Special offer

The One Thing a Buyer's Agent Should Do BEFORE Showing a Northern Virginia Short Sale

By
Real Estate Agent with Long and Foster Real Estate VA License # 0225089470

The One Thing a Buyer's Agent Should Do BEFORE Showing a Northern Virginia Short Sale

My phone rings with Short Sale questions all day long.  That's because I've established myself as a successful Northern Virginia Short Sale Agent.  Yet, not all of the calls I receive are from potential Buyers ans Sellers.  I'd say at least one third of the calls I receive with Short Sale questions come from my fellow Realtors®.  One such call came yesterday from a very respected colleague.  We'll call her Jan.

Jan had just gotten her Buyers under contract with a Northern Virginia Short Sale.  And as requested by the Sellers in a counter offer, the Buyers had done the home inspection shortly after contract ratification.  The Listing Agent was now requesting a copy of the home inspection and Jan thought  was odd, especially since her Buyers had sent notice removing the home inspection contingency.

My first question in situations like this is, "Who is the Listing Agent?"  Why?  Just as some agents have established themselves as successful Northern Virginia Short Sale Agents, others have established reputations in this field on the far end of the spectrum.  Jan told me his name.  We'll call him Carl.  Jan continued as my brain thrashed on why Carl's name was familiar to me.  Then Jan said something about Carl needing the home inspection to justify the contract price to the bank.  Suddenly, I knew where I had encountered Carl.  I asked Jan for the property address.  When she gave it to me, I recited what had stuck out to me in Carl's agent remarks.  "Bank approved at $300,000, but will present reasonable offer."   That was odd to me because Carl had the property priced at $260,000. 

I had Buyers who had been interested in this particular listing and when I called Carl I asked how he got the bank approved price.  Had he lost a prior contract shortly before the approval letter came through?  No.  Carl had a HAFA Approved Short Sale.  This means the bank sets the minimum price they will accept after an appraisal, not a BPO.  After hearing that, I knew it wasn't worth my Buyers' time.  Not only have I been in situations where I had a HAFA Approved Short Sale that was beyond what a buyer would pay, it was impossible to prove that to the bank.  The Sellers would have to agree to a traditional Short Sale.  Problem with that is that the Sellers have already seen that HAFA Approval Letter which likely offers them $3,000 in relocation assistance.  Try convincing a Seller to give that up prior to the end of the 120 HAFA marketing period.

I explained all of this to Jan, and told her that was the very reason I did not take my Buyers through this listing.  It was not likely to be approved.  Well, it was already approved, but beyond my Buyers' qualification and beyond what Buyers' seeing it online thought it was worth.  And I found that out by asking Carl where he came up with that price.  Problem here was Jan didn't.  And now her Buyers were stuck on a property they were likely never going to get.

Buyer's Agents should ALWAYS probe for as much information as possible on a Northern Virginia Short Sale BEFORE showing it....especially if the Listing Agent claims to have an approved price.  You want to know where that came from.  And if the approved price is less than the list price on a HAFA Short Sale...well...wad up that listing and throw it in the trash.  The Listing Agent has no clue how the HAFA program works.  It's HAFA's price or foreclosure.

Comments(5)

Jen Giraud
American Home Shield - Dallas, TX

Great information, thanks for sharing! I think this goes for agents in any state!

Jul 28, 2011 06:07 AM
Ellie McIntire
Ellicott City Clarksville Howard County Maryland Real Estate - Ellicott City, MD
Luxury service in Central Maryland

Questions, questions and more questions to a SS listing agent.

My buyers do NOT do any inspections on a short sale until the bank has approved the sale. I have had listing agents push for it, but there is no way my buyers will invest a dime when it could all fall apart. We have specific addendums that cover that.

Jul 28, 2011 06:39 AM
Chris Ann Cleland
Long and Foster Real Estate - Gainesville, VA
Associate Broker, Bristow, VA

Jen:  It certainly should go for every market.  I tend to address the Northern Virginia Short Sale market in my posts since that is where I work.

Ellie:  I have Buyers that will do it, but it's a gamble.  Some bets are better than others.  That's part of how we advise them.  If I know I'm working with a Listing Agent that doesn't take any old Short Sale listing and knows what they are doing, I can see advising this up front to make the offer stronger.  And ALWAYS putting the Earnest Money up at ratification.  Otherwise, you are telling the Sellers that you are still shopping around and not a serious Buyer.

Jul 28, 2011 06:45 AM
Michelle Gibson
Hansen Real Estate Group Inc. - Wellington, FL
REALTOR

Chris Ann - I can't imagine how much of my time and my clients time I would waste if I didn't contact every single Wellington short sale listing agent prior to showing.  A percentage of them are already under contract, but accepting back up offers although there is zero mention of that in the MLS.  A few months ago one agent didn't even know if the seller still owned the home let alone who the lienholders were.....the list goes on and on.

Jul 28, 2011 01:37 PM
Chris Ann Cleland
Long and Foster Real Estate - Gainesville, VA
Associate Broker, Bristow, VA

Michelle: Things that bad Short Sale Listing Agents don't know is astounding.

Jul 28, 2011 03:04 PM