No shoppersYou may have heard of the Alan Greenspan "briefcase indicator" which suggests whether the discount rate is going higher, lower or staying the same based on which briefcase he walks into the Federal Reserve meeting with (or how full it is).  At Angelic, we have our own indicator, what we see out our windows overlooking Michigan Avenue.  Lately, it's been a not-so-good story for retail sales, and that, in turn, should hold interest rates down.

Most mortgage brokers have been seeing a boom in refinancings lately, but they also see a potential end to that boom in the very near term.  Rates are anticipated to rise in 2007, bad news for mortgage brokers, even worse news for REALTORS hoping the housing market is going to pick up from a down year in 2006.  Higher interest rates help hold down the property market as monthly payments rise for the same given price of a home, making homes less affordable at the same price point and often driving buyers out of the market or to lower price points. 

That said, the NAR recently issued a report entitled something like "Now is the Time to Buy" based on the combination of low interest rates (currently the lowest in nearly a year and still near 45 year lows) and the depressed asking prices for homes on the market. 

As Enoch looks out our windows over Michigan Avenue and Rush Street, there really hasn't been much for him to see the past week, when normally it should be mobbed with shoppers rushing around in advance of the Christmas holiday.  Even if not before the 25th, certainly for today, the largest shopping day of the year to return things and one of the largest to buy (since everything is now on after-Christmas sale) it's quite bleak out there.  I just took the photo of Michigan Avenue and Rush Street, the heart of Chicago shopping, a few minutes ago, and it's been like this for days - plenty of cars, but not many people on the sidewalks (sorry for the glare, it's finally nice and sunny). 

According to MSNBC's recently released report on the day's trading, bond prices ticked higher (lowering interest rates) and early reports from MasterCard show a 6.6% rise in year-over-year sales between Thanksgiving and Christmas, whereas last year's holiday shopping season saw an 8.7% rise over two years ago, and that wasn't considered a fantastic year.

If this continues, I would expect that market concerns over higher interest rates coming soon might cool off, lowering interest rates a little and holding them for a while longer.  Maybe the NAR was right - now IS the time to buy.

 

4 Comments on The Michigan Avenue Penthouse View Indicator Says Mortgage Rates Hold Off on Increasing...

DEC
26
2006
609,143 Points 244 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Wow great view Gabriel! Home values in my market are declining quickly and still young working class families cannot afford to buy. Most of the folks in my area have service related jobs and with 2 parents working still make less than $50,000 a year. A starter house is about $185,000. Purchasing these with no money down, cost them about $1,600 to $1,800 a month PITI. They can rent the same house for $900 a month. Purchasing does not make any sense for them unless they can count on good appreciation, which they can't.  So it will be interesting to see what happens in 2007. My prediction is values will continue to decrease in my area.

Are the top end properties affected as much by interest rates? Or do you have a lot of cash purchasers?

4:32pm • #1
13 Featured Posts

Top end properties are not effected quite the same way, but they are effected.  There aren't necessarily cash purchasers (hey, a $2MM home is expensive to a lot of rich people, too!).  The higher price points seem to have higher price swings.  When the market is great, they go up faster, when the market is down they fall further.  It is surprising to most people how much debt the "rich" tend to have.  I haven't seen foreclosure lists with $2MM homes very often, but I certainly see plenty of $500K homes on those lists. 

There was a seller in our building earlier this year that had a great place, purchased for $500K two years ago, with $70K in upgrades and enhancements since, who was selling out of some desperation because she lost her job and couldn't stay afloat without selling. 

At a recent closing for a $900K home I was shocked to see the seller only walk away with $28K...and that was after he cut out his broker, who is after him for $45K now (which I think they will get, meaning he's underwater by over $15,000!).  He'd owned the place for over three years, with decent appreciation in the area, yet he was so leveraged the only way he took a check home from the close was breaking his contract with his listing broker, who we support fully in getting paid.

4:49pm • #2
110,135 Points 26 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

That last story is sad, and speaks volumes about over leveraging. I hope people wake up about that. Back to the shopping: I was at a gathering on Christmas Eve and my friend's daughter works at the local mall. I said 'so I bet it was crazy busy today.' and she said 'no it was pretty dead.' I said, 'yesterday?' she said 'same thing.' Surprised me. And this Mall, historically, is very active during the Holidays and in a solidly middle class area.

 

8:27pm • #3
13 Featured Posts
So Carole's Cleveland Cohort's index reads the same as our Magnificent Mile Measure!
8:33pm • #4

Leave a response…



(optional)
What does the graphic say?
 
Dsc_0006 Rainmaker_large

Gabriel Silverstein, SIOR

Manhattan, NY

More about me…

Angelic Real Estate

Address: 100 East Huron Street, Suite 4904, Chicago, IL, 60611

Office Phone: (212) 444-8520

Cell Phone: (646) 727-0837

Email Me

This blog is where I explore, comment on and even rant about industry issues for commercial and corporate real estate professionals and occasionally throw out thoughts on the residential side of the world as well (why, since we don't deal with residential? I guess because nobody can stop us from doing so and as this latest subprime-primed recession proves, housing matters even if you're not a house jockey).


Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find NY real estate agents and Manhattan real estate on ActiveRain.