Special offer

Congressman Dingell proposing 50 cent gas tax increase and elimination of Mortgage Interest Deduction. Are you Kidding Me?

By
Real Estate Broker/Owner with Jonathan and Associates, Inc
 Today, United States Congressman Dingell (Democrat- 15th District in Michigan) unveiled a draft proposal that would seek to eliminate the mortgage interest tax deduction and add a 50 (that's fifty cent...not the rapper for the kids reading this) cent tax increase on unleaded fuel.  For homes over 3,000 sq. ft., the current mortgage interest tax deduction would be "phased out" and eliminated entirely for those wiith homes over 4,200 sq. ft. I wonder if that includes a basement? According to Dingell, the tax increase is for global warming (yet Diesel vehicles are excluded) and the AP article that removing the mortgage intereest deducation from those with larger home "is only fair" since they are the ones moving out into the suburbs, creating urbal sprawl.  So I guess my wife Tabitha and I better not have more than one child since there won't be enough space for family and dogs in the government mandated electric car that will be parked outside of a 500sq. ft. studio condo. 

Talk about a party divided.  On the one hand, you have those from that party who are seeking to be president likening our current economy to that during the Great Depression and here you have Dingell disagreeing with these unbelievable taxes. 

The part that is most interesting is the guy who is drafting this bill: Representative John Dingell (D-Michigan).  Having this guy deciding on matters relating to taxes for the county is no worse than appointing The Cookie Monster to the Health and Nutrition Board with the FDA.  I say this because the economy in his state is in crisis in many cities and using it as a model for which to decide our economy on would be like taking parenting advice from Michael Jackson or Brittany Spears.  So here's the breakdown of Michigan's economy (the highlights only):

  1. 7.2% Unemployment Rate in August 2007 (up from 4.2% 10 years ago) - Courtesy the Bureau of Labor Statistics
    1. North Carolina's is 4.8% and South Carolina is 5.6%
  2. Michigan reported 15,565 foreclosure filings in August 2007, up 127% year over year. In the state, there are 1 foreclosure filing for every 288 households. Wayne County accounted for 60% of those filings, where there was a foreclosure filiing for 1 in every 87 households.  Wayne County is the District of our favorite Congressman.
    1. During the same period, North Carolina ranked 22nd, South Carolina ranked 35th (Higher is better) - Courtesy of Realty Trac
  3. In August 2007, home prices in Detroit fell 7.1% while Charlotte North Carolina experienced a 8.4% growth. - Yahoo Finance
  4. According to the state of Michigan's own property tax estimator, the taxes for a $200,000 home in Wayne County (primary residence) would be between $4,600 - $6,600 annually. 
    1. A similar $200,000 single family detached home would be between $1,800 - $2,300 depending on location.  In Union County, just south of Charlotte, the property tax would be closer to $1,000 - $1,300 annually estimated. - CMLS

So the question once again is....what is Congressman John Dingle (D-Michigan) thinking?  Clearly, high taxes and unemployment have benefitted his state for so long that maybe we should be so fortunate. 
Google Reader or Homepage Subscribe Add to My Yahoo! Subscribe with Bloglines Subscribe in NewsGator Online BittyBrowser Add to My AOL Subscribe in Rojo Subscribe with Pluck RSS reader Eskobo Add to Technorati Favorites! Subscribe in myEarthlink

Digg!

Sincerely;
Jonathan Osman
The Charlotte House Hunter
Charlotte NC Homes, Charlotte Real Estate

Maureen Francis
Coldwell Banker Weir Manuel - Bloomfield Hills, MI
Coldwell Banker Weir Manuel

Jonathan,

I haven't read much about Dingell's proposal, but I take offense with some of your statements.  I would hate to see the mortgage interest rated deduction taken away.

Michigan's current economic situation has everything to do with the fact that for decades we have been completely reliant on one industry.  This has nothing to do with one politician.  A politician, even from a state that is facing difficultly, is certainly capable of contributing to the discussion on the national economy.  Your arguments about why he is not qualified to comment are irrelevant.  

Sorry you consider us a blight. 

Sep 27, 2007 09:21 PM
Jonathan Osman
Jonathan and Associates, Inc - Charlotte, NC
Charlotte House Hunter Group

Maureen;

Your own state's economists have acknowledged that Michigan has been in a one state recession for years.  Just look up the articles and you'll see.  Yes, a lot has to do with manufacturing jobs going away however the Carolinas went through far worse when the textile industry (which created classes of extreme poverty) went away.  Today, those jobs are being replaced by jobs in the health care, financial, and technology and they weren't home grown. 

I would never claim to be the smartest guy in the room nor am I out to offend anyone and so for that I sincerely apologize.  It seems to me that like business, if you're doing poorly, you need to attract new business before things get too out of hand.  The one thing I am sure of, and this is from my days working on Capitol Hill with Congress, is that your elected representatives - especially one that has been in The House (which is even more important since the Senate has no control over spending) for over 50 years - do not fall far from the mindset your's local officials.  After all, it is their job to put earmarks in the spending bills to help back in their districts and to use their influence to help their constituents.

Thanks for reading and commenting 

Sep 28, 2007 04:22 AM
Jonathan Osman
Jonathan and Associates, Inc - Charlotte, NC
Charlotte House Hunter Group

Follow-up to the blog entry....

Because I was challenged that I didn't know what I was a talking about regarding my earlier entry, I found a story today on Michigan Live.com talking about that the state government in that state just past a record tax increase to prevent a government work stoppage.  Residents will face a higher income tax and expanded sales tax.  http://www.mlive.com/newsflash/michigan/index.ssf?/base/business-13/119127926058980.xml&storylist=newsmichigan

So to that I say....Come on down to Charlotte!!!

Oct 01, 2007 05:31 PM