Special offer

What Caused The Real Estate Bubble? AND - HAVE WE HIT BOTTOM?

By
Real Estate Broker/Owner with Connect Real Estate - REALTOR / BROKER DRE # 01427063

What is A Housing Bubble?

A housing bubble is usually characterized by a fast surge of increases in home values until unsustainable levels are reached in relationship to incomes.  Then once the peek is reached and affordability is out of reach, this fast surge is directly followed by an equally fast decline in home values - resulting in negative equity for homeowners. 

This means that if a person received a bank loan and bought a home during the peak of a bubble, once the bubble bursts, that same home is worth thousands - less or in the case of the California market, hundreds of thousandsless - all within a matter of months or 1-3 years.  Also, this resulted in homeowners having a mortgages/bank loasn on homes that were much larger than the home's value.

What About the U.S. Housing Bubble?

The United States housing bubble is an economic bubble that effected many parts of the U.S. housing market.  Housing prices started climbing in mid 2004, peaked in early 2006, started declining in 2007 and many experts say, have hit bottom in 2011.  On December 30, 2008, I read in the Case-Shiller home price index report - it stated that it had the largest price drop in it's report history in December 2008.

What Caused The Housing Bubble?

The underlying reasons and causes for the housing bubble are complicated.  Many blame the interest-only loans, and ARM loans (Adjustable Rate Mortgage) written for home buyers.  In my opinion, these types of loans have been a huge factor here in my area - Ventura County (Southern California).  I know this because each time I List a home for sale, and it is a "Short Sale," the overwhelming hardship reason stated is, the payment "adjusted" and I just couldn't afford to pay it. 

Some Other Causes... 

  1. First, tax policy - for example, the exemption of housing from Capital Gains. 
  2. Next, the historically low Interest Rates during the bubble.  This allowed home buyers to qualify for homes that, under historical interest rates, may not have qualified. 
  3. Then, the lackadaisical lending standards (there were "no doc loans" and "100% Financing" loans being made in order to accommodate the mounting pressure to qualify for the upward surge of home prices). 
  4. Next, very importantly, as home prices were driving upward (in 2005 and 2006), homeowners were refinancing and pulling cash equity out of their homes, which some months later proved to be unwise. 
  5. And then finally, the failure of our Regulators to recognize the many warnings, and intervene sooner rather than later!

What happened when the bubble burst?

Increased foreclosure rates in 2006 and 2007 with U.S. Homeowners led us to a real crisis in August of 2008 for the subprime, mortgage, credit, hedge fund, and foreign markets too.  In October 2007, our U.S. Secretary of the Treasury stated that the bursting of the housing bubble was "the most significant risk to our economy."

The collapse of our housing bubble had a direct impact on more areas than just home values.  The collapse also has impacted our nation's mortgage markets, home builders, and Wall Street hedge funds.

What did the Government do to help compensate for the bubble burst?

Worry about the heavy impact of our housing market collapse, and imploding credit markets in the U.S. economy, led President George W. Bush and the Chairman of the Federal Reserve, Ben Bernake to announce a limited "bailout" of the U.S. housing market.  This "bailout" was for our homeowners who were not able to pay their mortgage debts. 

In 2008 alone, our U.S. Government allocated over $900 billion to special loans and "rescues" related to our housing bubble bursting.  The majority of this money went to agencies of Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and the Federal Housing Administration.

What Now... Have We Hit Bottom?

The opinions vary, however it appears that we have.  With a total of 3,825,637 foreclosures filed by year end 2010, the purge seems to have taken place.  At this point, the cost to rebuild may outweigh the cost to purchase in some areas of California.  This supports the "hit bottom" position.

 

Posted by

Connecting Ventura County's Best Home Sellers and Home Buyers...!

 

Temple Schneider Callahan, RE BROKER

Certified Short Sale Specialist

Connect Real Estate Services

BRE: 01427063

Ventura, CA

email: Temple@ConnectRES.com

www.ConnectRES.com

www.YouTubeChannel.us

www.FaceBook.com/Temple.SchneiderCallahan

Direct: 805-208-6024

 

Tom Robinson
Keller Williams Realty Kingstowne/Alexandria, VA Office - Fairfax, VA
Experienced Real Estate, Professional Serving No. VA and DC

Some economists are saying this may be America's lost decade like Japan had in in the 90s. I hope not but growth seems to be flat and housing prices and sale  certainly seem to have stop going up after a nice bump in the last year (in my market). In the D.C. area it is easier to find a house to buy than to find one for rent.

Jun 17, 2011 04:08 AM
Jack Gillis, M.B.A., J.D., LL.M. Dallas, Texas 214.718.4910
Coldwell Banker Apex, Realtors - Dallas, TX
Locally Known, Globally Connected, COLDWELL BANKER

I have been in real estate since 1980 from land developer to home builder to Realtor. I have been through several so-called "bubbles," but this time it was a world wide economic recession. Hopefully, I won't see this one again.

Jun 17, 2011 04:09 AM
Mike Carlier
Lakeville, MN
More opinions than you want to hear about.

We can analyze the cause of the collapse of the housing market and subsequent drop in values, but the time for that is after the recovery.  Right now, there is a compelling need to get the industry back to a reasonable level of robustness.  The nation's economy will continue to drift aimlessly until the housing market has returned to a reasonable level.  Home prices may or may not have hit bottom.  They are close to stable in many markets, and it does not appear that there are any sharp declines ahead. 

Banks and the government have joined together to do nothing to facilitate a more rapid return to housing industry normalcy.  Our unspoken policy is to put forth effort to sell REO property to investors so everyone in America can more easily become a renter.

Jun 17, 2011 04:19 AM
Charlie Ragonesi
AllMountainRealty.com - Big Canoe, GA
Homes - Big Canoe, Jasper, North Georgia Pros

Well, I really liked your analysis. I thought it was well written and made a number of good points. I think you did not include the, in my opinion, a major contributor to the housing bubble and later crisis. In the 1990's and thru the early 2000's an extreme amount of foreign capital flowed into this country. In fact Greenspan and Bernacke told us all this was a good thing. Foreign money came into the U.S because we were a safe haven for investment. On the surface this all seemed good. But that money had to go somewhere. Where it ended up was in the housing market. So it fueled the fires of inflation in pricing. And created the capital necessary for folks to borrow and go into debt. There was so much money that banks and brokerage houses needed to create all kinds of mortgages to spend the money. They ran out of "good Borrowers" so started lending to others. Then when that was not enough the commodities act of 2000 overturned State laws that went back to 1900 that prohibited things which we call today derivatives.

So I think your analysis was great and highlighted all the things that went wrong. But none of this could have happened if the amounts of money that came into the country were not there. The Fed with some notable exceptions totally missed the boat and what would be a set of inevitable consequences from this inflow of capital.

Again I really liked this post and would recommend a book this time it is different if you wish to look at some additional analysis

Jun 17, 2011 04:22 AM
Josh Feinberg
Crestmark Realty Group LLC - Scottsdale, AZ

Great Post, Great Information....I belive more information about the bubble needs to be posted its an important aspect of the current economy.

Jun 17, 2011 04:31 AM
Rob Arnold
Sand Dollar Realty Group, Inc. - Altamonte Springs, FL
Metro Orlando Full Service - Investor Friendly & F

Very well thought out article.  I think there was also a ton of speculation involved by investors.  People buying multiple properties trying to flip them for higher only to get burned when they did not sell and the prices collapsed. 

Jun 17, 2011 10:09 AM
William Feela
WHISPERING PINES REALTY - North Branch, MN
Realtor, Whispering Pines Realty 651-674-5999 No.

I agree with Mike....we can anylize all we want but that does not bring things back to normal.  It is an attitude that things are getting better.  It is a media that decides it is time to get on the train of positive outlook and not always the doom and gloom bringing the people only part of a story and only the worst part.

Jun 17, 2011 10:48 AM
Lenn Harley
Lenn Harley, Homefinders.com, MD & VA Homes and Real Estate - Leesburg, VA
Real Estate Broker - Virginia & Maryland

This "report" totally ignores the government's role in passing Gramm-Leach-Bliley, the MBS fiasco and the influences of sub-prime mills to feed Wall Street.

We all know the effects.  This piece totally ignores the causes.

Jun 17, 2011 12:05 PM
Ron Brown NMLS #270845
NMLS ID: 40831 - Federal Way, WA

I agree with Lenn.  There are many aspects that were glossed over.

That being as it is, we will not see a "bottom" to housing prices until we get unemployment under control.  Housing prices have historically held at roughly three times a buyer's annual earnings.  With low interest rates feeding a "free money" atmosphere of consumption as people tapped new found equity to purchase more "stuff" our economy experienced false growth.  Now that ship has sailed, and we're left holding the bag (or the bill) for government spending that assumed GDP was like housing prices, and could never stop.  Until we get job creation (and I don't know how we're going to do that with wages at the top of the Global economy), there cannot be a "recovery." 

Jun 19, 2011 01:47 PM
Temple Callahan
Connect Real Estate - REALTOR / BROKER - Ventura, CA
Search Ventura County Homes For Sale CA

My goodness - there are a lot of educated and governmentally informed people here on AR!  Thank you so much for all the thought provoking comments.  I really appreciate the wisdom.  I am doing some more research, and I will write a "part 2" to this blog I think.  God Bless...

Jun 21, 2011 02:22 AM