Special offer

California HOAs Can No Longer Restrict Rentals

By
Services for Real Estate Pros with Rentec Direct Property Management Software

California has passed a bill (SB 150) now disallows HOA's from changing the rules mid-game on a landlord by restricting rentals within the HOA.  This bill took effect January 1st.

An association which previously has no restrictions on rentals, that attempts to amend the HOA to then restrict the amount or percentage of rentals is now prohibited from doing so.  Such a change in bylaws will have no impact on existing owners unless the existing owners specifically provide their authorization.  The existing owner by default will get grandfathered into the pre-restriction rules.

It however does not protect the next owner of a home in the same association.  If a home is sold, the new HOA rules related to rentals will apply to the new owner and the previous owner must disclose the fact of the restrictions.

I have mixed feeling about this.  My first impression (as a Landlord) makes me think this is great!  If I bought a property in an association as an investment property, and later the association changed the rules which prevented me from renting my investment property that could be catestrophic to my cash flow.  On the other hand, I prefer smaller government and less government interference in my affairs.  An association is a mini-government in itself, and I generally trend towards wanting decisions to be at the smallest and most local form of government possible.  In this particular topic, I think property rights might trump my preference for local government though.

Thoughts?

 ---

Nathan is a member of Rentec Direct who provides property management software, tenant ach payment processing, and tenant credit and criminal reports for property managers and landlords.

Comments (5)

Wallace S. Gibson, CPM
Gibson Management Group, Ltd. - Charlottesville, VA
LandlordWhisperer

This is an abridgement of PRIVATE PROPERTY rights and will deal a blow to HOA REsales if not disclosed and EXPLAINED properly.

Jan 21, 2012 10:33 PM
Mark Delgado
houses for rent, Solano County & Glen Cove - Benicia, CA
Benicia and Vallejo, Property Management, rental h

My thoughts are in line with Wallace. While the new law may be an improvement, it is still an unacceptable situation that creates hardships on people by impeding their rights. 

Jan 22, 2012 04:47 AM
Michelle Francis
Tim Francis Realty LLC - Atlanta, GA
Realtor, Buckhead Atlanta Homes for Sale & Lease

Nathan, 

We had an owner in our HOA that tried to change our rules four years ago.  I literally talked to 75% of the neighbors about this.  The good news is it got no support and certainly not the 67% they would have needed to pass it. 

HOWEVER, key thing is I know rentals and was paying attention.  Also, we've had executive rentals in our neighborhood for 10+ years with fabulous tenants - so the neighbors knew it was NOT an issue. 

Had a number of buyers last year who were buying personally last year who DID NOT offer for homes if the HOA had this provision.  Why you want to sign away your options is insane in this market! 

All the best, Michelle

Jan 22, 2012 05:15 AM
Anonymous
Sheree Cox

Do you know if there are any proposed billls to do away with the old rental restrictions??? I was just notified by my HOA that my tenant needs to vacate within 15 days because we were an owner occupied unit in June of 2010 when they passed the new rental restriction. I have never lived at that unit and never will My son was renting it and they consider that owner occupied and I can never rent it out??? We bought it as an investment and now in order to sell it,we would have to sell for 1/2 of what we paid.

 

I am hoping someone will outlaw ALL rental restrictions. As a Real Estate Broker,I have seen a HUGE decline in value with HOAs that have these restrictions. Unfortunately the owners that live in these unit are poverty level and have an agenda and no jobs or life. Very Sad!!!

Jan 22, 2012 05:38 AM
#4
Nathan M
Rentec Direct Property Management Software - Grants Pass, OR
President (Rentec Direct)

@Sheree,

 

If you had a lease agreement with your son and he was paying rent, you might have some legal authority to fight back with the HOA on that issue.  If not, and as being a member of numerous HOAs myself, I would probably agree with their assessment that it was owner occupied.

I have not heard of any bills proposed which would override these restrictions in the past, only ones imposed in the future.  You could gather up support among other owners and work on an amendment to the bylaws to allow rentals or ease up on the restriction at least.  Usually bylaw amendments require a large percentage of owners in agreement.  Most Oregon HOAs require 75% from what I've seen.

Jan 24, 2012 07:23 AM