There was a great post from a Realtor named Shari George that prompted me to write this blog entry.

Factory Built Housing from a popular manufacturer

Funny, it doesn't look like a trailer!

According to Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, the two largest investors in conventional mortgage notes, the guidelines (and every major lender uses these guidelines, although they may be more restrictive if they don't feel up to underwriting these properly) for manufactured homes are as follows:

  • Built on or after June 15th, 1976
  • On it's own land
  • Have access to roads, utilities
  • Be taxed as Real Estate
  • Be on a permanent foundation
  • The axle has been removed
  • Be at least a double wide...unless it's in a PUD

Manufactured Financing: with a conventional loan (meets the guidelines) the loan would have the exact same interest rate as a stick built-home, with an additional expense of .75 discount points.  In other words, if you qualify for a 6% interest rate (about where it's at today) for a $200,000 home, then there's going to be an additional expense of $1500.  That's it!  Only if you or the property doesn't qualify for a conventional loan would you have to pay exorbitant interest for a manufactured home.

What is the difference between a manufactured home, a mobile home and a modular home?

The mobile is built before june 15, 1976.  It's that simple.  HUD determines it, and every Manufacture Home has a HUD tag (DON'T REMOVE IT EVER!)

FHA is a bit more restrictive...it has to not only have a permanent foundation but also have it recorded (a 433a) and it can NOT be moved after it is place on the land.

The main distinction between modular and manufactured is simply the codes they are built to.  A common distinction is the type of chassis it is built on and delivered with.  Even though there is very little difference between a modular home and a manufactured home...conventional guidelines treat a modular home EXACTLY THE SAME AS A STICK BUILT.  For that reason, a modular is going to be

Don't believe the hype.  A well-built manufactured home is sometimes constructed better than a stick-built home, plus it's cheaper.  When you build in a factory, there are less injuries, delays because of weather, and cheaper worker's compensation insurance than building on site.

I HIGHLY recommend that you Google Richard Heyn, SRA.  He's a sought after expert by the NAR and, for a fee, your Association of Realtors can have him come teach an excellent classz for Realtors.

Regarding appreciation: In my community, it would have been difficuly to find an average manufactured home on a half-acre over $100k six years ago.  Now it would be diffictult to find one under 259k.  Perception obviously affects price, and manufactured homes have not appreciated as much (in dollars), but at nearly the same rate as stick-built homes.

I only do residential mortgages in California, but anybody that has questions is welcome to use me as a resource.  Take care!

 
This post has been included in California Information

5 Comments on Manufactured Homes, Mobile Homes, Modular Homes...what's the deal?

DEC
17
2006
244,607 Points 5 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
Thanks for the information. I know the difference, but never knew about the dates.
4:22pm • #1
DEC
18
2006
143,475 Points 7 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Joey,

 Thanks for the post and adding clarity to the discussion!

8:05pm • #2
MAR
17
2007

Who are you trying to kid?  I've worked in a manufactured housing plant for 5 years now. I have been in all phases of the construction of these houses.  Although the concept of building them is good, they are junk.  The whole concept is quality before numbers.  BULL !!!   Anybody who believes in that crap is in really bad need of a house right now.  They are beautiful on the outside, but underneath....I Really Wish That I Buyer Could See All Of That.  I Think that all of them should have a clear belly board so that customers can get a real look at the picture.  Of course as soon as the company gets notification that a Federal Inspector is on the way, the whole plant slows down.  If you are reading this and plan on buying a manufactured home, try to get your house built on the day that the federal inspectors are in the plant and not on the other 362 days.   I will be starting my own blog on this subject.  It will include daily comments of the production process, materials that are used, pictures showing the outer 3/8 foamboard walls, wood that looks like it came from the reject bin, staples and glue that help hold it all together, cheap plastic fittings and all the shabby construction that goos along with it.  BUILT TO LAST AT LEAST FIVE YEARS.  Buy the way,  Get a razor knife if you get locked out of the house, it will take you about 1 minute to cut yourself a new entry through the walls.

Jim
9:17am • #3
MAR
18
2007
114,512 Points 9 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Wow Jim...Thanks for your comment.

As far as trying to kid anyone, my post is mostlyabout what the loan guidelines are.  In other words, how the FHA and conventional loan guidelines treat a manufactured home in comparison to a stick-built home.

And when I say that a manufactured home is sometimes built better than a stick home, that's obviously about a well-built manufactured home...not just some cardboard trailer like you seem to be describing.

I'm no expert on the differences in construction materials, workmanship, etc.

Are the comments you make true across the board?  Where are you from?

If you really want to make a difference with your information, my recommendation is that you follow through on your blog idea and that you don't post anonymously.  That way people can dialogue with you and keep the conversation going.

Thanks again...and keep posting.

9:25am • #4
JUN
16
2007

Nice post Joey! Jim seems a little pissed off at his ex-employer.

There are reputable manufactured home builders and there are shody ones. Just as there is with single family construction homes being sold these days. Seems like he was working for an unethical builder and employer.

I've been seeing your posts show up in Google and it's how I found out about Active Rains, so thanks.

Best Regards,

Maurice

3:18pm • #5

Leave a response…



(optional)
What does the graphic say?
 
Rainmaker_large

Hemet Home Loan Guy, Joey Aszterbaum

Hemet, CA

More about me…

Jolynne Photography

Address: Hemet, CA, 92544

Cell Phone: (951) 285-1012

Email Me

Hemet Mortgage and Real Estate Blog: buy or refinance, credit, things to do in Hemet, Realtor sales training and misc stuff from the Hemet Home Loan Guy a member of the Active Rain social network since 11/06.

BEWARE OF BLOG: Joey Aszterbaum disclaims liability for any damages or losses, direct or indirect that may result from use of or reliance on, information contained in the blog or for accuracy of comments or opinions of visitors to my blogs. Warm wash with like colors. Do not iron. If rash occurs, discontinue use.



Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find CA real estate agents and Hemet real estate on ActiveRain.