Plagiarism

Passing off someone else's work as your own, whether word for word or merely the creative ideas. This can amount to copyright infringement if permission has not been obtained from the copyright owner for use of the expressive elements of the work. Even if permission is granted, putting your name on someone else's work is still plagiarism and is unethical within artistic, scientific, academic and political communities.

The definition above comes from NOLO.com.  To me it highlights a mind boggling (or should that be blogging) question.  If you copy something word for word - no question that it is Plagiarism.  If you review several sources on the same topic, use that to spark some "original" thoughts and blog away - that MIGHT be considered Plagiarism.  If you even subconsciously recall some element of a creative idea you heard or read somewhere - that MIGHT be considered Plagiarism.  Even having copied and pasted the definition above -  MIGHT be considered Plagiarism.

How many words must be identical before something is considered plagiarism?  If you're going to write about something, for example "Phoenix", or "Real Estate" - those words have been used before, and will be used again.  At what point does it cross the line from being "original" to being "plagiarism"?

Plagiarism.org offers up Turnitin and iThenticate as two methods of combating plagiarism.  Don't know what they charge for these options - pricing isn't published on their site - you have to request a quote.

Just as MS Word offers spell-check and grammar-check, perhaps it should offer plagiarism-check?!

But, joking apart, where is the line drawn, and how can it be recognized?

 

3 Comments on Plagiarism Conundrum

DEC
02
2006
120,880 Points 6 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Per the U.S. Copyright Office, a couple of the things that are not protected by copyright:

  • Ideas, procedures, methods, systems, processes, concepts, principles, discoveries, or devices, as distinguished from a description, explanation, or illustration

  • Works consisting entirely of information that is common property and containing no original authorship (for example: standard calendars, height and weight charts, tape measures and rulers, and lists or tables taken from public documents or other common sources)

 Thus, if you research and then come up with your own ideas based on that research and write this in your own words, it isn't copyrighted.  As for plagiarism, hmmm.  Gonna have to research that one and see how, if any, the legal definition varies.  It sounds from your quote like they're using the two terms interchangably for their purposes.  I'd guess that your quote, unless it's a substantial part of the work, and considering the use that you're putting it to, would fall under the "Fair Use" category, though that's a slim reed to lean on in a court of law - Fair Use is decided almost on a case by case basis because the definition is somewhat vague. 

Anyway:  U.S. Copyright Office plain text page on their website (though you can get to the statutes from there if you really want to - I haven't done so in a while).  The info here can be helpful in dealing with this conundrum, I've found in my other life as a volunteer editor.

 

7:01pm • #1
120,696 Points 7 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Well you bring up a good point.  Do you think people here are purposely trying to plagerize?  I know that I've seen a good article on this site that I would like to put on my website for potential customers to read.  I don't write word for word what the original blog wrote but I do stay on the same topic and try to present it in a similiar fashion.  So I guess I wonder what most consider as plagerism
10:02pm • #2
120,880 Points 6 Featured Posts Outside Blog

One of the things about copyright law is that you can always ask the permission of the copyright holder for a one-time publishing of their piece.  Copyright infringement is when you do not do that, and plagiarism, at least as I've always known it to be used, is when you do that AND pretend that you wrote the words themselves.  You can have copyright infringement without plagiarism, in other words (well, hmm, in the SAME words, I guess!). 

But the crux of the matter as far as copyright is concerned is permission. 

What's the worst they can do if you ask?  They could say no.  Not the end of the world.

10:08pm • #3

This blog does not allow anonymous comments

 
Rainmaker_large

Tony Marriott, Associate Broker, CRP, CLHMS, CRB, CRS ~~ Phoenix Arizona

Phoenix, AZ

More about me…

Keller Williams Realty Professional Partners

Address: 7025 W Bell Rd, Suite 10, Glendale, AZ, 85308

Office Phone: (623) 910-8988

Cell Phone: (623) 910-8988

Email Me

Phoenix Arizona Real Estate Blog, presented by Tony Marriott of FREE Listings Search!!


Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find AZ real estate agents and Phoenix real estate on ActiveRain.