Special offer

My World: What the robosigning settlement might mean to the market.

By
Real Estate Agent with RE/MAX Properties SW, Inc.

The recent settlement of the robosigning case brought against a number of major U.S. banks by attorneys general of the states will most likely result in increased levels of foreclosure seizures. The involved banks have greatly slowed their foreclosure process during the negotiations, allowing some homeowners in default to remain in their properties without paying for months or even years. Now that the case has been settled with what amounts to a slap on the wrist for the banks for engaging in practices which resulted in allegations of fraudulent paperwork, the banks are likely to move quickly to help their bottom lines.

The $25 billion settlement will be parceled out in chunks. About $17 billion will go to help about a million owners who are facing foreclosure. The settlement includes $5 billion to pay for foreclosure prevention programs and $3 billion to lower homeowners' interest rates with a small residual of $1.5 billion left over to compensate homeowners who suffered from poorly handled foreclosures.

It seems that about 750,000 people are supposed to receive direct payments of around $2,000 to partially compensate them for servicing errors. Regardless of how the money will be handed out, it must filter it's way through the existing or new bureaucratic structures to actually reach the homeowners' hands. This has proved to be a slow and not too effective process in the past with other government assistance programs. It remains to be seen how quickly it will happen and how much this settlement will actually help.

The end effect, however, will most likely be an increase in the rates of home seizures and an increase in the REO inventory levels. If this is not dealt with carefully by the banks, it will result in a further decline of the market as these properties are placed for sale and increase inventory levels.

A reasonable speculation is that investors are likely to purchase many of the REO properties and convert them to rentals. The central Florida market has seen quite a large amount of this sort of sales action in the past few months. As a result, our inventory levels here are lower than they have been for some time and there has been enough competition to actually bring prices up a few percentage points during the past year. This situation may very well change as a result of the settlement and resultant actions by the banks.

There is an old Chinese curse which goes something like, "May you live in interesting times." The real estate market is poised to get a lot more interesting shortly if the above speculations are correct.

Namaste!

Ron Marshall
Marshall Enterprises - Saint Michael, MN
Birdhouse Builder Extraordinaire

Well, if the investors buy the properties and make them available to renters, Mitt Romney was right.  All the foreclosures should just drift into the market and let people find the rentals they can afford.  I guess that is the new American dream....renting. 

Feb 09, 2012 02:31 PM
Margo Currie
Exit 1 Stop Realty - Saint Augustine Beach, FL

I'm not sure if we can survive "more interesting times." ... and I agree it will get more interesting!

Feb 09, 2012 02:31 PM
Karen Hurst
RICOASTALLIVING.COM - Warwick, RI
Rhode Island Waterfront!

Hi Eric,

I am curious as to why you feel this way  

"The end effect, however, will most likely be an increase in the rates of home seizures and an increase in the REO inventory levels. If this is not dealt with carefully by the banks, it will result in a further decline of the market as these properties are placed for sale and increase inventory levels"

Why wouldn't it decrease the rate of REO inventory levels?

Feb 09, 2012 02:32 PM
Eric Martell
RE/MAX Properties SW, Inc. - Orlando, FL
Ph.D.

Ron - thanks for the comment - welcome to the new normal!

Margo - I've had about enough "interesting" to last me for awhile.

Karen - My speculation is that an increase in foreclosure rates will place a large number of additional properties in the bank's REO departments and my fear is that they will release them in a large bunch and flood the market.  Hopefully they won't.  Eventually, as the properties sold, you would be correct, the REO levels would drop.  The only issue is how fast the additional properties come on the market and how the additional inventory will impact prices.

Feb 09, 2012 02:37 PM