Special offer

Living Expenses, Rent v. Buy

By
Mortgage and Lending with Guaranteed Rate NMLS# 2611 173124

It’s no secret that the real estate market is rapid changing and adapting to our new economic state, however I recently found an article that I found interesting about home occupancy, more specifically the divide between renters and owners. Renters now spend five percent more of their household budgets on housing costs than do homeowners. This difference is growing due to the rise in prices of rentals.

Since 2005, homeowners’ expenditures for housing approximately rose from 31.9 percent of their household budget to 33.2 percent, but renters’ costs have risen even more, from 35.6 percent to 38.4 percent, according to the October CoreLogic U.S. Housing and Mortgage Trends.

Homeowners have increased their housing expenditure allocation by 12 percent since 1985, while renters increased by 22 percent.

As consumers begin distributing more and more of their expenditures toward housing, they have less money to spend on non-housing consumption. The major decline in a household’s budget occurred in transportation costs which fell by 17 percent and 22 percent since 1985 for homeowners and renters, respectively.

The increased spending allocation for housing, which is largely due to the stagnation of incomes among Americans of home buying age beginning in the 1990s, has actually contributed to the decrease in homeownership by making buying a home more difficult.

Demographics have also contributed to the decline in homeownership. For the 25 to 34 age group, the homeownership rate fell from 51.6 percent in 1980 to 42.0 percent in 2010. For 35 to 44 year olds, homeownership rates fell from 71.2 percent to 62.3 percent over the same time period.

Also noteworthy numbers of foreclosures are remaining on the market for as long as four years or more. One out of five foreclosures (21 percent) is taking more than a year to sell. Nearly 10 percent, or 23,200 properties that were auctioned in 2006, remained in REO as of Q2 2010. In other words, these properties have been in REO constantly since 2006.

I found these statistics to be very interesting, considering other trends that have recently taken place in the market. What’s your opinion about the ratios around renters vs. owners?

Comments (27)

Sharon Alters
Coldwell Banker Vanguard Realty - 904-673-2308 - Fleming Island, FL
Realtor - Homes for Sale Fleming Island FL

I would love to see links to verify your stats, Eric. I think 25-34 year olds are timid about buying having watched the housing debacle, and 35-44 year olds are the ones who have lost their houses and have to rent. It's not rocket science, but in the end I believe people will always prefer to own their own home if and when the time is right.

Sharon

Oct 26, 2011 04:32 PM
Jackie Connelly-Fornuff
Douglas Elliman Real Estate in Babylon NY - Babylon, NY
"Moving at The Speed of YOU!"

Read the exact same article from Realtor.com that came in my email today.

Oct 26, 2011 05:31 PM
Pamela Seley
West Coast Realty Division - Murrieta, CA
Residential Real Estate Agent serving SW RivCo CA

Have to keep in mind that real estate continues to be local. In my county, one of the worst in unemployment rates and housing price drops in the state, we've a ways to go before hitting bottom. Ironically, when housing prices go down, so do rents. It's only a good time to buy when it fits the individual/family's needs. 

Oct 26, 2011 05:59 PM
Leslie Ebersole
Swanepoel T3 Group - Saint Charles, IL
I help brokers build businesses they love.

Realtor.com sort of said something similar. 

No, it was exactly the same thing. 

Has anyone explained what "Attribution" means?

 

Oct 26, 2011 06:20 PM
Rosalie Evans
Meritus Group Real Estate - Sioux Falls, SD
The Evans Group, Sioux Falls, SD Homes For Sale

Wow these are interesting and depressing statistics! It is definately the time to buy if you have the ability to buy clearly! 

Oct 26, 2011 07:27 PM
Tina Gleisner
Home Tips for Women - Portsmouth, NH
Home Tips for Women

Your message is key here, that for those who can buy a house, they will spend less of their income on housing costs than the average renter. I too want to review more of the data before sharing a similar message with my readers.

PS I did find supporting materials,

  • http://www.corelogic.com/about-us/news/media-advisory-corelogic-releases-u.s.-housing-and-mortgage-trends-report.aspx
  • http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/corelogic-releases-us-housing-and-mortgage-trends-report-132132518.html
  • http://realtormag.realtor.org/news-and-commentary/daily-news ... first article, http://realtormag.realtor.org/daily-news/2011/10/26/renters-spending-5-more-home-owners

... but everyone seems to be repeating the same, limited info as you have to buy the full report.

 

Oct 27, 2011 03:24 AM
Brad Baylor
ERA Coup Agency - Milton, PA

I recently sold my home and am now renting.  I'm kind of back to where I used to be, as far as my attitude is concerned toward homeownership.  I believe it's great for most, but not for everyone.  What I like about renting is I have no worries about furnace or water-heater failures, appliances, landscaping, etc.  Furnace isn't working?  Call the landlord.  No hot water?  Call the landlord.  Roof leaks?  Call the landlord.  You get the picture...

Oct 27, 2011 03:46 AM
Robby Leviton
Metro Real Estate LLC - Kirkland, WA
Knowles Team

This only talks numbers, when you start looking at quality of life, kids doing better in school, family stability, it still all supports the reasons behind owning your own home vs renting

Oct 27, 2011 03:52 AM
Jim Jones
Century 21 Advantage - Columbia, MO

OK, so the cost of renting is going up, and if your part of the country is anything like Columbia MO, it is getting harder and harder to find a decent place to rent.  To me that means that the rents are going to get even higher!

 

That report by Core Logic made for some rather unsettling reading, but I think it is something we should all keep in mind.  IF you want to read the whole thing, go to:  http://www.corelogic.com/about-us/researchtrends/asset_upload_file780_12750.pdf.

 

THis was a great post Erica.  Thanks for making me think and giving me another marketing tool.

Oct 27, 2011 04:22 AM
Roger Newton
Roger Newton Real Estate - North Plains, OR

The average person spends what they have.

I would guess that it does cost more to buy a home now and pay for it than it does to rent.  In the long-term, owners should be able to pay off their home if they pay mortgage, and have something that they own!

 

Oct 27, 2011 04:57 AM
Gene Riemenschneider
Home Point Real Estate - Brentwood, CA
Turning Houses into Homes

Around here it makes a lot more sense to buy.  The difference is a lot bigger than 5%, but credit scores and loan issues are killing people.

Oct 27, 2011 05:00 AM
Ken Anderson
Apex Results Realty Inc., Brokerage - Burlington, ON
Broker in Burlington, Ontario

Buying vs Renting.  An on-going debate that has proponents on both sides when it comes to financing.  I can easily make (and have made) believable arguments on either side.  I'll often get a kick out of taking and defending a minority position in a debate just for fun. 

However, what often gets lost in all this are the 'old-fashioned' benefits of home-ownership.  Things like pride of ownership, roots, neighbours that you actually talk to, pride of fixing up and decorating your own place, belonging to a community and so on.  These do not have a dollar value, they are priceless.  The argument shouldn't be just about costs alone, it should be about family, lifestyle, ownership, community, belonging, and counting for something.  Just sayin'.

Oct 27, 2011 05:32 AM
Elizabeth Dingler
Independent Appraiser - Seattle, WA

The fact that renters spend a larger percentage of their income on housing than homeowners would be pretty easily explained by the fact that renters as a whole have lower household incomes than homeowners. I would rather read statistics that compare apples to apples, that is "House A would have mortgage payments of X if you bought it today, and the same house would cost X to rent if you moved in today". I think in most cases the rent would be much lower.

For instance, I currently rent a 2,000sf house on 4.5 acres for $1250 a month plus utilities. If I wanted to buy the place it would cost around $350k, so the mortgage would be significantly higher. I could go out and buy one of the many <$50k REO condos that are sitting on the market, but it would be a 550sf, 1 bedroom condo in a sketchy neighborhood. So I would be paying less for housing, but it's certainly not comparable housing. Yet I would be supporting the hypothesis that it costs less to own than rent if one considers all types of housing to be equal.

Oct 27, 2011 05:52 AM
Denise Watkins
Samson Properties - Upper Marlboro, MD
Realtor Serving DC and MD

I'm acquiring a lot of renter leads and when I asked, why rent when you can own, most inform me that they are just leaving a bad situation - bankruptcy, foreclosure, or short sale.  In my search for housing, I'm finding that the rent the landlords are asking for is more than what the tenant could be paying in mortgage.

Oct 27, 2011 06:56 AM
Kate Akerly
Kaminsky Group - Manhattan Beach, CA
Manhattan Beach Residential Sales

It totally depends on the market.  There are areas of NYC where comparing rent to own costs will result in an obvious value in renting.  In other areas, ownership will win out.  That microcosm is repeated across the country.

Oct 27, 2011 10:12 AM
Bob Miller
Keller Williams Cornerstone Realty - Ocala, FL
The Ocala Dream Team

Hi Eric,  Great post.  I always appreciate the date and facts to know where the market is going.

Oct 27, 2011 11:10 PM
S W
Centerville, KS

Great stats, thanks! Knowledge is power!

Oct 28, 2011 06:25 AM
Dale Taylor
Re/Max 10 New Lenox Illinois http://dtaylor.remax.com - Frankfort, IL
Realtor = Chicago Illinois Homes Townhomes Condos

thanks for sharing

Oct 28, 2011 12:30 PM
Jayson Holland
Listings.com - Denver, CO
Jay Holland

Rents have been increasing in Denver about 10% per year for the past 2 years, as mortgage rates have dropped to the lowest levels EVER (4.1% for 30year conv + 3.3% for 15 year conv as I write this)

Housing prices from 2009-2010 and 2010-2011 have stayed about the same in Denver less than 2% change either way.

That equates to owning being MUCH cheaper than renting from a monthly payment standpoint.

Even if you factor in the maintenance costs, owning is still a better deal here, IF you can get the financing. And that is the big IF.

..

Oct 28, 2011 01:34 PM
Sylvie Stuart
Realty One Group Mountain Desert 928-600-2765 - Flagstaff, AZ
Home Buying, Home Selling and Investment - Flagsta

These are really great statistics and speak volumes. I think it's always more beneficial to own than rent. Your net worth is higher too, when you own compared to the average renter.

Feb 19, 2012 09:41 PM