Okay, so I encountered one of those 'first time' events this past week.

 I am representing some Buyers on the purchase of a house in Port Orchard WA. They're a really sweet young Navy couple, first time Buyers, he just made Chief. We've been having a blast!

We went under contract and conducted our inspection. We petitioned the Sellers to remedy a reasonable list of items. Rather than correct the issues, the Sellers offered a cash settlement to be credited to the Buyers at closing. After negotiating the dollar amount, both parties agreed, and onto 'Pending' we go.

This past Friday I contacted the Seller's Agent to request permission for some 3rd party contractors (an AC & Heating Technician, and an Electrician) to gain access to the home to make some the repairs specified by the inspection report. This way, my Buyers can have the charges paid out of escrow from their credit.

The Seller's Agent informed me that the Sellers refused our request. They don't want anyone messing around, tearing stuff up, until AFTER closing.

I assured the Seller's Agent that we would draft a 'Hold Harmless' addendum, absolving the Seller's of any liability. I also stated that I would be present during any and all repair work, to ensure the safety and integrity of the home.

The Seller's still refused us access.

I'm curious. Is it just me? I mean, in all my real estate experience, I've never had this happen. It's fairly common for repair work to be done prior to closing, either by the Seller or the Buyer. I almost feel as though the Sellers are hiding something. The house was a rental, and is currently vacant.

Am I missing something? Should I have done something differently? Unfortunately, this is a VA purchase and the VA underwriters only allow a certain amount of money to be credited to the Buyers.

Follow KitsapAgent on TwitterFriend Rich Jacobson on FacebookJoin Rich Jacobson's LinkedIn NetworkSubcribe to Rich Jacobson's YouTube ChannelListen to My Sweet Tunes on Last.fm

 

22 Comments on "Is it just ME?" Correcting Inspection Issues Prior to Closing

20 Most Recent Comments Displayed Show All

OCT
14
2007
I'd saying hiding something or worried that the contractors/technicians determine the problems to be worse than believed, or someone uncovers latent defects.  Explain the buyer's concern to the Seller's agent, and/or ask for another reduction.
2:48am • #3
338,741 Points 52 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Good morning Rich.  I'm going to play devils advocate for a moment with this one.  If for some reason your buyer clients didn't close on the home, who would pay for the work that was done?   It could be that the sellers do not have the money to pay out of pocket if it doesn't close and that is what is worrying them.  Since they didn't have the repairs done themselves but negotiated a credit to the buyer for them, this tips me off that they don't have the money to do this until they close on the home.

In my market area repairs are normally done after closing unless the repairs are lender mandated or there is something major that needs to be taken care of in the inspection report.

I am surprised though that in this market the seller isn't allowing this and adding a simple "bill the buyer" addendum to the work order if they don't get to closing.

2:58am • #4
597,029 Points 106 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router

I can see a seller not wanting someone making alterations to the home until it records.  There is always the "what if's".  What if it doesn't close?  What if they do some other damage or not make the repairs correctly? What if the buyer changes their mind after spending additional time in the home, rethinking their decision?

I have had the seller credit used to prepay taxes or maintenance fees.

3:27am • #5
520,678 Points 229 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master
We're already maxed out on what VA will allow the Seller's to pay in closing costs.
4:32am • #6
338,741 Points 52 Featured Posts Outside Blog
I understand the the buyers are at the 6% cap that VA puts on seller credits...my question is this:  Would your buyer clients sign something that states they will be responsible for paying the contractors should the transaction not close?  If they do that, and the seller still does not allow this to be done, then it's red flag time. 
5:12am • #7
2 Featured Posts

Rich,

It could be that the sellers have some concerns about mechanic's liens if the property doesn't close or they could have been advised that the "hold harmless" clause really doesn't protect them or they could just be stubborn.

I agree with a poster above, run it by the listing agent.

6:38am • #8
165,653 Points 58 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router

I'm with you Rich. Slap around the co-broke agent.  WAIT...that's the answer on another post.  But could apply here too.  Sounds like the seller's are hiding something. My guess is they think the problems are larger than they have been identified.

6:41am • #9
1 Featured Post

Rich-

In our market, if the buyers get a credit for repairs, they are not allowed to do the repairs until after closing.  I agree with Fred and Randy that if the property doesn't close, who is responsible for the cost of the repairs?  If there was an inspection done and the buyer hired a reputable inspector, wouldn't he have found the problems to be worse?

We have a tough time getting a "hold harmless" to let our buyers take possession of the garage before close.  I don't think the sellers are hiding something, just protecting themselves.

7:17am • #10
1,911,854 Points 385 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Rich,

I don't know any agents around the DC area who would give access prior to closing, even though it sounds perfectly reasonable.  And can't the title company can make a check payable to the AC folks at settlement for work to be done later?

8:06am • #11
874,487 Points 154 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Rich, I only had one client do something similiar. I had the listing and when the buyer had an inpection on a 1800 furnace their inspector told them it was cracked. So we had our own mechanical inspector out who cleaned it and said there is no crack. So the buyers wanted their inspector to recheck it after it was cleaned and the rust gone. My sellers did not want the buyers inspector back in the house to tear apart the furnace.

They finally agreed to let them, if I was present and I was. They had already moved.

8:08am • #12
1,949,535 Points 478 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

I believe that's what the seller agreed to "cash at closing" for a repair credit and that's about it.

Any pre-closing repairs made would be the seller's responsibility and I don't believe the seller would have agreed to the "cash at closing" knowing that the repairs were expected to be made prior to closing.

Lenn "What does the contract say?" Harley

If I were the owner of a property on which buyers wanted to make pre-settlement repairs, I would want a sizeable "Security Deposit" from the buyers to cover the amount of the repairs and another few thousand $$ to cover damages should any occur during repairs.

A sticky wicket.

8:34am • #13

Rich - I'm actually with the sellers on this one.  Repairs should not be made by the buyers until after closing.  1) The seller is still responsible for the repairs because they still own the house.  No 'hold harmless' addendum will protect them, no matter how much one would want it to.  2) There are liability issues - if the contractors hurt themselves, it's the sellers who are responsible and it's their insurance that will be charged.  3) If the contractors do any additional damage or determine that more work needs to be done, there is the possible that the buyers will back out.  4) No deal is guaranteed until it is recorded.  5) The sellers agreed to a credit at closing - there is no reason the buyers need to be in prior to closing and the sellers have every right (without everyone thinking they are hiding something) to say no, after closing. Essentially, this is early possession.  We will not allow early possession and we let our sellers know this.  We've seen it all and it's now a black and white issue.  Just say no to early possession. 

9:18am • #14
315,754 Points 39 Featured Posts Outside Blog
I've had that happen Rich. Repairs ended up being made after the closing not before.
9:29am • #15
695,884 Points 39 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Hi Rich,

Yes, we have also had this experience.  Repairs to a home that isn't the ownership of the new Buyer yet is frowned upon always in our area.  In the litigious society we live in these days, nobody wants to be caught in a legal scenario. 

9:43am • #16
329,956 Points 12 Featured Posts Outside Blog

It's not uncommon in my area at all. We suffered a devastating hail storm this summer. It will be a year or better before all the damage is fixed. The storm hit a week away from closing. But instead of the sellers offering a credit to have the house fixed they stepped up fixed the problem and offered them the deductible on their insurance.

9:50am • #17
520,678 Points 229 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Wow, I guess from the majority of response, it must just be me. Personally, I think we've gotten so shell shocked about potential issues and litigation from early possession that we've gone to far to one extreme in what actually constitutes early possession. Bottom line is that we have to respect the wishes of the Seller. It's their home until closing. It's an inconvience for my Buyers. Some of the reparis are safety related issues, and they will not be able to move in until they are remedied, so move-in will be delayed.

11:28am • #18
OCT
15
2007
247,757 Points 25 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Called Shot Master
I think Lenn is right on with her comment.  I had an escrow where $6000 in repairs were done and the buyers backed out the day before close.  My seller kept the $1000 deposit, but it was little consolation to him as he gained a $5000 debt to the pest company.  As the listing agent, I would insist the buyers increase their deposit to cover the work, just in case. 
12:15am • #19
9 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Hi Rich,

A few good people touched on it already, the sellers desire to minimize responsibility for repairs. I don't think it's necessarily a result of hiding something. How are your buyers taking it? It still sounds like a good home, and if it cleared VA inspection, the repairs needed must be minimal...

 

1:17am • #20
520,678 Points 229 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master
Yeah, we'll work through it. My sense is that the house is fine. The repairs are fairly minimal, but some are safety issues, so they will need to be completed prior to them actually moving in. A slight inconvenience up front, but long term, not huge.
9:23am • #21
OCT
16
2007
2 Featured Posts

Yep Rich...It's just you on the this one.

While I have had a few sellers agree to let a buyer do repairs before closing, it is a rare thing.  Usually they want not only a hold harmless, they also want the money in hand to pay for the repairs if the transaction doesn't close.  That is, they want a non-refundable deposit equal to more than the estimate for repairs.

I have had very occasionally a seller allow a buyer to do minor repairs before closing.

I recently was called into the middle of a FSBO transaction to rescue both parties after repairs were made, and early occupancy was begun only to find out that the well went dry before closing.  That was a very long and tough transaction that we finally closed.  I worked on a consultant basis.  It was a nightmare that deserves it's own chapter in my memoirs.

2:43am • #22

20 Most Recent Comments Displayed Show All


What does the graphic say?
Leave a response…


(optional)
Spam Prevention:
 
Wharfpic2 Ambassador_large

Rich Jacobson Your Kitsap County WA Real Estate Broker

Poulsbo, WA

More about me…

Keller Williams West Sound Realty

Address: 3594 NW Byron Street, Ste. 101B, Silverdale, WA, 98383

Office Phone: (360) 499-6367

Cell Phone: (360) 440-4758

Email Me

Providing Knowledgeable Empowerment and Relentless Representation of Real Estate Clients throughtout the Western Puget Sound, including all of Kitsap County WA, and portions of Mason, Pierce, and Jefferson Counties.

"Helping You to Successfully Achieve Your Next Adventure in Life!"

Rich Jacobson
Rich Jacobson
Create Your Badge



Listings

Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find WA real estate agents and Poulsbo real estate on ActiveRain.