Members: 112,835 - 2,106 Online Now
 

This is one of those cases that involve more than one area of fraud and identity theft.  Additionally, it highlights the fact that you can be a victim when you least expect it and by whom least suspect.  It also shows how the elderly are prime targets for mortgage fraud and identity theft.

It involves a couple named Albert and Santa Basile, an elderly couple that seemed to do everything right.  The couple nevertheless has been plaqued by health issues within their family.  They had a loss of their 27-year old son and are now in poor health.  Their daughter, now 44, also is facing health problems.  Albert spent some time in the Army, and also spent over 60 years as a butcher, a trade he began in South Philly when he was just 12.  Albert has been diagnosed with Parkinson's disease.  They worked hard, rarely took vacations, and did everything they could to pay off their mortgage.

Now they have a new problem, one they never would have expected.  A long-time friend and neighbor of theirs, John Malampy, came to their rescue.  John had become like a brother to their daughter and promised them he would take care of her after the couple had passed on.  He would drive them where they needed to go and offered to help keep their bills in order after Albert couldn't write anymore.

Then the problems began.  John started diverting their Social Security and pension checks after they were deposited.  He then transferred $21,000 from their home equity loan into his personal account.  As if that was not enough, he convinced them to raise the loan to $100,000 and stole that money as well.

After several months, the couple started receiving calls about unpaid bills and threats to cut off utilities.  When they asked John why they were receiving the calls, he stated that not to worry, they had, in fact, been paid.

After nearly a year, the trusting couple finally had another family member look into the persistent phone calls.  The truth finally came out and it truly devastated the couple, both financially and emotionally.

John immediately confessed, telling police he used the money for bills, stores, beach outings, and other usual stuff.  He immediately plead guilty to identity theft, theft by deception, and forgery.  All he has received so far is a sentence for probation and restitution.

Now here is a lesson that we all must learn from this.  You would think that since the couple can prove they were a victim of identity theft and mortgage fraud they should be able to avoid the payments and pick up where they were before, right?  Not so.  In fact they law is against you in this case. 

It actually states that even if you can prove it was a thief that did this, if you have not sent a letter that arrives at the creditor within 60 days, you are fully responsible for the charges, regardless!  So, there story continues. 

Wachovia Bank demanded that the couple be held responsible despite their ability to prove fraud.  The bank pressed form months with contentious foreclosure proceedings. The bank would likely win the case since the couple did not make the required notification per the law.  However, due to the bad publicity received by local newspapers, the bank has reversed its course and is no longer after the couple for the stolen funds. 

Others have not been as fortunate.

 
Post is included in group: Identity Theft and Mortgage Fraud

13 Comments on Betrayal by Trusted Friend and Neighbor

Wow..what a story! Those poor folks trusting that guy to take care of them instead he took them!!!

12/21/2006 10:09 AM by Monika McGillicuddy~REALTOR®~ N.H. Real Estate Broker & Trainer (Prudential Verani Realty/Hampstead)


Wachovia mean Walk all over ya!  at least that is what they say in my neck of the woods.  Im glad in this case that was not what happened.

12/21/2006 10:15 AM by Marci Toliver, Anderson, SC/ Spartanburg/Greenville SC/ Home Staging (First Impressions)


Man -you just don't know who to trust these days!

12/21/2006 11:37 AM by Brian Foxworth (Palmetto South Mortgage )


Monika...Sad story to say the least and probably happens more often than really gets reported.  Fortunately their situation did not end up as the worst case scenario.  Thanks for the comment.

Marci...I have not heard that about Wachovia, not surprised to hear it though.  Thanks for the comment.

Brian...You don't know who to trust, but there are fairly simple precautions they could have taken to prevent a lot of this.

12/21/2006 12:09 PM by Robert D. Ashby, CMPS - Solid Rock Mortgage Corporation


I'm always amazed that people are amazed when crime is committed by someone the victim knows. I recall reading somewhere that more than 70% of children that are molested are victimized by a family member or close family friend. If we are to believe the newspeople, the remaining 30% are assaulted by clergy, swim team coaches and Senators.

Therefore, I do not let my kids join athletic teams, attend church, vote, nor do we have any friends. In fact, we moved thousands of miles away from all family and told the kids their grandparents, cousins and other family all sank on a cruise ship that we were too poor to attend.

The reality Robert is that at some point people must be accountable for their own, sometimes misguided and dumb, actions. They were in financial trouble and sought help from what they considered to be a trustworthy source. I understand Albert couldn't write the checks and pay bills easily any longer but certainly he could read his bank statement. While I feel tremendous pity for these folks, there is responsibility to pay your debts. You can't just hand everything over to someone else INCLUDING the accountability. It just doesn't work that way.

The neighbor/friend is a slime and will have to answer for his actions on judgement day. That's between him and God and God ain't gonna think this was a great thing he did. But I hold back from thinking all of these couple's creditors should write off the debt as uncollectable because the couple didn't bother to check the statements for what sounds like a long time.

But, hey, it's Christmas....where can I send them money to help out? Is there a fund setup?

12/21/2006 11:33 PM by Ken Stampe | Wells Fargo | Mortgage Loan Dallas .com (Ken Stampe | Wells Fargo Home Mortgage))


Robert,

I'd have to agree with Ken on this one.  How do you allow a neighbor to do this for over a year!!  They'd know that bills were not being paid after a month or two.  I don't know too many mortgage companies or credit card companies that waite 5 days after your deliquent to pound you into submission, let alone a year.

12/22/2006 01:14 AM by Karl Christen Utah Mortgages~Mortgage Planning Expert (Envision Lending Group)


Ken...I wholeheartedly agree that we must be accountable for our own actions (or lack thereof). 

The point I was trying to make here is twofold in relation to protecting yourself, though I left it somewhat buried in the details.  Their case did not start as financial problems, it was solely health related.  Their financial problems started when their thwarted their financial responsiblity by handing it over to their friend.  I can understand why they took their friend's help, but like you said, they needed to maintain supervision for their own protection.  So the point to be made here was, no matter who you trust to handle this type of assistance, you never should delegate the entire responsibility out of your control.

The second part is more in relation to what the law states, which fortunately Wachovia backed off from.  That is the part about them being responsible for the amount due on the accounts.  In financial Identity Theft (or fraud), the law states "If an identity thief changed the address on your account and you didn't receive the bill, your dispute letter still must reach the creditor within 60 days of when the creditor would have mailed the bill. This is one reason it's essential to keep track of your billing statements, and follow up quickly if your bills don't arrive on time."  The translation to this is that if your letter is not on the creditor's desk within 60 days, regardless of proof that you are a victiom or not, you are responsible for the full amount due.  I don't think many readers realize this fact.

Thanks for the comment and remarks.  I agree with what you are saying and there is some good advice in there for those reading this post.

12/22/2006 07:25 AM by Robert D. Ashby, CMPS - Solid Rock Mortgage Corporation


Karl...I didn't want to leave you out either.  I appreciate your comment as well.  While it is surprising they let it go this long, their creditors had been after them for a while, including sending them into foreclosure.  I am not sure how close they were to actually losing their home, but I imagine it wasn't very far away.

12/22/2006 07:29 AM by Robert D. Ashby, CMPS - Solid Rock Mortgage Corporation


Your point about the 60 days is very informative. Have you looked into the identy shield protection offered by Pre-paid Legal? I have all the stuff but haven't read any of it, so I was hoping I could get away with personal laziness and see if someone else has reviewed the same material :)

They suggest that in the case of identity theft they will represent you and restore your credit, etc. I wonder if clauses like the 60 day notification are true barriers or only soft barriers requiring legal counsel to jump over. If so, it means those who are poor (or made poor by identity theft) will have less chance at a fair remedy.

Ken

12/22/2006 08:37 AM by Ken Stampe | Wells Fargo | Mortgage Loan Dallas .com (Ken Stampe | Wells Fargo Home Mortgage))


Ken,

Actually, I have incorporated Pre-Paid Legal into my business as an added value service.  Their Identity Theft Shield is, hands down, the best product available to combat identity theft and protect yourself.  I don't know of another service that actually downloads the change of address forms everyday.

Regarding the shield and the 60 day rule, part of the shield service is credit monitoring, so it should catch it quickly.  The free annual credit reports your are entitled to allow you to pull one report from each bureau each year.  Since you do not have to do them all at the same time, I suggest pulling one from one bureau every 4 months.  That gets them all covered once a year and since most credit issues are reported to all three bureaus, you are in essence checking your credit every 4 months.  Just added protection for yourself.

The 60 day rule is a true barrier, however you are much more likely to break that barrier with legal assistance.  PPL's product covers that cost and is a resoration service, not just insurance.  PPL's product also does the work for you, saving you hundreds of hours of time.

We all need to be protected and do all we can to minimize the threat of identity theft.  If anyone wants more info on PPL's Identity Theft Shield or any of their other products, please visit www.idtheftxpert.com.

Thanks again for your contributions Ken.

12/22/2006 09:06 AM by Robert D. Ashby, CMPS - Solid Rock Mortgage Corporation


We wish you a merry Christmas! We wish you a merry Christmas! We wish you a merry Christmas And a happy New Year! Glad tidings we bring To you and your kin! Glad tidings for Christmas And a happy New Year!

Broker Bryant and The Lovely Wife (pretend we are singing it works better like that) ROAR!

12/23/2006 08:00 PM by "The Lovely Wife"...Broker Bryant's Wife... (Co-Owner Tutas Towne Realty, Inc.)


TLW,

Thanks for stopping by to wish everyone a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year!

12/26/2006 10:28 AM by Robert D. Ashby, CMPS - Solid Rock Mortgage Corporation


This blog does not allow anonymous comments

 
Mortgage Company: Robert D.  Ashby, CMPS - Solid Rock Mortgage Corporation
Florida's #1 Mortgage Planner
Pembroke Pines, FL
More about me…
Robert D. Ashby, CMPS - Solid Rock Mortgage Corporation

Office Phone: (954) 432-3450
Email Me
Florida Mortgage Specialist provides "thought provoking" topics and strategies for proper mortgage planning. MEDS™ is a unique mortgage process that properly integrates your mortgage into your financial plan.

Media Relations




Discover How to Legally, Morally and Ethically Cut Your Taxes in Half...

Click to get a FREE business book summary!






Real Estate Blogs - Blog Top Sites
Blog Directory Top Blogs


Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog
ATOM 1.0 Feed for this blog

Find FL real estate agents and Pembroke Pines real estate here on ActiveRain.
Disclaimer: ActiveRain Corp. does not necessarily endorse the real estate agents, loan officers and brokers listed on this site. These real estate profiles, blogs and blog entries are provided here as a courtesy to our visitors to help them make an informed decision when buying or selling a house. ActiveRain Corp. takes no responsibility for the content in these profiles, that are written by the members of this community.
© 2007 ActiveRain Corp. All Rights Reserved