**I am putting my disclaimer upfront:  The story I am writing is not about any one particular
family, it is merely anHead in hand observation from a real estate agent in Metro Detroit who has watched
the downturn in our real estate market unfold. It is also a story that I've heard more times than I've wished by families who work hard, have purchased their piece of the American dream and have faced financial stress that they didn't realize was coming. 

Lola Audu wrote an excellent article yesterday entitled "When the pant legs are two different sizes".  Lola is a real estate broker in Grand Rapids and owner of Audu Real Estate.  If you have a few minutes I highly suggest you read her article.

As I was reading her article I saw the faces of the families that I have met and watched struggle through these hard economic times in Metro Detroit.   To say that Lola hit the nail on the head with her article is an understatement.  The foreclosure crisis in our state is a local crisis.  It cannot be compared to what is happening in Florida, or Nevada or California.  It was a monster in the making that took years of economic downturn to fully rear it's head.

For Mr. and Mrs. Jones and their 2 children it has been a financial nightmare.  Mr. Jones worked for a plastics plant that supplied parts for one of the Big Three automakers. He enjoyed job security, health benefits and most of the year worked 50-60 hours a week.    

When Mr. and Mrs. Jones children were no longer toddlers and were getting ready to begin school they decided to sell their small starter home and purchase a larger home in the school district of their choice.  On his steady income of $70,000 a year they purchased a $180,000 home in Metro Detroit and happily settled in.  They went about their daily lives contributing to their community and the economy.  They vacationed in Michigan and they shopped in Michigan.

3 years ago Mr. Jones couldn't have predicted the price of gas creeping up
and the effect it would have on truck and SUV sales.  He also didn't predict the foreign automakers leap to the head of the line with auto sales.   One day Mr. Jones went to work and was informed that the overtime that he had been steadily working for the past 7 years would be gone.  Mr. and Mrs. Jones adjust their budgets, learned to coupon shop, stopped taking vacations and life went on.

2 years ago Mr. Jones went into work only to be met with the gossip that his plastics plant would be closing.  Within weeks the gossip would become fact.  Mr. Jones did not have a job.  He was now going to receive an unemployment check along with job training offered by the state of Michigan.  His health insurance would be cut off, but could be replaced by a more expensive Cobra policy.   Mrs. Jones found a job to help supplement the income while Mr. Jones became "Mr. Dad" and looked for a new job in between school hours for their children.

The Jones sold everything that had any value to keep their heads above water.  The family camper, the boat, the snowmobiles.  Everything was sold at discounted prices to help them through one more month of mortgage, utility and insurance payments.

A year ago Mr. Jones heard about jobs in other states.  It was time to move on.  They would have to leave their family, friends and community to keep their heads above water and provide for their children.  They contacted their local real estate agent to put their home up for sale only to be told that their $180,000 home was now worth $150,000 because of the other Jones families in the area who also had their homes up for sale.  Supply and demand.  Mr. Jones was already familiar with it - remember, he lost his job because of it.

Mr. Jones heads off by himself and finds a job in another state, leaving his wife and children behind while he gets settled and they wait for their home to sell.   The home doesn't sell because they owe more on the mortgage than the home is worth in the current market.   The Jones cannot afford to live in 2 separate states any longer, and emotionally it is taking its toll on everyone being separated.  Mr. Jones makes the difficult decision to give his house back to the bank and have his family join him.  

Their American Dream has been shattered.  No longer will they feel secure in their jobs.  No longer will they feel secure in their community.   The emotional toll is too devastating to them.   They'll carry the pain of gain and loss with them forever.  The shame that a hard working man like Mr. Jones feels when he isn't able to feed his family or live up to his financial responsibility is sobering.  He will probably never be the same Mr. Jones again. 

In the Metro Detroit area the Jones family is a typical example of the foreclosure crisis.  Here, in one way or another, we are all connected to the auto industry.  When the auto industry is in a crisis there is more than a trickle down affect, it's a flood gate opening.  Restaurant workers, salon workers, travel agencies, insurance companies, plastic plants, paint companies - we all feel it.  

Do I have a cure for the ills the State of Michigan is going through?  No.  However I do vote.  I will scrutinize even more closely the candidates for office in our state.  Those that have not only a vision of how to turn around the economy in our state but the guts to do what it takes will receive my vote.    I want the Jones family to be able to come back to the Metro Detroit area.  I want them to be employed here, to shop here, to live here and raise their families here.  

© 2007 Kris Wales   Metro Detroit real estate  macombhomes.com





Contact Kris Wales
- A partner for your real estate needs in Macomb County MI


Search Macomb County MI homes for Sale  with MLS provided data updated daily.

Want to chat about local real estate?  Visit A Macomb County MI real estate blog

 
This post has been included in Michigan Information Macomb County, MI Information
Post is included in group: Michigan Real Estate

35 Comments on The typical Metro Detroit foreclosure family.

NOV
25
2007
42 Featured Posts

Kris

This post exemplifies the compassion needed to make it through the current crises.  It's got to be said, as adults and professionals we have a responsibility to assess matters honestly.   At the same time, we must acknowledge that foreclosures inflict human suffering that impact families (children) and communities for generations. 

I like your thoughts on choosing better political candidates in the future.  

5:32am • #1
165,064 Points 10 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
You tell it like it is!  This post deserves a feature...how bout it AR?
5:33am • #2
258,669 Points 44 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Ed:  Thank you so much for your kind comment.  Others see the investor-to-greedy stories.  Here in Metro Detroit we see the families suffering.  Good hard working families that have had their world turned upside down. I agree -we have to stand up and assess things honestly.  To do otherwise would mean adding more hardship upon people. 

Ruthmarie:   Thanks Ruth.  I simply wanted to point out the human side and the cost emotionally to those it is happening to. 
5:43am • #3
255,367 Points 2 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Great story.  I think there are at least some stories like this in every area. 

6:00am • #4
Hear, hear, bravo! I agree GREAT JOB on this post Kris. I agree this should be a feature post.
6:05am • #5
258,669 Points 44 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Penny:  Sadly, the whole Metro Detroit area is afflicted with too many of these "stories" and families.  Thanks for stopping in Penny.

Frank:  Thank you.  I do tend to ramble...one of the reasons that I still have a fear of posting my articles.  Reading Lolas article this morning struck such a chord with me.
6:13am • #6
1 Featured Post

Kris,

Great post. This one hits home for me as I was born and raised in Detroit.  2 generations of my family worked in the auto plants.  They did fine, but in today's climate in MI, dedicated hardworking people are losing their jobs.  And new jobs don't pay anywhere near the income they could make in the auto plants.  This whole "foreclosure debacle" is not always about the greedy consumer, uneducated speculative investor or the shady realtors or shady loan officers.

6:14am • #7
581,402 Points 95 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router
Great insight and so true, I got two lease agreements this weekend on my house in Westland, both of them bankruptcy due to layoffs and adjustable rates notes. So sad, I told my builder to expect less than perfect credit and that is what we got, but both good families you got caught in the mess. My builder will chose which on to go with.
6:14am • #8
258,669 Points 44 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Cheryl:   I've lived here all my life and up until the last 4-5 years you could always count on the Big Three for job security.  That's gone forever in my opinion. It is very sad what is going on here.  Yes there were greedy investors, and yes there were shady loan officers.  For the most part though the foreclosure crisis here is employment related.   I'm so glad you stopped in Cheryl.  Thanks for adding your personal family story to this. 
6:17am • #9
258,669 Points 44 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Missy:  Thank you SO much for advising your client that the likelihood of receiving 'credit challenged' applications would be high.  Thank your client also for his willingness to give a 2nd chance to a family that has been hit hard by the economy.   I'm seeing so much of the rental market here with notes "Must have good credit" that I just cringe.   The people and families that need this housing so desperately are the ones who lost their jobs and their homes and are now starting to pick up the pieces again. 
6:43am • #10
4 Featured Posts
Kris, great post. I haven't seen the magnitude of foreclosures in my market like you have. Thank you for personalizing what we hear on the news.
6:57am • #11
258,669 Points 44 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Craig:   Our local news does a superb job of personalizing many of their stories.  Kudos to them. Those of us in the trenches hear and see the families and their stories.  I'm glad I could personalize for you what we are experiencing here in Metro Detroit.  
7:09am • #12
279,678 Points 29 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
Kris, this is a great way to humanize the current market!
7:09am • #13
165,064 Points 10 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
Where is the feature...come one AR !!! You've featured quite a few supply-siders that think we should just let market forces "fix this" - how about some equal time so that they can see the consequences??????   I know, I sound like a cheerleader - but honestly, the person who wrote about doing nothing and had a picture of someone in a hammock made me want to throw up.  some people are far too casual about what is happening out there. 
7:16am • #14
258,669 Points 44 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Diane:  Thank you.  The media nationally forgets the human beings - thankfully our local media doesn't.

Ruthmarie:   You're a sweet cheerleader and I am grateful.  However if this local article reaches those who only see numbers that is gratifying in itself to me.  I missed the one with the hammock picture - it's probably good that I did. 
7:42am • #15
Vote. Vote. Vote.  As I often say in my posts, this down time is a time for us Realtors to educate ourselves.  And educating ourselves in government needs to be one of our top priorities. 
7:57am • #16
2 Featured Posts

Wow. Way to put a face on it. I do a lot of REO work, and I work very hard to keep in mind that these are not just listings for me, but they were homes for families.

On the other hand, and again, I do a lot of REO's, there is another segment of the market that I see. That is the investor, or the "thought I was an investor" who bought the house, rented it out (in my neighborhood) to a group of 10 construction workers who never cut their grass and leave trash all over the place and have 10-12 cars in the driveway. I don't feel as bad when I see those go down.

 

8:21am • #17
534,208 Points 52 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Hi Kris!  I hope I am not going off the deep end here on your blog.  I wrote about this when the last census numbers were released last Dec and talked about a "bubble implosion".  It is interesting to read the happenings in all the different markets.  Yours is prime example for my bubble implosion theory.

Yours has the human factor where mine is less human, unless you count humans that were renting from a speculator that got foreclosed on.  Which of course that counts:)  Luckily we still have the demand and people who have been renting and have been foreclosed on not once but two or three times are jumping into our buyer pool.  We also have investors realizing the demand and jumping into the buyer pool.

Unfortunately, in other places the jobs quite simply are not there.  I don't want to be accused of playing the "blame game" but I do believe it is our quest for cheap goods that drove us to this point.  I wish we could be more aware of what we are purchasing and consuming by simply looking at the tags of origination points.  I vote with my wallet and it is becoming so hard to vote with my wallet because, just like a lop sided two party system, the choices are not there.  Yesterday I had to attend a baby shower (husband forgot about it and I had three hour's notice.)  I got so mad while shopping and kept kicking myself in the butt because there was nothing for me to buy.  I don't WANT to buy stuff made out of this country AND more specifically I flat out refuse to buy Chinese goods. 

I wish I had more notice because about four years ago I bought about 40-50 vintage chenille bedspreads for the fabric only on EBay for this reason.  Even fabric these days is Chinese made.  I would have much rather hand crafted an heirloom with a fabric that was AMERICAN MADE and has lasted decades would LAST several more decades than attempt to purchase oh so cute non American made goods that probably won't even make it past a handful of washings

I am all for spreading the wealth from nation to nation but not at the expense of home grown jobs and human suffering.  I do believe NAFTA brought us here. 

:hopping over to Lola's blog now, thank you: 

8:40am • #18
258,669 Points 44 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Renee Parker:   I have spent more time in the past 2 years educating myself about our local government then I ever have.  I fully agree with you.  Thank you so much for stopping in to read and comment.

Kevin:  I give you credit.  I cannot do REO work (on the listing side)  It's too heartbreaking for me.  I agree - there are some neighborhoods that need to be cleaned up after the so called investors wreaked havoc, but for the most part our foreclosure neighborhoods are due to lack of jobs and the fallout from that.
8:53am • #19
258,669 Points 44 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Renee Burrows:    You are a breath of fresh air - don't ever worry about "going off the deep end" in one of my articles.  

There is SO much truth to what you say.  I cannot tell you how many real estate agents themselves have bought foreign cars in Metro Detroit.  Or the purchases of foreign goods.  I could write all day about the benefits of shopping at our local mom & pop stores, of taking the time to find and purchase American made products or of the appalling amount of money that has gone overseas to fight a "war" that didn't need to be fought. 

I've been following with interest your reports on the market in your area, they "whys" of it all and how you perceive the changes.  Once again you've reminded me that the foreclosure crisis is local as to the reasons behind it happening.  

Thank you Renee.  I know you'll enjoy Lolas article.

 

8:58am • #20
534,208 Points 52 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Kris:  Like you, I strive to shop at the mom and pops.  I hate crowds and Wally World gives me hives.  We have three Fords in our driveway and garage and wouldn't have it any different even though I get made fun of for driving an Exploder (my loving nickname for my car even though I LOVE it to death for it's reliability, knock on wood!)

There are so many "boutique" type American shops where goods are still handmade thanks to the internet, the middle man is cut out.  I encourage everyone to GOOGLE the Christmas gift giving item they are looking for and buy it from a fellow American merchant.  Hmmmmmmmmmmmmm think I may have a new blog post idea! 

9:08am • #21
9 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor

Kris,  I was emotionally involved with this family by paragraph 4. 

Yes, the foreclosure crisis is a local crisis.  It is happening across the country, but the reasons behind the crisis are often locally-driven.  I have had the unique experience of seeing two markets in crisis for the same "national" reason -- foreclosure.  We moved from San Diego to Kitsap County, Washington, a few months ago.  Two very different markets struggling with the same foreclosure issues, just on different scales and for different reasons.

I hope you get your star for this one, fantastic post that really makes it a very personal struggle.  Thanks!

1:08pm • #22
3 Featured Posts
Kris, I also suggested this be a featured post.  Great work
3:54pm • #23
195,145 Points 29 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Kris:  This is so sad...and unfortunately all too familiar. I see things like this happening all around me also. I know that things will get better...but how many families will lose everything before it gets better? Thanks for writing another great article! GBY!
10:34pm • #24
NOV
26
2007
258,669 Points 44 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Renee:  You're a girl after my own heart.   We also drive only American jobs cars, always have.  Thank you so much for supporting Ford.  I'm going to jog over to your blog and see if your post is there.  You are MUCH more eloquent than I am!

Marlene:  The truly sad part of this "story" is that there are thousands and thousands of Jones families.   Changing market areas as you have you do truly understand the local aspects to the national problem.  There isn't one "fix" that fits all. 

Gary Smith:  Thank you.  I'm glad you could stop by and read and meet the "Jones"

Elizabeth:  Are the foreclosures in your area primarily job loss driven? 
3:09am • #25
323,743 Points 40 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Kris--Your post could have been written about many many communities in the US besides Detroit, as many jobs have been lost in our country in a variety of industries. It is not just the job loss, there are the past enticements of equity loans. There are rising medical costs for those who are sick. There are a myriad of reasons and few solutions...Voting not only in elections but with our wallets gives ua a bit of power in these troubling times.  Good post!
8:39am • #26
Localism Sponsor

Kris - Great post, as a fellow MI Realtor, I see it all the time, it is so sad. I don't think some realize how bad it is, like you said, I see good hardworking people who've lost their jobs and their home fell into foreclosure. And I agree with you, I think the foreclosure rate in MI is mostly due to loss of jobs.

4:11pm • #27
165,064 Points 10 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

I guess this is just a "fair warning" message. I mentioned that you influenced me in one of my own blogs about the mortgage meltdown. It was somewhat edgy - so you can feel free to disavow what I wrote!!!  I'm seeing something a bit different around here. Middle class people using their homes for college tuition and because prices have gone through the roof but their salaries have not. They aren't in foreclosure, but their home WAS their retirement and if prices go way down, they are in for grinding poverty in old age. 

 I admit that I was annoyed about the posts - particularly ones that blithely said - oh these foreclosed people were "greedy" and "lazy" and they'll just have to rent for a while...thus the edginess.

6:14pm • #28
NOV
27
2007
258,669 Points 44 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Teri:  Sadly what you are saying is true.  Job losses have hit much of our country and with it the economic trickle down into home foreclosures.   I also agree about medical costs (and insurance.)  The increase in expenses surely isn't being met by an increase in income.

Mike:  I'm sure you're hearing and seeing the sad stories also.  I look forward to the days when job losses aren't quite an issue in our area.  I'm sure your consumers are also.

Ruthmarie:  Uh oh :-)  I better go on over to your blog and read the article you've written.  Thank you for letting me know about it!
5:10am • #29
NOV
28
2007
214,452 Points 16 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Kris, This is an excellent portrayal of the way things can unravel and lead to foreclosure.

The homeowner is often struck by things far beyond their control and I see it happening right across the USA (from where I sit in Canada) due to outsourcing jobs to other countries, corporations moving their plants to other countries where labour is cheaper, foreign goods being much more competitively priced than domestic goods hence domestic manufacturers suffering, etc.

Increasingly we are becoming a global economy however this does not bode well for the individual person who is NOT a global entity, but a citizen of a country, and if that country is suffering, then so will the individual citizen. Unless something drastic changes in government policy,I believe  things will only get worse.

Jo 

7:28am • #30
NOV
29
2007
258,669 Points 44 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Jo-Anne:  I found myself nodding my head up and down while reading your comment.  Thank you.  There are so many things happening that are out of the consumers control as you stated.   I'm a firm believer that we should take care of ours at home first, and buy home grown and manufactured products.  If we as a community do that then there will be plenty of income to help out worldwide afterwards.
6:28am • #31
NOV
30
2007

Kris - good thoughts in this post.  I do my best to remind people who ask me about the state of Michigan's economy that we are a manufacturing center in a country that has decided to get out of the manufacturing business.

Plus, it's a relief to read a story dealing with the "F" subject without hammering on brokers and lenders being responsible for every last one.

Thanks!

12:02am • #32
258,669 Points 44 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Ted:   Thank you. THANK YOU.   I couldn't have worded it more clearly than you did in your first paragraph.  I would love to see you write a post on what *you* are experiencing and seeing on an every day basis.  I also agree about the *F* subject and the medias hype with spreading blame and forgetting about those who are jobless through no fault of their own. 
4:13am • #33
DEC
05
2007
1 Featured Post Hit Router

Kris,  I should do a follow up story of up beat for all of us who have suffered in MI.  Kase was layed off (NO package at all and he was management level at Ford!) and he loves being out of automotive.  Would we ever buy a Ford again?  NO WAY.  I keep thinking they are firing their main customers, and thats the truth.  Kase (my hubby) is happily in his own company working on I.T. for Eastern European clients and LOVES his own company.

I hope many Michigan families can find happiness still HERE!  Your blog is great and oh so true!  Thank you. 

 

5:44pm • #34
DEC
06
2007
258,669 Points 44 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Karen:  I'm sorry to hear about what happened to Kase.  I've seen so much of it (blue collar and white collar) and have mixed thoughts about the domestic auto industry and their practices over the years.  I'm also sorry to hear that this stops you from buying another Ford product but can understand your frustration.  Thank YOU Karen for your input and personal story. 
4:37am • #35

Leave a response…



(optional)
What does the graphic say?
 
Kris Rainmaker_large

Kris Wales - Macomb County MI real estate blog & homes for sale search site

Macomb, MI

More about me…

Keller Williams Realty - Lakeside Market Center

Address: 45609 Village Blvd., Shelby Township, MI, 48315

Office Phone: (586) 536-5453

Email Me

A partner for your real estate
needs in Macomb County.


Looking for a full time real
estate professional with over
a decade of experience in
Macomb County MI and it's
surrounding areas?  

Feel free to get to know me and
how I conduct my business by
reading here and visiting
 Chataboutmacomb.com and
Macombhomes.com

I'm a firm believer that the best
real estate relationship is a
partnership. We work together
to achieve your goals - whether
it be in purchasing your first
home or selling your present
home to purchase another or
to relocate.

Please feel free to email me at
any time. I would enjoy chatting
with you and getting to know you.


Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find MI real estate agents and Macomb real estate on ActiveRain.