let my wife who is a Brian Buffini Mentor know this!

 

Nov 22, 2007 05:26 PM