Special offer

Myth: Buying a foreclosure is always the best deal.

By
Real Estate Broker/Owner with Southern Living Realty Partners TN Lic# 266926
Buying a foreclosure is NOT always a good deal. With so many foreclosures and distressed properties on the market right now, one could easily assume that a foreclosure is the way to go. After all, it was a nice house at one time. The lenders have lost so much money lately that foreclosures are being sold for pennies on the dollar, right??? Wrong! While no lender wants to foreclosure on any homeowner, it does happen. We are all told at the closing table "If you don't pay, you don't stay." The main reason why so many people lose their homes is because of illness and being unable to work due to the illness. Even though these days more and more foreclosures are being attributed to the adjustable rate mortgages, illness is still the #1 cause. And usually what happens during this time of illness is that the house as well as the mortgage is neglected. No maintenance, no pest control, no lawn care, no painting, no cleaning, etc. These houses become a shell of their former selves. Normally by the time the bank has taken it back, this once prized asset has deteriorated in condition and value.

Lenders never want to own real estate. Banks/lenders are in the business of loaning money, not buying or selling real estate. Lenders make even worse property managers so they had that over to Realtors to do. The marketing job comes back to the Realtor to market that property and get it sold FOR AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE and as quickly as possible. The lenders want to stop the bleeding too. While in some parts of the country that have been hit especially hard by foreclosures, the vast majority are not selling these properties for pennies on the dollar. Many of the banks have gotten into the home improvement business by rehabbing many of these properties before they place them on the market. Let me say it again, the banks want them sold FOR AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE. Simply do the math: If a lender has invested thousands of dollars in rehabbing a property, do you think they are looking for 50 cents on the dollar when it sells?

We get calls from buyers who only want to see foreclosure listings. There are certainly still some bargains to be had in the foreclosure market but buyers need not overlook the other existing homes on the market. If you find a great home that has been loving cared for by their present owner who continues to do the grass cutting, maintenance, etc., at a below market price next door to a foreclosure that needs work for the same price, which one do you choose? With the sheer number of well-maintained, aggressively-priced existing homes with motivated sellers, buyers need to consider all of the properties on the market and not just focus on the foreclosures. Foreclosures sure do sound good on paper or in the media, but foreclosures are not always the best deal.
Posted by

Southern Living Realty Partners Logo

Rhonda Burgess, Broker

615.554.0832

 

Vickie Arcuri
Coldwell Banker Realty - Fort Lauderdale, FL
South Florida Luxury Real Estate
Hi Rhonda, what a timely post and you're absolutely correct!  If only we could get more Buyers to understand this (and then, when you're showing them the absence of "dirt cheap" Foreclosures in great condition, some of them appear suspicious that certainly we must be hiding the good deals from them).  They have too many sources advising them that Foreclosures are always a great deal and that they're always the way too go :(
Oct 30, 2007 03:24 PM
Vicky Poe
Good Ole Rocky Top - Crossville, TN
Realtor/ Auctioneer
Working foreclosure is difficult.  When making offers to banks is not like dealing with normal people.  You can make a good offer but if it does not fit in their time frame they will not take it.  I am dealing with one right now and I hate it. 
Oct 30, 2007 03:26 PM
Richard Perkins
R PERKINS REALTY - Stockton, CA
I agree, there are a lot of good buys out there and they are not all foreclosures. I say if it is a foreclosure do your research before jumping in. Thanks for the post
Oct 30, 2007 03:30 PM
Rhonda Burgess
Southern Living Realty Partners - Smyrna, TN
Moving to Nashville TN Real Estate Specialist
Vickie - I realize that I wrote this towards buyers but it is really meant to help our sellers who have nice homes, priced right, move-in ready who have to compete against a foreclosure next door or on the same block that is not truly "competition" but because the media hypes up foreclosures, the foreclosure becomes the "best deal".  And you're exactly right - the buyers think we're withholding the best repos when these houses cannot be bought for 50 cents on the dollar.  I have to education somebody every week that we (Realtors) do not set the price - the bank does.
Oct 30, 2007 03:33 PM
Forrest Barbee
BHHS Nevada Properties - Las Vegas, NV
You are right on target with this post.  Let's also remember that at the point the bank owns the property and it has be listed in the local MLS with an REO agent that it is no longer a foreclosure.  That means that the opportunity to buy a foreclosure property per se is past.  That may seem like an insignificant technicality, but once in the hands of the bank . . . the game changes.  Banks are relunctant to aggressively price the property when it is a new REO listing these days.  So as you stated, they may not be bargains for weeks or months after they come on the market; worse yet, there may not be much room to negotiate on price early on.  However, there are probably a large number of resale sellers with more motivation and in a better position to negotiate a bargain for today's buyer.
Oct 30, 2007 03:37 PM
Joan Whitebook
BHG The Masiello Group - Nashua, NH
Consumer Focused Real Estate Services
You are absolutely correct.  I have seen some foreclosures that look like they are ready to be condemned.  I am horrified to see how these homes can deteriorate so quickly.  One needs to know what they are doing when they buy a foreclosed property.
Oct 30, 2007 03:39 PM
Rhonda Burgess
Southern Living Realty Partners - Smyrna, TN
Moving to Nashville TN Real Estate Specialist
Vicky - I deal with a bunch of foreclosures.  Every lender/REO company has their rules and guidelines.  If you don't dot the "I"s and cross the "T"s just the right way, they won't cooperate with you.  Hang in there.
Oct 30, 2007 03:40 PM
Rhonda Burgess
Southern Living Realty Partners - Smyrna, TN
Moving to Nashville TN Real Estate Specialist
Richard - One thing that a lot of people do not realize is that when the foreclosure is sold as-is, it really truly is sold as-is.  Buyers definitely need to their due diligence on foreclosures.  There may be a huge can of worms in that "great deal".
Oct 30, 2007 03:45 PM
Rhonda Burgess
Southern Living Realty Partners - Smyrna, TN
Moving to Nashville TN Real Estate Specialist
Forrest - You're right - Once the bank has bought it back, it's a whole different deal.  It's not a bargain anymore.  It's like any other listing on the market. 
Oct 30, 2007 03:47 PM
Rhonda Burgess
Southern Living Realty Partners - Smyrna, TN
Moving to Nashville TN Real Estate Specialist
Joan - Some of these properties are so bad, I won't go inside.  If you have to practically rebuild it, I just don't see the value in the deal.
Oct 30, 2007 03:50 PM
Chris Savoia
1-800-GOT-JUNK? - Chula Vista, CA
(1-800-GOT-JUNK?-SD South Bay)
Excellent info in the article and the comments. I agree with what you wrote back to Joan. We see some homes in really bad shape. The kind where you walk out of the house and you have fleas all up and down your clothes. We see it all. But that's what we do. We feel really bad when people have lost their homes, but aside from foreclosures, most of the time removing junk is really fun. Thanks for the info. Trying to learn as much as possible.
Dec 15, 2007 01:11 PM
Rhonda Burgess
Southern Living Realty Partners - Smyrna, TN
Moving to Nashville TN Real Estate Specialist
Chris - Thanks for stopping by.  I have a love/hate relationship on the trashouts.  I dread some of the really bad ones but we almost always find something of value.  One foreclosure I was assigned had a brand new washer & dryer sitting in the basement.  The neighbors said they could not fit it on the truck so they just left it.  You just never know what you will find.
Dec 15, 2007 04:58 PM