I've had a borrower approved for FHA financing for a purchase price of $125,000 for several months now.  Much of their credit documentation has expired and I've advised them that I'll need to get updated documedntation from them in order to update their approval of which I still have not received.

A few hours ago I get an email from their agent.  Asking me to provide a pre-approval for $156,000, $31,000 higher than our previous approval! 

Honestly, why on Earth would he be showing them properties in this price range when our approval was only for $125,000?  The borrowers debt to income ratios, at the $125,000 purchase price was already pushing 50% and we have some past credit issues.  With this increase to $156,000 my ratios now exceed 52%, I"m pretty certain the previous approval was capping out at a 50% debt ratio.  In my opinion, he should  have had them verify with their loan officer (yours truly) that a purchase in excess of $125,000 was even possible before he started showing them properties.

To me, these actions are a complete disservice to the buyers.  He KNEW they were only approved for $125,000 (as did the borrowers).  Now, here at the eleventh hour, he wants to submit an offer AND wants me to provide a letter to go with it.

I did speak with the borrower's wife (she can't be on the loan) to see if perhaps hubby has received a pay increase since our last approval.  She's uncertain.  I requested (again) updated paystubs but she won't have them to me until morning.

Do these agent's actions make sense to any of you professionals out there?  I feel like I'M somewhat being thrown under the bus by not providing a letter at this moment. 

 

Did you find my blog informative, fun or even entertaining?  If so, subscribe HERE!

 

 

 

Contact me for more information!

Email me here!

Visit My Website!

 

 
Post is included in group: Addicted to Active Rain
Post is included in group: BananaTude
Post is included in group: Bartender, Make it a Double
Post is included in group: The Lounge at Active Rain
Post is included in group: "Whacked"!!!

99 Comments on Why would the Realtor do this?

20 Most Recent Comments Displayed Show All

JUL
10
2011

Good business practice is to have your buyers prequalified, show them only properties they qualify for, and hopefully find and settle on a house. Repeat the process and life is good. On the other hand show everything and anything on the market then see if they qualify and feel the frustration set in.

10:43am • #80

Karen,

 

that was pretty much every first time home buyer deal I did from 2004-2007, and it still happens today. just not as much. It would really bother me that the agents would just go along with it, yes we both make more $$ if deal is higher but not enough to warrant me begging my UW to override a higher DTI,that is why we have so many foreclosures.. 

I will not put my name on  deal with is foreclosure waiting to happen ...

I have always told my buyers, DO NOT LOOK AT HOMES THAT ARE AT THE TOP OF YOUR DTI. but 8-10 would stil do it or at least attempt,

11:11am • #81
2 Featured Posts

Occasionally I have a buyer who suddenly decides to buy a higher priced home. Before embarking on showings, I ALWAYS call the loan officer to find out if they qualify for the higher amount, and sometimes they do. Not talking with the lender ahead of time is crazy.

11:16am • #82
699,194 Points 39 Featured Posts Outside Blog Called Shot Master

Nope, not to me. It's a disservice that's for sure to the seller. That's a lot of negotiating room if they think they can get it for a lower price. 

12:41pm • #83
1 Featured Post

Flash to agent - call lender before you even think about showing properties above the lending letter established limit.  If you feel that there are changes in the buyer's situation that should be re-evaluated by the lender, by all means, communicate and provide detail to the lender.  Don't you have enough to do other than day-dreaming in technicolor and providing your buyer with false hope (and probably losing them, too)? 

I'm sure, Karen, that this agent no longer has, if he ever did, your respect, and any offer that makes its way to you that has his name associated with it will be given a thorough second look, with deserved prejudice.

12:43pm • #84

Buyers deserve a competent professional AND an advocate representing their best interest.  Certainly you can show slightly above their pre qual limit in the hopes a low offer will be negotiated.  However, to encourage the buyer's interest in a property beyond their means is a lack of expertise in my opinion and the buyers should fire the agent and the LO should contact their broker.

3:01pm • #85
JUL
11
2011
583,938 Points 104 Featured Posts Outside Blog Called Shot Master

Some people just believe what they hope to be true - and ignore the facts. At this point you couldn't even give them a letter at 125 - right? You're waiting for new documentation.

Maybe they think if they can get you to SAY they can buy this house, then it will be true.

3:15am • #86
Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp

Is this a new agent?  Doesn't make any sense to me!

9:08am • #87
1 Featured Post

It seems to me that the agent AND the buyer are to blame here. The agent is at fault for showing the buyer properties that they cannot afford and the buyer is at fault for allowing themselves to be shown properties that they cannot afford. We all know what happens when you show a buyer homes above their limit. Nothing in their price range will ever compare. Karen, fortunately most of us possess a little common sense.

10:55am • #88
1,022,895 Points 15 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Called Shot Master

Sometimes we as agents loose control of the client or d not have the full story from them.  When they want to see a house outside of the budget I tell them they need to talk to the lender first.

12:16pm • #89
142,185 Points 7 Featured Posts Called Shot Master

Is that THE Bill Burns who used to be here in Medford?  How the heck are ya!?  Sorry, my water walking days ended in about 2006!  LOL.  Hope you are doing well, Bill!  All the best to you!

Morning Mike!  There are some instances that do warrant book writing however.  ;-)  Thanks for taking the time to read and comment.  Very much appreciated! 

Hi Ed.  Your business practice will definitely avoid a lot of frustrations.  Wishing you continued success!

Morning Brent.  I agree with you 100%.  And like you, I will NOT put my signature on a letter that is worthless or moreover, does NOT provide accurate statements.  Thanks for being on board with this one!  Have a great day. 

Hi Sylvia.  I'm in total agreement!   Thanks for being the voice of reason here!  Have a great day and all the best to you. 

 

12:40pm • #90
142,185 Points 7 Featured Posts Called Shot Master

Hi Lyn.  You are right that it's a complete disservice to the seller as well.  In this case, it was a short sale they wanted to put an offer in on.  What a complete waste of everyone's time on something that had no chance of going forward.  Thank you for your added insight! 

Ken...I'm guessing maybe he DOESN'T have enough to do!  <wink>  Thanks for taking the time to read and add some great comments.  Much appreciated.  Best wishes to you! 

Hi Linda!  Thanks so much for your great comments.  Agreed, It "seems" like there's more interest in a higher commission than what the borrowers can afford.  Have a terrific day and thanks for your visit! 

You're absolutely correct, Marte!  I'm awaiting on an updated Verification of Employment and wouldn't you know it...a new credit "issue" popped up on the newest credit report.  Lovely.....    Thanks for your visit and all the best to you! 

Hi Marsha.  While I've never worked with this agent before, I do recognize his name and he's been in the business for quite some time I believe.  Have a great day!

That's exactly right, Scotti!  They've now got champagne taste on a beer budget.  I'm reeling them back in and they seem to understand what I've communicated with them.  Thanks so much for taking the time to read and to comment.  Very much appreciated! 

Hi Gene!  Thanks for setting realistic expectations for your clients! Kudos to you!  

12:48pm • #91

An agent should be putting the clients' needs first, and it's difficult to see how encouraging the consideration of homes beyond their means accomplishes that.

2:56pm • #92
142,185 Points 7 Featured Posts Called Shot Master

Well said, Christopher!  You are spot on.  Thanks for your visit and taking the time to comment.  It's very much appreciated.  All the best to you! 

2:59pm • #93

The agent simply was not listening to anyone, especially you. He probably will lose the buyers because he built up their expectations and now he has to take them away.  Everyone needs to talk to the lender before anything happens.

Listening is what this business is all about.  Ask a question then wait 8 seconds for the answer before you say anything.

4:47pm • #94
142,185 Points 7 Featured Posts Called Shot Master

Hello #94.   Thanks so much for your visit to my blog!  I appreciate your comments, very much!  You are oh so correct...COMMUNICATION is KEY!  Thanks again and I hope you have a fantastic day! 

5:33pm • #95
JUL
12
2011
236,294 Points 9 Featured Posts Outside Blog Called Shot Master

I'm sorry if this was already asked and answered, but had you been in contact with the agent before this?  Had you provided the $125k approval or was this Realtor just showing properties blindly and possibly believing the clients that they were approved for that high amount? - Kasey

1:32am • #96
142,185 Points 7 Featured Posts Called Shot Master

Hi Kasey!  Thanks for your visit.  Yes, I had already been in contact with the agent.  At the end of May he was provided with a letter for the $125,000 approval amount AS WELL as advising him that the commitment had a June 30th expiration.  Borrowers were looking at short sale properties, so not surprising, there wasn't much activity from them.  Then, out of the blue, on the day I wrote this post, he said they were writing an offer on a $156,000 property.  When I told him I couldn't provide an approval at that amount currently (I asked the borrowers to provide some updated information to see if perhaps there was add'l income I could use), I even resent him the orignal $125,000 letter as a gentle "reminder" as to what the qualifications had been.  Thanks for your interest! 

11:08am • #97
JUL
19
2011
125,521 Points 4 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Wow, this is the same blog but from a lenders perspecitve. Just yeterday I read another one from a listing agent with the same frustration. Hope the fad ends soon:) Sounds like the buyer needs some gift funds, fast:)

 

1:23pm • #98
142,185 Points 7 Featured Posts Called Shot Master

Hi Elisa!  Thanks for your visit.  I may have to hunt down that other article you're referring too.  Glad it's not just "me" but DO hate to think others are experiencing the same frustrations.  Gift funds indeed!  Thanks again for your interest and all the best to you! 

1:35pm • #99

20 Most Recent Comments Displayed Show All


What does the graphic say?
Leave a response…


(optional)
Spam Prevention:
 
Bill_karen_wedding_pic

Karen Burket-Valley Mortgage Grou Conventional, FHA, VA, mortgages

Medford, OR

More about me…

Bank of Oregon a division of Willamette Valley Bank

Address: Medford, Central Point, Eagle Point, White City, Rogue River, Grants Pass, Klamath Falls, Jacksonville,, Medford, OR, 97504

Office Phone: (541) 842-5605

Cell Phone: (541) 890-3262

Email Me

Mortgage Calculator


Free Mortgage Calculator
Locations of visitors to this page

You can find great local Medford, OR real estate information on Localism.com Karen Burket-Bank of Oregon Home Loans Conventional, FHA, VA, mortgages is a proud member of the ActiveRain Real Estate Network, a free online community to help real estate professionals grow their business.
Feedjit Live Blog Stats


Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find OR real estate agents and Medford real estate on ActiveRain.